COP31 on the brink of collapse as EU rejects UN climate deal

UN climate negotiations have descended into crisis after the European Union rejected a proposed agreement following days of bitter disputes with Saudi Arabia and other oil-producing nations over the future of fossil fuels.

The EU accused the oil states of effectively hijacking COP31 after they resisted any wording that would commit countries to moving away from coal, oil and gas.

Turkey and Australia, the conference’s co-hosts, produced a fourth draft on Sunday in a last-ditch effort to bridge the deep divisions.

However, the document still contained no direct reference to a transition away from fossil fuels, an omission that had already prompted some countries to threaten a walkout.

After more than two weeks of negotiations, originally scheduled to conclude on Friday but continuing through the weekend, Turkey’s COP31 president, Murat Kurum, told the closing plenary that the agreement had not been accepted.

‘It is clear that there are parties in this hall who oppose this text. We recognize that there is no consensus on this document. Therefore, these decisions have not been adopted,’ he said.

The failure recalled the breakdown at the Copenhagen climate summit in 2009, when nations were unable to adopt the Copenhagen Accord by consensus, dealing a major blow to multilateral climate diplomacy.

Several versions of the proposed agreement had been issued by the hosts, each attempting to balance the demands of countries most exposed to climate change with the interests of economies reliant on producing or burning fossil fuels.

The text acknowledged, for the first time, that global temperatures are likely to rise beyond the 1.5-degree Celsius limit that countries have tried to protect. It also called for faster progress on carbon-removal technologies that could eventually bring temperatures back down.

That attempt at compromise failed to win the necessary support, with opponents describing the proposal as far too weak.

COP31 President Murat Kurum (C) spoke during the Closing Plenary session on what was meant to be the final day of the COP31 UNFCCC Climate Conference on November 20

COP31 President Murat Kurum (C) addressed the Closing Plenary during what was expected to be the final day of the COP31 UNFCCC Climate Conference on November 20

Maina Vakafua Talia, Tuvalu's Minister for Home Affairs, Climate Change and Environment, speaks to journalists during a press conference at the COP31 UN Climate Change Conference in Antalya, Turkey, on November 21

Maina Vakafua Talia, Tuvalu’s minister for home affairs, climate change and environment, speaks to reporters at a press conference during the COP31 UN Climate Change Conference in Antalya, Turkey, on November 21

The Antalya conference was meant to finish on Friday, but negotiators remained locked in a dispute over the wording of the final agreement.

The meeting has now become the longest UN climate conference on record, extending more than 44 minutes beyond its scheduled closing time.

Darragh O’Brien, Ireland’s climate and energy minister and the EU’s representative, said the latest draft ‘fails to meet the moment the world faces’.

Addressing the closing plenary, Mr O’Brien said: ‘The drafts put before us do not begin to address the climate emergency that we face and therefore the European Union cannot accept it.’

He repeated that the proposal was inadequate given the scale of the crisis facing the world.

‘At a point where the world urgently needs action to avert disastrous levels of global warming, the draft cover decision falls well short.’

Mr O’Brien said the EU could not support any agreement that failed to mention fossil fuels.

‘We will not accept a COP that greenwashes fossil fuels,’ he added.

The plenary was delayed several times as negotiators conducted frantic, last-minute consultations.

Tuvalu’s climate minister, Maina Talia, said the negotiations appeared to be taking place largely with Saudi Arabia.

Mr Talia, whose low-lying Pacific island nation faces an existential threat from rising seas, said that without action on fossil fuels, ‘then we are wasting our time here’.

The summit is taking place after a series of climate-related disasters across Europe, Nepal and Indonesia, while a super El Nino pattern is increasing the threat of further extreme weather.

An earlier draft released this week had called for an accelerated phase-out of fossil fuels. But a revised version published on Thursday removed all direct references to coal, oil and gas.

Fossil fuels remain the primary cause of human-driven climate change, making them one of the most contentious issues at the UN negotiations.

The dispute forced the summit to continue well beyond its Friday deadline.

By Saturday, negotiating teams were rearranging flights as confidence in a final agreement dwindled.

Turkey and Australia brought EU and Saudi representatives together on Saturday in an urgent effort to find common ground.

People protested outside the plenary ahead of the Closing Plenary session on what was the scheduled final day of the COP31 UNFCCC Climate Conference on November 20

Protesters gathered outside the plenary before the Closing Plenary session on what had been scheduled as the final day of the COP31 UNFCCC Climate Conference on November 20

Several delegations, speaking anonymously because of the sensitivity of the discussions, said countries were considering leaving Antalya without an agreement.

Jennifer Morgan, a former German climate minister and senior fellow at Tufts University’s Fletcher School, said the talks were close to collapse after the presidency presented what she called a weak proposal that disregarded the positions of 150 countries.

Climate campaigners at 350.org also criticised the draft for avoiding an explicit reference to fossil fuels while promoting carbon-removal technologies.

‘Carbon capture is one of the biggest scams of the overshoot era, and our leaders are on the verge of falling for it,’ said Sara Shaw, the group’s campaigns and networks director. She was referring to efforts to capture carbon dioxide before it enters the atmosphere.

Opponents argue that the technology remains costly and unproven at scale, and could be used to justify continued investment in oil and gas.

The latest draft followed intensive discussions between Australia, which was leading the negotiations, Turkey, the host nation, and almost 200 delegations representing countries of every size and level of wealth.

