Finn Russell is tackled by Australia's Len Ikitau at Murrayfield on Sunday

As this round of Nations Championship fixtures approached, much of the discussion surrounding Finn Russell centred on Bath’s inconsistent start to the new season.

Russell had not been playing badly. There had still been glimpses of his trademark brilliance, but Bath’s results had been decidedly uneven.

Of the six matches Russell had started for Bath, the club had won only three.

That record included three successive defeats in October: a heavy 71-48 loss to Northampton, a 23-5 defeat by Gloucester and a 32-14 Champions Cup reverse against Montpellier.

It would be simplistic to blame Russell entirely for those results, but his dip in form appeared to reflect Bath’s wider struggles.

He was certainly not operating at the level he reached in 2025, when he helped Bath win the Premiership title before playing a starring role in the British and Irish Lions’ series victory in Australia.

Finn Russell is tackled by Australia's Len Ikitau at Murrayfield on Sunday

Finn Russell is tackled by Australia’s Len Ikitau at Murrayfield on Sunday

Russell has not been at his best in the autumn window of the Nations Championship

Russell has struggled to reach his best during the Nations Championship autumn window

Speaking to Daily Mail Sport a couple of weeks ago, former Scotland lock Jim Hamilton acknowledged Bath’s difficult start but backed Russell to rediscover his best form in international colours.

‘I know Bath have struggled slightly at the start of the season. But it’s still Finn Russell — he’ll put on a Scotland jersey and he’ll be one of the best players in the world again,’ Hamilton said.

So far, however, that prediction has not been fulfilled. Russell has looked below his best for Scotland and failed to impose himself in the matches against New Zealand and Australia over the past week.

Gregor Townsend was asked about his fly-half’s form after Scotland’s defeat by the All Blacks at Murrayfield.

‘I actually think Finn has been fine for Bath over the first few weeks of the season,’ the Scotland head coach said. ‘But it wasn’t his best game against New Zealand. He will know that himself.

‘He will be disappointed and he will definitely want to put that right next week. He’s been very, very good for us over a long period. He will want to show that against Australia.’

Russell did not improve significantly against the Wallabies on Sunday afternoon. With or without the ball, this was a long way from one of his defining performances.

Early in the first half, he missed an important tackle on Harry Potter during the passage of play that ended with the Australia winger scoring in the corner.

Former Scotland prop Peter Wright, working as a pundit for BBC Radio Scotland, did not hold back. ‘Finn Russell, that’s shocking,’ he said.

Russell's kicking game wasn't entirely on point in the narrow 15-12 win over Australia

Russell’s kicking lacked its usual accuracy during Scotland’s narrow 15-12 victory over Australia

Defence is often an overlooked part of Russell’s game. The fly-half regularly makes sizeable tackles and generally has a strong success rate.

That such a soft miss came at a crucial moment was therefore surprising. Yet it was not the only aspect of his performance that disappointed.

His kicking lacked precision and consistency. At times he failed to find touch, while on other occasions he sent the ball straight back into Australian hands.

For the second consecutive week, Scotland’s attack struggled to generate momentum. By his own demanding standards, Russell appeared subdued and largely ineffective.

Across the two games against New Zealand and Australia, Scotland scored five tries, all of them from forwards. Ewan Ashman claimed a hat-trick against the All Blacks, before Jack Dempsey and Matt Fagerson crossed against the Wallabies.

The fact that Scotland’s backs failed to score in either match underlined how far the team’s attack was from firing properly.

In Scottish rugby, criticism of Russell can sometimes be treated almost as an act of heresy. In this observer’s view, he is probably the country’s greatest rugby player. That status, however, cannot place him beyond scrutiny.

It is perhaps inevitable that Russell is judged more harshly than others in the Scotland side because everyone knows the extraordinary level he can reach.

Speaking on a podcast last week, former South Africa captain Jean de Villiers suggested that Russell was currently ‘playing on reputation’.

After only one match against New Zealand, that verdict seemed unduly severe. Following another underwhelming display against Australia, though, it is becoming more difficult to dismiss.

After Scotland’s laboured and uninspiring victory over the Wallabies on Sunday, Townsend once again defended his star player.

‘I thought he was excellent, I really did,’ Townsend said. ‘I felt he was our leader tactically in terms of the decisions to make. And it’s a tough game for a 10 when you’re not able to maybe play with as much width in your game. And you’re looking at tight options but the defence are closing that down.

Russell tackles Australia's Max Jorgensen as his defensive skills were tested

Russell tackles Australia’s Max Jorgensen as his defensive work came under pressure

‘I thought he had a couple of excellent kicks in behind. And I thought he was really dialled in in terms of what the team needed. And sometimes in our game, he doesn’t get to kick a lot.’

Asked whether Russell was expected to produce something brilliant in every match, Townsend replied: ‘I suppose that’s for you guys to decide. I think he’s very much appreciated by us and I hope by you guys as well. And also the supporters. Yeah, he’s a team player. He’s delighted the team beat Australia and he played his part in that.’

Russell remains Scotland’s most influential player, although the absence of captain Sione Tuipulotu in midfield against Australia was clearly a significant setback for the team’s attack.

Australia were extremely disappointing against Scotland, so Townsend’s claim that it was ‘the best defensive performance in the last couple of years’ should be viewed with some caution.

It was also an attempt to ease pressure on defence coach Lee Radford. The reality is that Australia created very few meaningful attacking opportunities.

Scotland, meanwhile, were hardly more threatening. That is the main concern. The sense of excitement around Russell — the belief that Scotland can score from anywhere — has been notably absent.

Townsend is expected to make numerous changes for Saturday’s meeting with Japan, making it unlikely that Russell will feature.

Scotland do need to examine their alternatives at fly-half. Russell is now 34 and will not remain at the heart of the team indefinitely.

That said, there may be value in giving him an opportunity to play himself back into form, particularly with Scotland expected to beat a Japan side that conceded 78 points against England at Twickenham last weekend.

Whatever Townsend decides, Scotland need the real Finn Russell to re-emerge as they head towards the Nations Championship finals weekend.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

A revolutionary cancer treatment that can destroy targeted tumour tissue without surgery is attracting international attention and offering new hope to patients who have exhausted conventional options - but it's not yet available in Australia or New Zealand

Australians Pay Fortunes Overseas for Needle-Free Cancer Treatment

A cutting-edge cancer treatment that can destroy tumours without an operation is…
Robert Irwin sparked uproar after weighing in on the trans-Tasman debate over who invented pavlova during an appearance on UK radio program Capital Buzz HQ

Robert Irwin Sparks Kiwi Backlash Over Australia’s Pavlova Claim

Robert Irwin has ignited a fresh trans-Tasman clash after declaring that Australia,…