Menlo College student accused of raping 12-year-old as prosecutors probe second victim

A Menlo College student in California accused of sexually assaulting a 12-year-old girl in his campus dorm room is being held without bail while authorities continue investigating whether there may be additional victims, prosecutors said.

Andres Manuel Aguilar, 19, faces two counts of forcible sexual assault — rape and oral copulation — along with one felony count of providing marijuana to a minor. The charges stem from an alleged encounter on May 5.

A preliminary hearing in the case has been pushed back to Aug. 27, giving investigators more time to review information that prosecutors say could result in additional charges.

Booking photo of Andres Manuel Aguilar, 19, who faces sexual assault and marijuana-related charges in San Mateo County, California.

Andres Manuel Aguilar, 19, a Menlo College student, is charged with two counts of forcible sexual assault and one count of providing marijuana to a juvenile. (Credit: FOX 2 San Francisco)

“Nothing new to report on the potential second victim in the Aguilar case,” San Mateo County District Attorney Steve Wagstaffe told INC News. “The case was continued to Aug. 27, and that gives the police well over a month to complete the investigation and for my prosecutor to make the decision on whether the evidence is sufficient to add additional charges for the second victim.”

Court notes provided to INC News by San Francisco affiliate FOX 2 state that prosecutors allege the girl left her home without permission after previously meeting Aguilar at a bus stop in Menlo Park. Prosecutors said that while the girl told Aguilar she was 17, he acknowledged she was still a minor.

The two later went to a Safeway, where prosecutors say they obtained beer and rum before returning to Aguilar’s dorm room. Investigators allege they drank alcohol and vaped marijuana there before Aguilar sexually assaulted the girl after she repeatedly told him “no.”

Entrance sign and driveway leading into Menlo College in Atherton, California

The entrance to Menlo College in Atherton, California, where prosecutors allege the incident occurred inside a campus dormitory. (Google Maps)

Aguilar then allegedly became concerned about a possible pregnancy and used DoorDash to have a Plan B emergency contraceptive delivered to his dorm room before giving it to the girl.

Investigators also say dormitory surveillance video captured Aguilar and the girl entering his room before later showing the girl leaving.

In a statement, Menlo College said it takes allegations of criminal conduct seriously and is cooperating with law enforcement, but declined to comment on Aguilar specifically.

A gavel on a bench as people leave court

A gavel sits on a judge’s bench as people leave court. (iStock)

“Due to federal and state privacy laws and College policy, Menlo College cannot comment on matters involving identifiable individuals,” the statement read, adding that further questions should be directed to the Atherton Police Department.

Wagstaffe said investigators are encouraging anyone who believes they may have been victimized by Aguilar to contact law enforcement.

“It is our hope that if there are additional victims out there, we want them to come forward so we can provide justice for any such crimes,” Wagstaffe said.

Whether additional charges are filed will depend on the evidence gathered during the ongoing investigation, the district attorney added.

INC News has reached out to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement regarding Aguilar’s immigration status, as well as The United Firm | La Liga Defensora, which is representing Aguilar, for comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Luigi Mangione returns to court for jury selection hearing after reported plea deal falls apart

Luigi Mangione Says NY Murder Case Repeats Same Prosecution

Luigi Mangione pleads guilty in federal case as state murder charges remain…
Private jet with 9 people on board crashes just miles from Mar-a-Lago

NTSB Finds No Evidence Florida Jet Crash That Killed 9 Was Linked to Mar-a-Lago

Federal investigators said Tuesday that a key part of the private jet…
Man, 86, and his dog rescued hundreds of miles off California coast after going silent for 2 months

86-Year-Old Sailor and Dog Rescued After 2 Months Adrift Off California

An 86-year-old man and his dog were rescued from a disabled sailboat…
NYC Marathon runner Rachel Apa sent heartbreaking final text before dying on race day

NYC Marathon Runner Rachel Apa’s Heartbreaking Final Text Before Death

A 24-year-old runner who died after collapsing roughly two miles from the…
Sherrod Brown kicks Jon Husted's 'great a--' in Ohio Senate race

Sherrod Brown Vows to ‘Kick’ Jon Husted in Ohio Senate Race

Sherrod Brown is returning to the Senate after a two-year absence, notching…
Illegal immigrant accused of violent attempted murder, kidnapping of a minor was released under Biden admin

Biden Released Migrant Accused of Attempted Murder, Child Kidnapping

A 23-year-old man is facing multiple charges after Baltimore investigators accused him…
Prop 40 results: California voters to decide on billionaire tax

California Prop 40 Results: Voters Decide on Billionaire Tax Measure

Could California make history as the first state to impose a tax…
Retired NYPD officer arrested after 'off with his head' post over Florida mosque expansion

Retired NYPD Officer Arrested Over Florida Mosque Expansion Threat

A retired NYPD officer living in Florida was arrested Monday after allegedly…
Governor race winners 2026: All the results across 36 elections

2026 Governor Race Results: Winners Across All 36 Elections

The 2026 midterm elections will feature 36 gubernatorial races, with voters determining…
2026 House election live results as Democrats and Republicans vie for majority control

2026 House Election Live Results: Democrats, GOP Vie for Control

Ballot-scanning problems were reported Tuesday morning in New York’s Westchester County, which…
Miguel Urbano-Vazquez found guilty of 2002 Sharon Van Gilder murder and Tacoma rapes after extradition from Mexico

Miguel Urbano-Vazquez Guilty in Sharon Van Gilder Murder, Rapes

A man deported to Mexico and later extradited to the United States…
What is rhabdo? Sudden exercise complication that killed NYC marathoner

Rhabdomyolysis Explained: Rare Exercise Complication Linked to NYC Marathon Runner’s Death

A young, otherwise healthy New York City marathon runner died hours after…