Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue have married at their picturesque New Jersey farm, Our News Outlet can exclusively reveal, bringing a happy conclusion to a remarkable story just weeks after their former spouses, T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach, exchanged vows.
Fiebig, 49, and the 59-year-old former Melrose Place star and philanthropist said “I do” during an intimate ceremony attended by family and close friends at their secluded 92-acre estate near the riverside community of Stockton.
Shue bought the expansive property for $3.2 million in April 2023. With a horse farm, two historic houses dating to the 1700s, open pasture, woodland and a flowing stream, the grounds offered a striking autumn setting for the wedding.
Shortly before 2 p.m. Sunday, the bride departed the nearby inn where she had been staying in a floor-length white lace dress featuring an off-the-shoulder, corset-inspired bodice.
Fiebig completed the bridal look with a coordinating white shawl, a delicate netted half-veil and a sleek updo. Satin block heels finished the elegant ensemble.
Her 13-year-old daughter, Sabine, whom she shares with Holmes, accompanied her and appeared to serve as her mother’s bridesmaid. Sabine carried a bouquet of white flowers and wore a navy satin gown with metallic heels.
Fiebig’s close friend Lisa Bashishow, a finance executive in the music and entertainment industry, joined them in a sleeveless green satin midi dress with cream lace accents and brown cowboy boots.
The party climbed aboard a white shuttle bus outside the cottage and headed to the couple’s country property for the ceremony.
Marilee Fiebig leaves the hotel in her wedding gown with daughter Sabine, whom she shares with ex-husband T.J. Holmes, before marrying Andrew Shue.
Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue gathered with relatives, including Fiebig’s daughter Sabine, and friends at the Woolverton Inn on Saturday evening before their Sunday wedding, just weeks after Holmes and Robach married.
Fiebig shielded her shoulders with a matching shawl and wore a netted half-veil over her dark hair, styled in an elegant updo.
Shue purchased the 92-acre property for $3.2 million in April 2023. The farm includes two centuries-old homes, pastures, woodland, a stream and equestrian facilities.
Shue’s sister, actress Elisabeth Shue, 63, was also among those celebrating beneath a large white marquee built on the property for the wedding festivities.
The couple appeared to follow tradition the night before the ceremony, with Fiebig staying at the inn alongside her teenage daughter.
The wedding took place a little more than a month after Robach, 53, and Holmes, 49, married in a private ceremony in Arkansas, Holmes’ home state, on September 19.
Sunday’s ceremony marked the latest chapter in an unexpected romance that began after Holmes and Robach, then co-hosts of ABC’s lunchtime program GMA3, became romantically involved while still married to Fiebig and Shue.
The four had once been close friends, regularly sharing meals and supporting one another at sporting events.
Their off-camera relationships became public after Our News Outlet reported on the romances in November 2022, and Holmes and Robach subsequently lost their television positions.
Both marriages had lasted more than a decade, and the couples were reportedly separated before the relationships were exposed. Holmes and Robach later divorced their spouses.
Holmes and Fiebig, who share Sabine, finalized their divorce in late 2023. Robach and Shue reached a mediated divorce agreement earlier that year.
Fiebig’s daughter Sabine, 13, boards a white shuttle bus for the brief journey to Shue’s expansive farm on the edge of town.
Marilee Fiebig smiles as she welcomes Andrew Shue’s actress sister Elisabeth to the New Jersey gathering held the evening before the wedding.
Marilee Fiebig and her daughter Sabine walk along the grounds of the historic Woolverton Inn.
Marilee and her daughter greet actress Elisabeth Shue, 63, who received an Academy Award nomination for Leaving Las Vegas, starring Nicolas Cage.
Robach and Shue did not have children together, though they had previously spoken warmly about their blended family. When they married in 2010, Shue’s three sons joined Robach’s two daughters.
As their respective marriages unraveled in the public eye, Fiebig and Shue found comfort and understanding in one another.
Their friendship gradually became a romantic relationship, which was publicly reported in December 2023.
The pair moved in together in February 2025 and became engaged later that spring.
When the engagement was announced 10 days ago, Shue told People: “I don’t know how it happened, but there’s a happy ending.”
“This just happened to be our way of getting to know each other and being able to share ourselves with each other at a time when we both needed a friend,” he added.
The wedding weekend began Saturday evening with a private sunset cocktail reception at the Woolverton Inn, a boutique hotel and bed-and-breakfast centered around an 18th-century manor and several cottages on 300 acres overlooking the Delaware River.
Approximately 40 relatives and close friends gathered upstairs at the inn’s Northridge restaurant, a converted barn now used as a fine-dining space.
Staff spent the afternoon preparing for the event as guests arrived. One worker was seen transporting a large metal drinks bucket filled with beverages.
Andrew and Marilee arrive at New Jersey’s historic Woolverton Inn for the pre-wedding celebration. The couple unloaded luggage from Shue’s vehicle before heading inside.
