A Mississippi grand jury has determined that Nolan Wells’ July 4 death was “consistent with drowning,” finding no evidence of foul play despite widespread speculation surrounding the case.
The Jackson County grand jury concluded that the evidence presented was insufficient to support criminal charges in connection with Wells’ death.
Wells, 18, was found floating in the water on July 6, two days after he and friends had taken a boat trip near Horn Island off the Mississippi Gulf Coast.
The teenager’s death attracted national attention as his grieving family called for a deeper investigation, even though law enforcement had determined there was no indication of foul play.
In a report released by the Jackson County District Attorney’s Office, the grand jury said the position, condition, discovery time and location of Wells’ body were “consistent with drowning.”
“After a thorough and exhaustive investigation,” District Attorney Angel Myers Mcllrath said, the grand jury met the previous week to review Wells’ death and unanimously returned a “no true bill,” meaning no indictment was issued.
Mcllrath said Wells’ death had “devastated our community,” adding that outsiders and influencers had tried to exploit the tragedy to create division and chaos, but that the community was “better together.”
The report noted that both the state chief medical examiner and another doctor listed the cause of death as “undetermined,” emphasizing that drowning is a “diagnosis of exclusion.”
Nolan Wells’ body was recovered after the 18-year-old football player and his friends took a Fourth of July boating trip near Horn Island off Mississippi’s Gulf Coast
Wells’ death drew national attention, while his grieving family sought an investigation despite authorities’ conclusion that no foul play was involved
Wells’ mother grew more suspicious after receiving his phone and checking Snapchat, where she found no photos from the outing—something she said was unusual for the football player
The documents said Wells had bruising on the back of his head, but that the injury was not fatal. They added that the doctor and state medical examiner disagreed about additional bruising on his back and shoulder.
A witness testified that he saw Wells slip awkwardly from the side of a boat at about 3:30 p.m. on July 4, although he could not say whether Wells hit his head during the fall.
According to the witness, Wells continued socializing afterward and did not appear to be injured.
The grand jury also addressed public concerns and rejected rumors that Wells had been the only person of color on Horn Island that day.
“There is absolutely no evidence to support the allegations that Nolan’s disappearance and death were racially motivated,” Mcllrath said.
The report stated that the grand jury found no credible evidence that anyone who traveled to or from Horn Island on July 4 had engaged in criminal conduct connected to Wells’ death.
It also concluded that Wells had not been involved in a fight or argument that day and had remained on the island with others to socialize.
The report said the Triton boat carrying Wells’ group suffered a bilge pump and motor malfunction on July 4 and was “actively taking on water and sinking.”
The grand jury rejected rumors surrounding the case, finding that Wells was not the only person of color on Horn Island when he died
‘The Grand Jury conducted a comprehensive inquiry into the death of Mr Wells and is confident in the extensive investigation done by both Federal and State law enforcement agencies,’ the report added.
The report comes after a flurry of theories were shared by media personalities and on social media.
The View’s host Sunny Hostin even suggested Wells’ friends played a role in his death.
Lawyers Morgan Seymour, Jax Pitalo and Warren Hudson sent Hostin a letter demanding she retract, delete and apologize within 10 days for what they claim were defamatory comments she made – or face legal consequences.
Paltzik and Cox took specific aim at comments she allegedly made about the case on The View’s Behind the Tale podcast on July 13 and on a segment that aired on the talk show the following day.
On the podcast, the lawyers say, Hostin claimed there were ‘a lot of inconsistencies’ regarding Wells’ cellphone and ‘social media profiles being erased,’ an apparent reference to claims that Snapchat messages may have been deleted from Wells’ phone, as a photo of Pitalo, Seymour and Wells was displayed on camera.
Hostin also said she found it ‘extremely odd’ that ‘the three boys he was on the boat with’ were not questioned separately by police.
‘I don’t know that that’s happened here and that is shocking to me,’ she said.
In a segment that aired on The View the following day, Hostin claimed there were ‘some racial undertones’ to the case and that Wells ‘was the only black kid on an island full of kids that were white.’
The View co-host Sunny Hostin was threatened with a defamation lawsuit for comments she made about the Nolan Wells case
Wells’ parents, Christine and Elmore Wonsley, previously challenged the accounts given by their son’s friends about what happened on the day he died
Lawyers representing three of Wells’ friends – Morgan Seymour, Jax Pitalo and Warren Hudson – deny he was the only black kid on the island as Hostin had claimed
She further claimed the ‘three boys with him that were good friends with him’ had ‘kept his phone and didn’t give it to his parents.’
But the attorneys deny that their clients ever touched or had ‘actual possession of Nolan’s phone.’
They noted that many on the island stored their cellphones and electronic devices on their boats so they would not be damaged by the water, and witnesses have said Wells did not seem concerned his phone was onboard as the others left in separate boats.
The phone was then brought back to the mainland by a wider friend group and kept safe in another friend’s truck.
‘At no time did they alter, delete, modify or erase any data or information on Nolan’s phone,’ they argued, saying the phone was turned over to a friend of Wells’ family ‘without incident or delay.’
The attorneys further denied Wells was ‘the only black kid on an island full of kids that were white,’ as Sunny suggested, and noted that their clients had ‘repeatedly cooperated with law enforcement and turned their phones in for inspection long ago.’
They also argued that the three friends did not need to be ‘separated in different rooms’ because ‘they did nothing wrong, had nothing to do with Nolan’s tragic death and immediately stepped forward to accelerate the investigation by contacting Nolan’s mother and law enforcement.’
‘Warren, Jax and Morgan were all close with Nolan and loved him like a brother. And Nolan loved them back,’ the lawyers claimed.
‘Unlike you, Warren, Jax and Morgan welcomed the truth and care very much about learning the truth surrounding Nolan’s tragic death.’
Hostin’s remarks, taken in full, suggested that the friends ‘were colluding to hide evidence and/or obstruct the efforts to find Nolan at the very least, and that they murdered Nolan at the very worst,’ Paltzik and Cox argued.
‘It is hard to fathom the pure negligence you have shown through your multiple interviews regarding these young men and the tragic death of their friend, Nolan Wells,’ the lawyers tell Hostin.
‘Your unwillingness to research the most basic facts surrounding the incident before commenting publicly is downright baffling,’ they continue.
‘Moreover, as a former prosecutor, you of all people should know the importance of “innocent until proven guilty.” You swore an oath with that principle in mind.’
‘To put it plainly, Sunny: our clients are completely innocent and your harmful lies and complete disregard for the truth have brought shame on you, your dwindling audience and the profession we share.’
This is a breaking news story.
