The fate of a contentious research facility in Oregon, long criticized for its use of monkeys in experiments, may soon shift towards becoming a sanctuary for primates.
Last week, discussions were initiated by the Oregon Health and Science University to determine the future of the Oregon National Primate Research Center. The facility has drawn significant criticism from animal rights advocates who have consistently demanded its closure, citing allegations of animal mistreatment.
Situated in Hillsboro, the center houses approximately 5,000 monkeys and employs 267 staff members, making it the largest among the seven primate research centers in the United States that receive federal support, as reported by Oregon Live.
In the wake of stalled merger talks with Legacy Health, legislative pressure has increased for the center to cease its research activities.
Earlier this year, in February, the OHSU board voted to encourage President Dr. Shereef Elnahal to transition the center into a sanctuary for the monkeys. At a recent OHSU Faculty Senate meeting, Elnahal emphasized that this transformation would only proceed with adequate funding, according to reports.
Dr. Elnahal stated that without federal funding from Congress, estimated between $220 million and $290 million, the sanctuary plan would not move forward, as noted by Oregon Live.
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) announced in February that the vote for the center to end experiments on monkeys was a ‘colossal win for monkeys and science.’
PETA Senior Vice President Kathy Guillermo told the Daily Mail, however, that the center should be funding the sanctuary, not the government.
‘[The center] has profited from these monkeys for the last 60 years. They’ve taken in millions and millions of dollars to experiment on them,’ she said. ‘…if it can be transitioned to a sanctuary that meets the standards of the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries, we would be all in favor of that.’
The Oregon Health and Science University began talks last week to decide the fate of the Oregon National Primate Research Center
The center in Hillsboro is home to around 5,000 monkeys and 267 employees and stands as the largest of the seven federally supported primate research centers
PETA Senior Vice President Kathy Guillermo said the center conducts experiments that are ‘more the stuff of nightmare than the stuff of science’ and believes it should have been shuttered years ago
PETA said that the vote followed ‘sustained pressure’ from the organization, along with the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, Oregon legislators, Governor Tina Kotek and residents of the state.
‘During these discussions, the primate center will stop breeding monkeys as OHSU works with NIH to devise a plan to end the torment and killing of 1,200 monkeys a year in pointless tests,’ the organization said.
‘The abuse inside the Oregon National Primate Research Center (ONPRC) is so grotesque and prolific that adjectives simply fail to describe the horror accurately.’
The organization cited experiments, including one that separated young monkeys from their mothers and deliberately frightened them and another injecting nicotine or surgically implanting nicotine pouches into the animals.
Elliot Spindel’s nicotine experiment intended to see the effect of the drugs on the monkey’s children, and in one example he gave the animals high doses of vitamin c, removed their fetuses and performed ‘lung function’ tests on them before they were killed and internally studied, according to PETA.
Dr Lisa Jones-Engel, who performed the separation experiment on the subjects, also published two experiments which saw seven-month-old and then 14-month-old monkeys being killed by exsanguination, or ‘bleeding out.’
‘Experimenters have deviated from approved protocols, exposing monkeys to additional pain and distress,’ the animal rights organization said.
Guillermo added that the experiments in the center ‘is more the stuff of nightmare than the stuff of science.’
‘The rest of the scientific world is moving ahead…all the public had to hear is that the [center] straps monkeys into chairs and electro ejaculates them and that’s all they needed to know to be in favor of closure,’ she said.
According to Guillermo, PETA conducted two undercover investigations into the center, one in 2001 and another in 2007, and ‘from that time to this, nothing has changed.’
The center’s largest benefactor, the National Institutes of Health which has poured in tens of millions of dollars each year, announced in April that it would be ‘adopting a new initiative’ to focus more on human-based research technologies.
After a vote in February by the OHSU board, which pushed for President Dr Shereef Elnahal to convert the center into a sanctuary for monkeys, Elnahal told staff at a recent OHSU Faculty Senate meeting that a sanctuary would only go ahead if it was fully funded
According to Guillermo, PETA conducted two undercover investigations into the center, one in 2001 and another in 2007, and ‘from that time to this, nothing has changed.’
