Despite confessing to the gruesome murders of two women, Wade Wilson—dubbed the “Deadpool Killer”—has bizarrely attracted a cult-like following. This strange phenomenon has seen hundreds of women express their loyalty to him.
“I’ve reported on many criminals and violent offenders, but the fascination surrounding Wilson is extraordinary,” remarked Brian Ross, the co-director and producer of the documentary “Handsome Devil: Charming Killer,” in an interview with Fox News Digital.
“Wilson managed to captivate hundreds of women who fell for him, expressed a desire to marry him, and even considered having his children,” Ross explained. “They were aware of the horrific details of his crimes, yet this infatuation persisted, warranting a closer examination. The more we investigated, the more bizarre it became.”
Appearing in court on July 19, 2024, Wade Wilson was convicted of the brutal murders of two women in Cape Coral back in 2019. (© Ricardo Rolon/USA TODAY NETWORK-FLORIDA/USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images)
The true crime documentary on Paramount+ delves into the story of the 31-year-old whose name coincidentally matches a famous Marvel Comics character. The film features fresh interviews with Wilson’s former partners, his father, and law enforcement officials.
On October 7, 2019, Wilson strangled 35-year-old Kristine Melton as she slept after they met in a bar the previous night. Later that same day, he brutally attacked, strangled, and ran over 43-year-old Diane Ruiz with his car after encountering her on the street. Wilson was apprehended on October 8, 2019, following a series of confessions made during phone calls with his father.
Kristine Melton (left) and Diane Ruiz were murdered on Oct. 7, 2019. (Lee County DA Office/Paramount+)
“These were both very well-loved women,” co-director and producer Rhonda Schwartz told Fox News Digital.
Wade Wilson is seen here speaking with one of his then-girlfriends, Alexis Williams. (Alexis Williams/Paramount+)
“Kristine had moved to Florida to be near her family. She had a close circle of friends dating back to childhood. She was known for her loving family. Diane Ruiz was also cherished by her children and co-workers. When she went missing, they searched tirelessly for her, raising awareness in hopes of finding her.”
“These were almost accidental encounters,” Schwartz added.
Dr. Mark Rubino, a neurologist, testified for the defense and then Dr. Thomas Coyne took the stand on behalf of the state. He is a neuropathologist and an associate medical examiner. (© Andrew West/The News-Press/USA Today Network / USA TODAY NETWORK)
Wilson’s mugshot exploded across social media, sparking a wave of online fixation as many women openly romanticized his looks. That obsession intensified when he appeared in court dressed in colorful suits with his hair slicked back, turning the legal proceedings into a viral spectacle.
Wade Wilson enters the courtroom during his murder trial at Lee County Courthouse in Fort Myers on June 20, 2024. (© Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
His appearance drew widespread attention for its severity — his head and face were heavily tattooed, including swastikas etched on both and a grotesque, stitched-on smile inked around his mouth.
An intense fan base developed on social media, specifically TikTok. Wilson basked in the attention, fielding a steady stream of jailhouse calls from ghoulish groupies, known as “Wade’s Wives” who fawned over his voice and looks. One woman demanded “marathon sex,” while another pleaded for him to impregnate her.
Wade Wilson confessed his crimes to his father, who then alerted the authorities. (Cape Coral Police Department/Paramount+)
“What these women described to us was that in these phone calls, he made them laugh,” Ross explained.
A prison letter from Wade Wilson to Alexis Williams. (Alexis Williams/Paramount+)
“He told them he loved them. And these were women who weren’t always on the market looking for men. Criminologists we spoke to say that sometimes these women who themselves have been victims of abuse are attracted to men like Wade Wilson because they can have a conversation with him, but it’s safe because they know he’s behind bars and can’t hurt them.”
A picture of Kristine Melton is displayed for the jury during the penalty phase of Wade Wilson’s murder trial at the Lee County Courthouse in Fort Myers on June 25, 2024. (© Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
Ross said that at one point, Wilson received about $100K through a fundraising site created by a supporter, as many women rushed to send him money. While they claimed the funds would help pay his lawyers, Wilson splurged on pizza and chocolate bars, Ross said. During his years behind bars, Wilson received hundreds of love letters and explicit photos.
“He always asked them for money,” Ross said. “While he was buying snacks at the jail, other women talked about how they couldn’t wait to have his children.”
Alexis Williams shows off her tattoo dedicated to Wade Wilson. (CBS/Paramount+)
“One woman who spoke with us, who swooned over him, used her own money to buy suits, shirts and ties so he could appear in court,” Ross said.