Delegates were given several hours to submit objections, with another session planned for Sunday to begin formally approving the text.

Australia, backed by Turkey, had been tasked with finding a compromise between countries most vulnerable to climate impacts and those whose economies depend on producing or consuming fossil fuels.

This is the first COP since the UN’s environmental body confirmed that global warming is on course to exceed 1.5 degrees Celsius, the threshold countries agreed more than a decade ago to try to avoid and beyond which extreme weather risks become more severe.

With expectations already subdued, Australia’s lead negotiator sought a broad political agreement that would record the outcome of COP31 and indicate the direction of future climate policy.

Instead, the newest version of the proposed ‘cover decision’ omitted any mention of fossil fuels.

Houses lie partially submerged in muddy water along a riverside after flash floods at Trishuli Bazar in Nepal's Nuwakot district after deadly floods in August

Houses are partly submerged in muddy floodwater along a riverbank at Trishuli Bazar in Nepal’s Nuwakot district after deadly floods in August

That kind of language has been strongly opposed by petrostates and other fossil fuel-dependent nations, including Saudi Arabia. A Saudi official declined to comment.

‘The situation is difficult, and the outcome is uncertain. The oil-producing countries are putting up a fierce fight,’ a German official said.

Threats of a walkout on Saturday led Turkey and Australia to arrange an emergency meeting between the EU and Saudi Arabia, but no compromise was reached.

The latest draft made an indirect reference to a 2023 global agreement to shift away from fossil fuels, but stopped short of naming coal, oil or gas.

‘We are very disappointed with how the text looks,’ Antigua and Barbuda’s environment minister, Michael Joseph, told AFP after leaving the COP31 presidency’s offices.

‘I can’t honestly say that I’m okay with it passing’ in its current state, Mr Joseph said.

The document also preserved a controversial proposal to expand carbon capture and storage, a technology supported by the fossil fuel industry but criticised by campaigners as expensive and ineffective at reducing emissions.

The call to increase the use of carbon capture in the previous draft faced particularly strong resistance.

Critics say the technology has a poor record of cutting emissions and could allow fossil fuel use to continue for longer.

A group of 12 European and developing countries, including France, Panama and the Solomon Islands, issued a letter on Friday demanding ‘a clear transition away from fossil fuels’.

Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, accused a ‘petroleum mafia’ of obstructing progress and warned that his country could leave the negotiations unless a more ambitious deal was produced.

The OPEC oil cartel said on X that its secretary general, Haitham Al Ghais, met Russian presidential climate envoy Ruslan Edelgeriev at COP31 on Friday.

A man checked his phone near a building collapsed due to an earthquake, in Reok, East Nusa Tenggara province, Indonesia, in August

A man looks at his phone beside a building destroyed by an earthquake in Reok, East Nusa Tenggara province, Indonesia, in August

Coal supplies roughly one-third of the world’s electricity, while fossil gas accounts for another fifth.

A further source of tension has been an effort by Saudi Arabia, India and Kenya to postpone the next series of reports from the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

The draft says the reports will be important to the next assessment of global emissions-cutting efforts, scheduled for 2028.

Dozens of nations across Europe, Africa and the Pacific want the assessments from the world’s leading climate science body to be released in time for that review.

Delegates have also clashed over how to respond as the world approaches a breach of the 1.5C warming limit established under the Paris Agreement.

The latest proposal expressed ‘deep concern’ about missing the target but removed an earlier commitment to bring warming back below 1.5C as quickly as possible this century.

Negotiations remain deadlocked over longstanding complaints that wealthy nations are failing to provide enough support to help developing countries deal with climate change.

Developing nations were particularly angered by the removal of a $120billion (£91.74billion) goal for climate adaptation finance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

UK Defence Intelligence Chief Warns Putin’s Recklessness Could Trigger World War III

Vladimir Putin could inadvertently set off a third world war, according to…

Trump Was Set to Fire Another Top Official After Epstein Confession

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has made it through Donald Trump’s first two…

EU Plan Could Cost Britain Billions, Catching Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham Off Guard

Andy Burnham has vowed to continue his push to undo Brexit, despite…

How Celebrity Mental Health Disclosures Shape Scandal Coverage

The man at the end of the telephone line sounded panicked, his…

Mother Says She Watched Daughter Use AI to Write Suicide Note

One evening in March, a North Carolina mother received an urgent message…

The British Public School Brothers Behind Grand Theft Auto

St Paul’s, one of Britain’s most distinguished and long-established public schools, says…

Miley Cyrus Marries Rocker Maxx Morando in Intimate Ceremony

Miley Cyrus has married musician Maxx Morando in a beautiful ceremony in…

Theresa May Tells Andy Burnham to ‘Move On’ After Brexit Vote

Theresa May has told Andy Burnham to accept Brexit and “move on”,…

Jerry Jones Raises Questions Over Circumstances of Fan’s Death

Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones says the team had no knowledge of…

Rob Kardashian Makes Rare Appearance for Daughter Dream’s Birthday

Rob Kardashian gave fans a rare glimpse into his family life on…

Thomas Markle’s Asia Trips to Meet Girls Were ‘Open Secret’

Thomas Markle’s alleged “girls’ trips to Asia” were an “open family secret”,…

Revealed: The Salaries of Australia’s 30 Highest-Paid Public Servants

A new “golden circle” of 12 semi-state and agency chief executives are…