‘For decades, our biomedical research system has relied heavily on animal models,’ NIH Director Dr Jay Bhattacharya said in the release. ‘With this initiative, NIH is ushering in a new era of innovation.’
‘This human-based approach will accelerate innovation, improve healthcare outcomes and deliver life-changing treatments. It marks a critical leap forward for science, public trust and patient care,’ he added.
Guillermo called the NIH’s announcement a ‘good start,’ but believes they haven’t moved fast enough and the center ‘should have been closed down at least a decade or more ago’ when the New England National Primate Research Center shuttered its doors.
While animal welfare activist groups continue to push for the center to halt its research on primates, an opposing and recently formed nonprofit, Oregon Voices for Biomedical Research, launched their ‘Save Science Oregon’ campaign.
The campaign is calling for the center to continue its research, as spokesperson Diana Gordon told Oregon Live that the group of ‘concerned citizens and scientists’ has hopes of correcting misinformation and defending the advancements the research offers.
‘We feel that the political realm has encroached on science in a way that should not be happening. Science is not political… it is an endeavor attempting to help all of us,’ Gordon told the outlet.
Defense of the center revolves largely around the medical advancements that the research facilitates, which Gordon argued could not be done with computer models and lab-grown tissues.
‘Everyone in our group… looks forward to the day when animals are no longer needed in research… but it’s just not right now,’ she said.
The discussions to decide the center’s fate, however, are expected to continue on until August and current employees grow ever-more concerned for their jobs and research
The center has been responsible for a large number of studies on vaccines, infectious disease, neuroscience, reproductive health and aging, aiding advancements in cancer treatments as well as HIV and infertility.
Guillermo told the Mail, however, that ‘the experimenters who use monkeys at the primate center are primarily concerned with keeping their jobs.’
‘This place has been in business for 60 years. Remarkably little has come out of it that would benefit humans, and it’s time for them to acknowledge that and move on to better science,’ she continued.
‘Instead they’re reframing it that their work is essential. We know it’s not. Where are the vaccinations for HIV? Where are the vaccinations to prevent tuberculosis? Where is anything other than a published paper that has allowed a professor to slide into the tenure track?’
Researchers at the center have said that the current talks pose a major threat to their work, as Elnahal said the discussions come with hopes of avoiding a forced closure of the center.
The discussions to decide the center’s fate, however, are expected to continue on until August and current employees grow ever-more concerned for their jobs and research.
Should the center be transformed into a sanctuary, research would be restricted; new breeding would halt and animal studies would be limited while existing research could continue.
Molly Shallman, a union-represented researcher, said at a recent board meeting that the center’s employees are experiencing ‘growing stress’ over the fate of their careers. She also accused the center of being misleading in suggesting that the discussions were initiated through federal officials, the outlet reported.
Should the center be transformed into a sanctuary, research would be restricted; new breeding would halt and animal studies would be limited while existing research could continue
Elnahal acknowledged that communications had been sparse, noting the need for sensitivity during negotiations, but any final agreement would be made public.
He also said that the NIH approached the center with a draft agreement, but he had been in talks with federal officials prior to the draft.
OHSU officials told the outlet that the discussions were ‘ongoing, deliberative and confidential.’
According to PETA, the center houses 5,403 monkeys as of 2023 and took around $335 million in government money in the 2023 fiscal year.
Guillermo added: ‘I think we’re headed in the right direction, but the university probably needs a kick to get going.
‘I would urge them to consider that the Secretary of Health and Human Services, Robert F Kennedy Jr, has stated publicly that he would like the primate centers to close and transition into sanctuaries.’
NIH said in a statement to the Mail: ‘Oregon Health & Science University (OHSU) agreed to enter negotiations with NIH on turning the Oregon National Primate Research Center to a primate sanctuary. This decision reflects NIH’s plan to reduce the use of animals in NIH-supported research and to advance evidence-based science through new technologies and research models.’
OHSU said that ‘negotiations with NIH are ongoing, deliberative and confidential. No final agreement has yet been reached.’
The Daily Mail reached out to Oregon Voices for Biomedical Research for comment.
