Slain New Jersey therapist’s grad school roommate recounts friendship with couple during time in Boston

BOSTON – Jennifer Payne is still struggling to make sense of the death of Brooke Hanlon, her close friend and former roommate. “I hope she was not miserable toward the end of things,” Payne said of the New Jersey therapist who was killed earlier this summer.

Payne told INC News that she first met Hanlon in 2013, when the two were graduate students at Northeastern University. Their friendship deepened during those years, and they later shared an apartment in Boston for several years.

Hanlon, 35, had welcomed a baby last year. On June 6, she was found fatally stabbed inside her home in Chester, New Jersey.

Brooke, left stands for photo with Jennifer, right

Brooke Hanlon, 35, was found stabbed to death inside her Chester, New Jersey home in June. Her longtime friend and former roommate, Jennifer Payne, is reeling from the tragedy. (Jennifer Payne)

Payne said she learned of Hanlon’s death weeks after investigators made the grim discovery, when she received a call from a news outlet.

Authorities have not publicly identified a suspect or person of interest as the homicide investigation continues.

📩 Send me a story idea: kelsie.cairns@fox.com

🎥 Facebook: Kelsie Cairns

Speaking about the limited release of information in the case, Payne said, “The whole complexity of it all—and not knowing—keeps you on bated breath all the time.”

Payne’s painful loss of her friend brings back numerous memories, including their post-grad trip to Europe she tells INC News.

Brooke Hanlon and Jennifer Payne pose for a photo while traveling in Europe

Jennifer Payne, longtime friend to slain New Jersey mother, Brooke Hanlon, says the pair traveled to Europe together post graduation. (Jennifer Payne)

While Brooke and her husband, Conor, were dating, Payne said the group often hung out together and sometimes Conor’s family members would join. The Hanlon family is from Boston’s Brighton neighborhood.

Murdered New Jersey therapist, Brooke Hanlon's husband, Conor Hanlon

Conor Hanlon leaves a residence in Massachusetts Thursday, July 9, 2026. Hanlon is the widower of Brooke Hanlon, who was found dead in their home in New Jersey in June. (Rashid Umar Abbasi for INC News)

Conor had a reserved nature about him when she knew him, Payne said.

“He just didn’t really have much personality. I didn’t think he was very motivated.”

Murdered New Jersey therapist, Brooke Hanlon's husband, Conor Hanlon

Conor Hanlon leaves a residence in Massachusetts Thursday, July 9, 2026. (Rashid Umar Abbasi for INC News)

Conor has yet to make a public statement about the death of his wife.

Jennifer and Brooke seen standing near bleachers to an athletic event

Jennifer Payne, longtime friend and former roommate of slain New Jersey mother, Brooke Hanlon says she wants to keep her friend’s legacy alive. (Jennifer Payne)

photo of Brooke and Jennifer during their trip to Europe

Brooke Hanlon was found stabbed to death in her Chester, New Jersey home. Her longtime friend, Jennifer Payne says she got the devastating news when a news organization reached out to her. (Jennifer Payne)

Conor Hanlon has not been charged with any crime or wrongdoing.

INC News has made numerous attempts to reach him but calls have not been returned.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Whizzing college professor pees on student's backpack, found to be campus's mystery serial sprinkler: records

College Professor Accused of Being Campus ‘Serial Sprinkler’

It was allegedly his only relief. A Minnesota college professor allegedly urinated…
How Islanders helped superfan beat near-fatal rare cancer

New York Islanders Help Superfan Beat Near-Fatal Rare Cancer

He put his cancer battle on ice. After surviving a devastating medical…
Pope Leo XIV to be admitted to hospital Tuesday for lung nodule surgery, Vatican says

Vatican Says Pope Leo XIV to Undergo Lung Nodule Surgery Tuesday

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican announced that Pope Leo XIV is scheduled…
Pennsylvania gunman who killed 8 was grandfather who seemed normal, victim relatives say

Pennsylvania Grandfather Who Killed 8 Seemed Normal, Families Say

Erie police SWAT officers breach residence where nine people died in tragedy…
2 victims of Pa. grandpa's murder-suicide that killed 9 ID'd as friends who carried out brave final act

2 Friends Killed in Pa. Grandpa’s Murder-Suicide Hailed Heroes

Two women killed in the Pennsylvania murder-suicide that claimed nine lives—including those…
21-year-old NYC native goes to the hospital for a simple broken ankle -- and dies for shocking reason: lawsuit

NYC Woman, 21, Dies After Hospital Visit for Broken Ankle, Lawsuit Says

A 21-year-old Manhattan native went to the hospital for treatment of a…
Bessent taunts 'Pocahontas' Elizabeth Warren with cheeky clapback

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent Fires Back at Elizabeth Warren

WASHINGTON — Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent took a pointed swipe at Sen.…
NJ Transit train commuters brace for new month of hell

NJ Transit Commuters Brace for Another Month of Train Disruptions

NJ Transit rail passengers are facing another difficult stretch of commuting, with…
Pennsylvania grandpa accused of gunning down 8 in murder-suicide never seem distressed, was always 'smiling'

Pennsylvania Grandpa Accused of Killing 8 Was ‘Always Smiling’

The gunman who killed eight people in Erie, Pennsylvania, appeared to be…
NYC loses more than half of pied-a-terre tax appeals

NYC Suffers Court Defeat in Most Pied-à-Terre Tax Appeals

More than half of the homeowners who have challenged New York City’s…
DSA 'demands' Mamdani fire NYPD boss Tisch as socialists turn on mayor over ICE shooting

DSA Demands Mamdani Oust NYPD Commissioner Tisch After ICE Shooting

The Democratic Socialists of America are urging Mayor Zohran Mamdani to dismiss…
Wildfire erupts in LA County's Santa Clarita as homes evacuated

Santa Clarita Wildfire Triggers Home Evacuations in LA County

A wildfire spread rapidly through Southern California on Sunday afternoon, triggering evacuation…