Fox News True Crime Newsletter: Nancy Guthrie's evidence, Ohio teacher's murder, 'Deadpool Killer's' loyalty

The United Cajun Navy, a renowned volunteer search and rescue organization, is ready to adjust its search strategy for Nancy Guthrie to meet the requirements of local officials. This proactive step highlights the group’s commitment to collaboration and thoroughness in their mission.

Concurrently, an independent journalist has initiated a petition urging Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos to endorse the group’s efforts. This appeal reflects the community’s eagerness to see progress in the search for Guthrie.

“We seek permission from the lead agency,” expressed Josh Gill, an incident commander with the United Cajun Navy. Gill was present in Tucson, Arizona, in February, poised to begin the search but hindered by lack of authorization. “I believe our involvement could bring a step closer to closure, not only for the family and community but for the entire nation,” he added.

Nancy Guthrie's photo overlayed with images of investigators

Nancy Guthrie vanished from her Tucson home on Sunday, February 1, 2026, following a dinner at her daughter’s nearby residence. Her disappearance has drawn significant attention, partly due to her daughter, Savannah Guthrie, who is co-host of NBC’s “Today” show.

Josh Gill submitted a comprehensive 41-page search plan to the sheriff’s department shortly after Guthrie’s suspected abduction. The plan emphasizes that the United Cajun Navy would operate under the direct command of the sheriff, ensuring coordinated and controlled efforts.

According to the 41-page document, the UCN would have no independent authority and operate under the sheriff’s command.

Read the plan:

“We have not been contacted on the plan that we provided,” Gill told Fox News Digital. “I’m open to developing a new plan with law enforcement.”

Fragments of surveillance video show a masked man at her front door, where blood drops were found the following morning. Her back door had been propped open. No valuables were taken. Although the family offered to pay a ransom demand in the early days of the investigation, Guthrie has not been returned.

Investigators standing at the entrance of Nancy Guthrie's home in Tucson, Arizona

Investigators stand in the entrance to the home of Nancy Guthrie in Tucson, Ariz., Wednesday, February 25, 2026. (Kat Ramirez for Fox News Digital)

Last week, authorities revealed that a hair sample was found inside the home and has been sent from a private DNA lab in Florida to the FBI for more advanced testing.

The initial plan called for the use of certified cadaver dogs over land in around local bodies of water, a tracking dog trained to find specific scents, heat-detecting drones and GPS-tracked volunteers for a grid search from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. daily.

People searching for clues in the Nancy Guthrie case in Tucson, Arizona

People conduct an unofficial search flr clues in the Nancy Guthrie case, Tucson, Arizona, Sunday, February 22, 2026. Guthrie was last seen alive at the end of January. (Kat Ramirez/Fox News Digital)

The plan even included volunteer EMTs on standby in case any searchers suffered injuries from the terrain or sun and heat.

Gill said the group had also proposed deferring all media inquiries to the Pima County Sheriff’s Department.

“We’ve got some of the best and brightest, and our network is huge,” he told Fox News Digital. “Let us work [with the sheriff’s department] to do what’s best.”

Savannah Guthrie standing on the Today show set at Rockefeller Plaza in New York

Savannah Guthrie visits the Today show at Rockefeller Plaza in New York on Thursday, March 5, 2026. (Charles Sykes/Invision/AP)

He proposed searching the desert outside town, many drainage ditches known as “washes” in the area, a series of “remote access areas” and abandoned structures. Searchers were preparing for harsh conditions including extreme heat, wildlife hazards, uneven terrain and dark nights due to local ordinances designed at limiting light pollution.

According to the plan, if volunteer searchers find any evidence they would not handle it and report it to the sheriff’s department.

Savannah Guthrie standing next to her mother Nancy Guthrie at Sydney Opera House.

Australian-born presenter, Savannah Guthrie poses alongside her mother Nancy Guthrie during a production break whilst hosting NBC’s “Today Show” live from Australia at Sydney Opera House on May 4, 2015 in Sydney, Australia. (Don Arnold/WireImage)

UCN has submitted similar plans for other searches to law enforcement agencies around the country.

Cherise “Pebbles” Wilson, an independent journalist who focuses on missing persons and human trafficking cases, is behind a Change.org petition calling on PCSD to accept Gill’s plan.

“I lost my vulnerable grandmother a couple of years ago, and Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance pulled at my heartstrings,” she told Fox News Digital. “Knowing that somebody took advantage of a loving lady, an elderly lady like that, is really disturbing.”

<!–>

–>

You May Also Like

Los Angeles County issues beach water contamination advisory after heavy rain

Los Angeles County Issues Beach Water Contamination Alert After Rain

Los Angeles County health officials are urging residents to avoid local beaches…
MICHAEL RUIZ: Montauk bikini designer's $50M yacht death lawsuit frozen as owner asks judge for exoneration

Michael Ruiz Yacht Death Lawsuit Paused as Owner Seeks Exoneration in $50M Claim

The family of an Irish bikini designer found dead aboard a luxury…
At least 100 people pulled from Mississippi River after New Orleans ship crash as lengthy salvage effort looms

Over 100 Pulled From Mississippi River After New Orleans Ship Crash

About 100 people were rescued from the Mississippi River after a tanker…
Chinese fraudster in viral video sentenced for $27M elderly scam

Chinese Fraudster in Viral Video Sentenced Over $27M Elderly Scam

A Chinese national who helped steal $27 million from roughly 2,000 elderly…
White House Correspondents' Association dinner shooting suspect charged with terrorism

White House Correspondents’ Dinner Shooting Suspect Charged With Terrorism

The Department of Justice has filed an additional terrorism charge against the…
SpaceX recovers Starship with giant tower arms in historic first

SpaceX Recovers Starship Using Giant Launch Tower Arms in Historic First

This catch belongs on SportsCenter. SpaceX’s Starship returned from more than 22…
King Charles jokes about aging with Elton John in birthday podcast appearance

King Charles Jokes About Aging With Elton John on Birthday Podcast

King Charles III marked his 78th birthday with a special appearance on…
Sexual predator deported to Mexico hauled back to US for assault and murder of American mom

Sex Offender Deported to Mexico Charged in U.S. Mom’s Assault, Murder

A Mexican serial rapist who murdered an American woman more than two…
Rare sea turtle hatchlings make history on Southern California coast

Rare Sea Turtle Hatchlings Make History on California’s South Coast

California’s newest beachgoers are tiny enough to fit in a handful, yet…
Hundreds gather to remember 'loving' young construction worker killed in Brooklyn building collapse: 'He was always smiling'

Hundreds Honor Beloved Young Construction Worker Killed in Brooklyn Building Collapse

Gabriel Siguencia, one of the construction workers killed in Wednesday’s Brooklyn building…
Elk Grove man gets life without parole for murdering parents over inheritance

Elk Grove Man Gets Life Without Parole in Parents’ Inheritance Murders

A California man who killed his parents to secure their money—and later…
FAA Ground Stop Leaves College Football Teams Scrambling to Reach Saturday Games

FAA Ground Stop Scrambles College Football Teams Before Saturday Games

The Arizona State Sun Devils delayed their flight to Orlando until Saturday…