Slayings rock quiet town after alleged Tom Selleck catfish targeted woman before couple found dead: friend

Authorities in California have launched a homicide investigation following the discovery of an elderly couple deceased in their residence on Friday, May 15. The Riverside County Sheriff’s Department reported that Donald Whitaker, aged 80, and Karen Whitaker, aged 79, were found in their Bermuda Dunes home, both having suffered “traumatic injuries.”

Fox News Digital spoke with Joy Meidecke, a longtime friend of the Whitakers, whom she knew through her role as president of the East Valley Republican Women Patriots. This organization was the connection through which Meidecke formed her friendship with the couple over the past ten years.

Karen Whitaker was actively involved with the East Valley Republican Women Patriots as a volunteer. Meidecke mentioned that Karen might have been targeted by an online scammer pretending to be the well-known actor Tom Selleck.

Karen Whitaker was a volunteer within the East Valley Republican Women Patriots in California. (Joy Miedecke)

She said Karen, who was a volunteer at EVRWP, may have fallen victim to an online scammer posing as famous actor Tom Selleck.

FOLLOW US ON X

Their relationship stemmed from an exchange in Facebook comments that turned to daily messaging.

FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X

Karen had commented on a post regarding the passing of a dear friend, Miedecke said. The scammer then started replying to Karen’s comments to where the two began a conversation, which flourished into a secret relationship, she said.

SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER

Karen Whitaker seen standing with Charlie Kirk. (Joy Miedecke)

GET BREAKING NEWS BY EMAIL

“He romanced her, he told her all these things,” she said.

FLEETWOOD MAC BACKUP SINGER LOST MORE THAN $1 MILLION IN ROMANCE SCAM

Eventually, the scammer then began requesting money and monopolizing Karen’s time — Miedecke said it’s possible that Karen may have sent hundreds of dollars to the Selleck poser.

Over time, Miedecke said she reported the possible elder abuse to Riverside County Adult Protective Services. The agency eventually visited the Whitakers’ home, to which Donald ultimately found out about the relationship, she said.

Karen standing next to a man and a woman

Karen Whitaker stands with a friend at an event for East Valley Republican Women Patriots. (Joy Miedecke)

“Her husband tried to talk to her. She wouldn’t listen. So they cut up all of her [credit] cards,” Miedecke said.

The Sheriff’s Department is investigating the couple’s death as a homicide; however, investigators have not revealed a suspect, nor have they announced any charges.

LISTEN TO THE NEW ‘CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO’ PODCAST

Fox News Digital has reached out to Riverside Adult Protective Services.

LIKE WHAT YOU’RE READING? FIND MORE ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

GOP Senate Candidates in Michigan, Iowa Push for End to Iran War

GOP Senate Candidates in Michigan and Iowa Call for End to Iran War

Republican Senate hopefuls Mike Rogers of Michigan and Ashley Hinson of Iowa…
Mom of boy killed in NYC gunfire endorses Letitia James' AG opponent Saritha Komatireddy

Mom of slain NYC boy backs Komatireddy over Letitia James

The Bronx mother whose 12-year-old son was killed by a stray bullet…
FBI agents escort 18 assassination plot suspects

Haitian President Assassination Suspects Sent to Miami Over Alleged COVID Fraud-Funded Plot

18 suspects in killing of Haiti president transferred to Florida Fox News…
Hipster NYC neighborhoods to get gentrified transit makeover at cost of seniors

NYC Transit Makeover in Trendy Neighborhoods Raises Fears for Seniors

Older residents in some of Brooklyn’s most sought-after neighborhoods say Mayor Zohran…
$147K reward offered to unmask mystery tree poisoning suspect

$147K Reward Offered to Identify Suspect in Mystery Tree Poisoning

A $147,000 reward is being offered in Lake Tahoe’s famously affluent Incline…
Mark Ruffalo rips Gavin Newsom after Paramount settlement reached

Mark Ruffalo Blasts Gavin Newsom Over Paramount Settlement

Mark Ruffalo sharply criticized California Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday after Paramount…
Clancy holdout juror taps former Trump lawyer to fight back as he’s ‘dragged through the mud’: attorney

Lindsay Clancy Defense Seeks Probe of Holdout Juror Vote

Lindsay Clancy trial holdout juror defends vote The mistrial in the Lindsay…
‘American Idol’ contestant’s 100K texts with mistress show motive in wife’s murder, prosecutors say

Prosecutors: 100K Texts Show Idol Contestant’s Wife Murder Motive

Text messages surface in murder trial with former ‘American Idol’ contestant Former…
Soaring California electricity costs among highest rates in US

California Electricity Rates Soar to Among the Highest in the U.S.

A new analysis ranks California among the states with the highest electricity…
Norwegian skater Joachim Lanham, rollerblading across US, killed after allegedly being struck by 82-year-old driver in Kansas hit and run

Norwegian Skater Joachim Lanham Killed in Kansas Hit-and-Run

A 24-year-old Norwegian man rollerblading across the United States died in Kansas…
Nolan Wells' death ‘consistent with drowning,’ no evidence it was criminal or racially motivated: grand jury

Grand Jury Finds Nolan Wells’ Death Consistent With Drowning

A grand jury has determined that Nolan Wells’ death was consistent with…
Lindsay Clancy's attorney requests investigation into holdout juror, asks judge to dismiss criminal case

Lindsay Clancy Attorney Seeks Probe of Juror, Dismissal of Case

Attorneys for Lindsay Clancy are asking a judge to examine the conduct…