“She even bought makeup for him to try covering the tattoos on his face. It didn’t really work, so he appeared barefaced during the trial, and we saw all the tattoos. But these women were devoted to him — some still are, frankly.”
A photo of Diane Ruiz is displayed during the penalty phase of Wade Wilson’s murder trial at the Lee County Courthouse in Fort Myers on June 25, 2024. (© Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
Both the crimes and the disturbing fandom left prosecutors horrified, Ross said.
Mila Montanez, one of Wade Wilson’s ex-girlfriends, described in the documentary how she was physically abused by him. (CBS/Paramount+)
“It’s hard to know what drove him to kill,” Ross admitted. “He’s given several different explanations, including that he just wanted to, which is hard to fathom, but that’s what he told the detectives. His girlfriend, Mila, was aware that when he took drugs, he got crazy. But deep down, this is a cold-blooded killer who was handsome and had the gift of gab. That became his downfall.”
Schwartz said that even today, many loved ones still wonder what went wrong with Wilson.
Wade Wilson was found guilty on two counts of first degree murder, grand theft of a motor vehicle, battery, burglary of a dwelling and first degree petit theft in Lee County, Florida in June 2024. (Lee County Sheriff’s Office)
“I think so many have tried to figure that out,” she said. “His defense attorneys did their best to present a strong case. They even examined whether neurological damage played a role. Early in his life, he was in and out of trouble. Many who encountered Wade Wilson over the years felt his charm and wanted to help him. His girlfriends often said, ‘I thought I could be the one to fix him.’”
Wade Wilson was in and out of juvenile detention before committing the murders. (Chelsea Bianco/Paramount+)
Those who knew Wilson said his demeanor could change without warning, turning hostile and threatening — even toward the women who pledged loyalty to him.
“The women who were around him and at one point loved him, they talked about how they fell in love with his eyes, but there’d be a time when those eyes turned dark,” Ross explained.
Mila Montanez described her ex-boyfriend Wade Wilson as having “serial killer eyes.” (CBS/Paramount+)
“Mila called them ‘serial killer eyes,’” Ross shared. “He didn’t seem to show much remorse for what he did. Even in prison, we wanted to talk to him — and he agreed. But because he was such a bad prisoner and always on disciplinary status, he was denied access to any outside media. So, we never got to talk to him.”
GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB
Wade Wilson sits in the courtroom during the penalty phase of his murder trial at the Lee County Courthouse in Fort Myers on June 25, 2024. The jury recommended the death penalty for Wilson. (© Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
“What was in his head? He said he became the devil. He thinks of ‘kill, kill, murder, murder, murder.’ Those are his words.”
In June 2024, Wilson was convicted of killing Melton and Ruiz. He was sentenced to death in August of that year.
A close-up of Wade Wilson’s facial tattoos. (Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
The Lee County Sheriff’s Office told Newsweek that Wilson received 3,903 messages between June 12, 2024 — the day he was convicted — and July 12 of that year. According to the outlet, he also received 65 letters and 754 photos, with 163 rejected for being “inappropriate in nature.”
Assistant state attorney Sara Miller places photos for the jury to see during the penalty phase of Wade Wilson’s murder trial at the Lee County Courthouse in Fort Myers on June 25, 2024. (© Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
Florida state attorneys condemned his supporters.
“I’ve been doing this a very long time, 34 years, and I have to say that I have never seen someone as evil as Wade Wilson,” Amira Fox, state attorney for the 20th Judicial Circuit of Florida, announced to the press after Wilson was sentenced to death.
Zane Romero, 19, the youngest son of Diane Ruiz, testifies during the penalty phase of Wade Wilson’s murder trial at the Lee County Courthouse in Fort Myers on June 24, 2024. (© Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
“And I have never been so stunned as to see some people in the community that actually think it’s a good idea to support somebody that evil and monstrous,” she added.
Wade Wilson was sentenced to death in August 2024. (© Jonah Hinebaugh/Naples Daily News/USA Today Network-Florida/USA TODAY NETWORK)
Today, Ross said the online portrayal of Wilson as “chiseled” has faded. In recent prison photos, he appears bloated and disheveled, with several teeth missing.
“These horrific crimes have left a deep scar on the victims’ loved ones and the community,” Ross said. “He’s on death row in isolation with little outside contact. He’s appealing his death sentence, but he’ll be there for life — he’ll leave in a coffin.”
“Handsome Devil: Charming Killer” is now streaming on Paramount+.
