Share this @internewscast.com
Australia can reclaim a proposed Russian embassy site but will need to compensate the authoritarian state for cancelling its lease on the land.
In 2023, Australia quickly passed laws to cancel Russia’s lease on a plot of land where it planned to build an embassy a few hundred metres from Parliament House in Canberra.
The government claimed the site could pose a threat to national security.
Russia described the cancellation of the 99-year lease, which was granted by the Australian government in 2008, as a hostile action amounting to “Russophobic hysteria”.
It took the fight to the High Court, arguing the laws were unconstitutional and there was no evidence the embassy posed a national security threat.
The High Court on Wednesday ruled in the federal government’s favour, finding the laws were valid.

In a recent ruling, Russia has been granted the right to receive compensation, with the stipulation that the Australian government must cover half of Russia’s legal expenses. This decision follows a standoff involving a plot of land where construction was halted.

An empty block of land with a small white demountable building on it. A temporary chain link fence with a sign saying the land belongs to the Commonwealth of Australia.

Despite no developments having been completed on the site, a Russian official took up residence there, effectively thwarting any Australian attempts to reclaim the land. This bold move was intended to challenge the Australian government’s authority over the plot.

The situation has drawn parallels with hypothetical scenarios, such as one involving an army barracks. In such cases, the Commonwealth can rightfully acquire adjacent land to ensure security. However, it is noted that compensation should still be provided to the landowners.

Top lawyer Bret Walker SC, representing Russia, previously argued it was offensive to assume people would willingly give up their property without compensation because national security grounds were invoked.

Previously, Donaghue argued before the High Court that a nation should not receive compensation for issues they have caused themselves. This sentiment reflects the ongoing complexities in international land disputes and the responsibilities of governments in addressing such challenges.

Solicitor-General Stephen Donaghue argued the government had the power and authority to make laws stripping the Russians of their lease.
The Commonwealth also relied on “specific advice” about the nature of the construction that was planned and the capacity the site’s location would provide the Russian mission.
The advice from ASIO was not detailed in court due to public interest immunity protections.

Compensation should not be paid to a nation “for problems they cause themselves”, Donaghue told the High Court previously.

Walker said it was “really disturbing” to propose the taking of land without compensation on preemptive national security grounds where no explicit threat had been proven.
He said such a precedent was absurd and would mean “everyone is to be regarded, until proven otherwise, a terrorist threat”.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Man kept alive for 48 hours with lungs removed

Man Sustained for 48 Hours Following Lung Removal Procedure

Surgeons in the US managed to keep a man alive for 48…
'Cold shower' for mortgage holders: Experts' gloomy rates' forecast

Experts Predict Challenging Outlook for Mortgage Holders with Anticipated Rate Increases

Australian mortgage holders are bracing for the possibility of an interest rate…

Greenland Mayor Raises Alarm Over Controversial US Flag Display

The mayor of Greenland’s capital urged members of the media and content…
'Absolutely crazy': Scary fire damages property in Perth

Intense Blaze Causes Significant Property Damage in Perth

A fierce fire has damaged property in Perth’s north-east and left residents…
NSW Premier Chris Minns insisted he would only move ahead with the proposal of an extra Anzac Day public holiday with the blessing of the RSL.

Potential New Public Holiday in NSW: Government Considers Extra Day Off for 2023

Those in NSW could be given an extra day off this year…
Alex Pretti filmed interacting with federal agents days before shooting

Newly Released Footage Reveals Tense Confrontation Between Alex Pretti and ICE Prior to Fatal Shooting

Warning: This story contains images and details that may be distressing to…
Olivia Stiles' paper permit used to allow her to park outside her home for free.

New Council Regulation Introduces Residential Parking Fees for Australians

Exclusive: For the past seven years, Olivia Stiles has enjoyed the convenience…

Minnesota Border Agents on Administrative Leave Following Fatal Shooting Incident

Two immigration officers involved in the fatal shooting of a protester in…

Trump Urges Iran to Act Quickly on Nuclear Deal as US Military Presence Grows

U.S. President Donald Trump has issued a stern warning to Iran, emphasizing…
What goes into a terrorism declaration? Questions arise after Perth bomb attack

Unraveling the Complexities: How Authorities Determine a Terrorism Declaration After the Perth Bomb Attack

It took police more than 48 hours to announce it was investigating…
Scarlett Hack.

Scarlett’s Journey: From Breathing Difficulties to Life Support

At the tender age of 10, Scarlett Hack began to experience troubling…
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA - NOVEMBER 27: A packed Bondi Beach at sunrise on November 27, 2024 in Sydney, Australia. Some Australians experienced temperatures of 40 degrees plus last weekend.

Unmasking the Silent Killer: Urgent Call to Action as Threat Grows in Australia

A politician’s provocative campaign has reignited the debate to name heatwaves like…