21-year-old NYC native goes to the hospital for a simple broken ankle -- and dies for shocking reason: lawsuit

A 21-year-old Manhattan native went to the hospital for treatment of a broken ankle. Instead, she died after allegedly being given an excessive amount of pain medication, according to a shocking lawsuit.

The family of Dale Alice Martin alleges in court documents that Waterbury Hospital in Connecticut severely mishandled the college student’s care on April 10, 2025. Martin had fractured her ankle while doing farm work, but the lawsuit claims she was given a lethal combination of drugs that left her brain-dead, the Hartford Courant reported.

“We didn’t know till after Dale’s death that she was admitted to a bankrupt hospital that was under investigation, where nurses allegedly were buying food for patients, where the level of funding was so constrained that the hospital may not have been able to function properly,” her father, Westchester County resident Lindsay Martin, told the outlet.

“Dale did not have a choice of where to go,” he said of his daughter, a Bethlehem, Connecticut, resident who attended middle and high school in Pelham in Westchester County. According to the Pelham Examiner, she studied English and history at Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas.

“She was brought to the nearest hospital,” her father said.

An autopsy determined that Martin died of cardiac arrest after receiving multiple painkillers, according to the lawsuit filed by the family’s attorney, Christopher Mattei.

“Within 14 hours of admission, providers at the hospital had administered so much pain medication that Dale stopped breathing and later died,” the lawsuit states. “No one checked on Dale during this time.”

“The same medications that were interfering with Dale’s breathing were also sedating her. Dale could not even call for help as she suffocated. At 7 a.m. on April 10, a Waterbury Hospital nurse finally checked on Dale. It was far too late. Her heart had stopped beating.”

Lindsay Martin said he still remembers the devastating phone call from the hospital informing him of his daughter’s death.

“I hung up the phone, and I was in shock,” he said.

The family said it was unaware of the hospital’s financial and operational problems. Waterbury Hospital had long been owned by California-based Prospect Medical Holdings, which filed for bankruptcy in January 2025.

Earlier this year, Hartford HealthCare purchased the struggling facility along with two other hospitals.

“What we expect to find is that this was a hospital that was largely operating on fumes as a result of Prospect dismantling infrastructure within the hospital, reducing staff, training, and finding every way possible to extract value out of the hospital in a way that jeopardized care,” Mattei said.

A hospital representative declined to comment, saying Martin’s death occurred before Hartford HealthCare took ownership.

Former Prospect CEOs David Topper and Von Crockett did not respond to calls and emails from WNBC-TV News seeking comment on the lawsuit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

King Charles jokes about aging with Elton John in birthday podcast appearance

King Charles Jokes About Aging With Elton John on Birthday Podcast

King Charles III marked his 78th birthday with a special appearance on…
MICHAEL RUIZ: Montauk bikini designer's $50M yacht death lawsuit frozen as owner asks judge for exoneration

Michael Ruiz Yacht Death Lawsuit Paused as Owner Seeks Exoneration in $50M Claim

The family of an Irish bikini designer found dead aboard a luxury…
Ohio teen roper catches sneaky sheep that was on the lam for 45 days

Ohio Teen Roper Captures Sheep After 45 Days on the Run

A 14-year-old roper and her seasoned horse have brought an end to…
Alex Murdaugh lawyers say top investigator lied to grand jury, want murder indictments tossed

Alex Murdaugh Lawyers Seek Dismissal of Murder Charges, Claim Investigator Lied to Grand Jury

Attorneys for Alex Murdaugh asked a judge Friday to dismiss the indictments…
Hundreds gather to remember 'loving' young construction worker killed in Brooklyn building collapse: 'He was always smiling'

Hundreds Honor Beloved Young Construction Worker Killed in Brooklyn Building Collapse

Gabriel Siguencia, one of the construction workers killed in Wednesday’s Brooklyn building…
FAA Ground Stop Leaves College Football Teams Scrambling to Reach Saturday Games

FAA Ground Stop Scrambles College Football Teams Before Saturday Games

The Arizona State Sun Devils delayed their flight to Orlando until Saturday…
Illinois bomb threat at Peoria ethanol plant prompts mile wide evacuation

Bomb Threat at Peoria Ethanol Plant Triggers Mile-Wide Evacuation

A bomb threat at an ethanol plant triggered a large-scale evacuation in…
Massachusetts lunatic allegedly stabs sister to death -- and claims she was possessed by demons

Massachusetts Woman Charged With Killing Sister, Claims Demons

A Massachusetts man allegedly stabbed his sister to death before calling 911…
Ohio school investigating after viral video shows 10th grade girl punched, put in chokehold by boy

Ohio School Probes Video of Teen Girl Punched, Put in Chokehold

An Ohio school board is investigating an alleged assault on a 10th-grade…
Natalee Holloway's confessed killer caught trying to extort $250K from grieving mother in FBI sting video

FBI Sting Video Shows Natalee Holloway Killer Joran van der Sloot in Alleged $250K Extortion Attempt

For years, Joran van der Sloot tormented Natalee Holloway’s family with a…
Rock bands perform on Southwest flight during FAA ground stop

Rock Bands Perform on Southwest Flight During FAA Ground Stop

Passengers on a Southwest flight were treated to an impromptu in-flight concert…
Family Dollar to pay $63 million to settle claims it overcharged customers

Family Dollar to Pay $63M Over Customer Overcharging Claims

Family Dollar has agreed to pay $63 million to resolve allegations that…