A 32-year-old married teacher and soccer coach at a Kentucky high school wept in court Friday as she admitted to having a months-long sexual relationship with a 16-year-old student that involved intercourse and the exchange of nude images.
Mary ‘Hanna’ Mattingly, of Louisville, pleaded guilty to first-degree sexual abuse and possessing material depicting a sexual performance by a minor, according to WKYT.
Mattingly, who worked at Bardstown High School, was arrested in March and taken to the Nelson County Correctional Center.
She was initially charged with sexual abuse and procuring or promoting the use of a minor by electronic means. She later posted a $20,000 bond while awaiting arraignment.
At her latest hearing, a judge said the sexual contact took place between March 1 and July 31, 2025.
Under the terms of her plea agreement, Mattingly will serve five years in prison, the outlet reported.
The case began after Bardstown City Schools received an anonymous letter describing ‘alleged inappropriate conduct between a female substitute teacher and a student,’ according to the report.
Mattingly was a permanent substitute teacher at the school and also worked as an assistant coach for the girls’ soccer team, Bardstown City Schools superintendent Ryan Clark said.
Mary ‘Hanna’ Mattingly, of Louisville, Kentucky, broke down as she pleaded guilty to first-degree sexual abuse and possession of material portraying a sexual performance of a minor
During Friday’s hearing, a judge said the sexual contact with the student occurred between March 1 and July 31, 2025
The school district placed her on leave immediately after learning of the allegations.
Police said Mattingly had sexual contact with a high school student and allegedly sent the student partially nude photographs of herself.
READ MORE: 2 Public Safety Officers Shot at NYC Housing Complex; Suspect Dead
She has been charged with sexual abuse and procuring or promoting the use of a minor by electronic means
‘Multiple partially nude photographs were sent to the student,’ Bardstown police detective Eric Williamson said at the time.
Police said the arrest underscored how seriously they investigate tips submitted by members of the public.
‘Someone was concerned about an inappropriate relationship,’ Williamson said. ‘The only way they believed they could alert someone was through an anonymous letter.’
‘Look what it has yielded,’ he added.
Williamson emphasized that Bardstown police would not ‘tolerate this type of stuff in the community.’
Meanwhile, photos on social media showed happier times, with Mattingly standing next to her husband, Keith Mattingly, 33, and posing with her family by a Christmas tree
A post from a friend described Mattingly as ‘by far one of the BEST mothers I know’
‘This should not happen,’ he said. ‘This should not be something you have to worry about when you send your children to school.’
Elsewhere, social media photos depicted happier moments, including Mattingly standing beside her husband, Keith Mattingly, 33, and posing with her family near a Christmas tree.
One friend wrote that Mattingly was ‘by far one of the BEST mothers I know.’
Mattingly is scheduled to be sentenced on January 21, 2027.