The ceremony concluded an unexpected love story that began after Holmes and Robach, then colleagues on GMA3, entered a secret relationship while married to Fiebig and Shue.
Exclusive photographs from Our News Outlet show the couple reaching the inn earlier in the day and carrying suitcases and boxes from Shue’s green Toyota Land Cruiser.
Shue brought the belongings inside, where Fiebig was believed to have spent Saturday night.
He later returned in a navy suit, pale blue shirt and lace-up boots, accompanied by his sons Nate, 30, Aidan, 27, and Wyatt, 22, from his previous marriage to Jennifer Hageney.
Fiebig welcomed guests in a champagne-toned chiffon skirt, a cream sleeveless blouse and a matching cover-up.
The bride warmly greeted Elisabeth Shue, who had traveled from Los Angeles with her filmmaker husband, Davis Guggenheim, and their daughter.
She also embraced Shue’s brother John, 56, who came from Massachusetts for the family celebration.
Guests later gathered under a sweeping white marquee installed on the property for the wedding celebrations.
Andrew Shue and his sister Elisabeth help their mother Anne Harms into the pre-wedding gathering in Stockton, New Jersey.
Elisabeth Shue, her husband Davis Guggenheim and their daughter arrive for the pre-wedding event.
Marilee embraces Andrew’s brother John as he arrives in Stockton, New Jersey.
The wedding weekend opened with a small sunset cocktail reception at the Woolverton Inn, whose 18th-century manor and cottages sit on 300 acres above the Delaware River.
Elisabeth and Andrew helped their mother, Anne Harms, who uses a walker, into the venue.
Their father, James W. Shue, divorced from Harms when the children were young, died in 2013.
Harms officiated Andrew’s wedding to Robach, although it has not been confirmed whether she played the same role in his ceremony with Fiebig.
Born in Wilmington, Delaware, Shue rose to fame as Billy Campbell on the Beverly Hills spinoff Melrose Place, appearing in the series for six seasons.
He later pursued professional soccer, playing for Zimbabwe’s Bulawayo Highlanders before making five appearances for the LA Galaxy during the 1996-97 season.
Marilee Fiebig’s sister Chantale photographs their parents, Pauline and William, as they arrive at a Stockton hotel. Fiebig was born in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where her mother met her father while he was serving in the Peace Corps.
Shue later moved into entrepreneurship, founding the youth charity DoSomething and the website CafeMom with his friend Michael Sanchez.
DoSomething works to encourage young people to create positive change through campaigns conducted both online and in their communities.
He recently launched The Forum, a nonpartisan civic project that brings together political voices from across the ideological divide.
In a profile for Town & Country magazine’s November 2026 Philanthropy issue, Shue said the initiative ultimately aims to “help set a different tone for 2028 and beyond.”
He explained that The Forum “is currently operating in three states — South Carolina, Nevada and New Hampshire — and it works in phases.”
Shue has acknowledged that some people remain skeptical of the project.
Guests mingle ahead of the pre-wedding festivities at the Woolverton Inn.
Fiebig is legal counsel and a partner at Axis Hats, a luxury art house headquartered in New York City.
“There’s been a few good-luck-with-that’s,” he said. “But I don’t have time to be cynical. Our leaders have been working in a system that is broken, and now corrupt, and they can’t get out of it.”
“So we need to get them out of it. We need to flip the script. The American people should be leading, and our leaders should be following.”
“We’ve been watching the same bad movie every two years, with the same games and the same intense partisanship in primaries, all for one and a half percent of voters to determine who gets into power. I’m sure in my bones this is the only way we’re going to get ourselves out of the mess that America is in.”
Fiebig’s family also traveled to New Jersey for the wedding, including her parents, Pauline, 69, and William, 78, as well as her attorney siblings Chantale, 46, and Jason, 43, and their families.
Shue and Fiebig announced their engagement only days after their former spouses married. The couple is pictured in 2024.
Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes are now husband and wife after marrying privately in Arkansas on September 19.
The wedding completed an unlikely romance that began after Holmes and Robach, then co-hosts on GMA3, began a secret relationship while still married to Fiebig and Shue.
Shue was born in Wilmington, Delaware, and became widely known for playing Billy Campbell on Melrose Place, where he appeared for six seasons. He is pictured in the cast photo on the bottom row between Kristin Davis and Heather Locklear.
Fiebig is currently legal counsel and a partner at Axis Hats, a New York City-based luxury art house.
She was born in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where her mother grew up, and where her mother met Fiebig’s father while he was serving with the Peace Corps.
Fiebig’s family moved to the United States when she was five. Her mother previously told her that she wanted her children to benefit fully from educational opportunities she had not received while growing up in Africa.
That immigration experience helped inspire Fiebig’s decision to pursue a career as an immigration attorney.
A graduate of Vanderbilt Law School and the University of Michigan, she worked at major international law firms in Atlanta and New York.
Fiebig later became chief diversity officer at Save the Children, the international humanitarian organization, and served as chief of staff to rapper Jay-Z at his entertainment company, Roc Nation.
