‘Dangerous, ideological betrayal of public safety,’ Jewish groups say of Mamdani nixing specialized NYPD unit

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani faced widespread criticism Monday after announcing plans to dissolve the NYPD’s specialized counterterrorism unit, which also oversees crowd control during protests. The unit would be replaced by a civilian-led “community dialogue and de-escalation division” and a separate “First Amendment support team.”

City Hall described the de-escalation division as a “first-of-its-kind” initiative, emphasizing that it “will not have weapons or arrest powers.”

“During our campaign, I promised New Yorkers that we would disband the Strategic Response Group and separate counterterrorism from protest response, and today we are delivering on that promise,” Mamdani said.

“New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat,” he added. “We are establishing a new, civilian-led approach that prioritizes dialogue, engagement and de-escalation.”

The NYPD Strategic Response Group was established in 2015.

Mamdani said police officers could still be “called upon to come make arrests, including for those engaging in civil disobedience.”

According to City Hall, the new civilian-led division will “not have weapons or arrest powers.” The NYPD support team will include 30 uniformed officers trained in communication and de-escalation.

City Hall also said officers would be prohibited from using tear gas or pepper spray during “First Amendment activities.” The crowd-control practice known as “kettling,” in which police confine demonstrators within a restricted area, will also be discontinued.

NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said she “would never support changes that diminish the NYPD’s ability to protect New Yorkers or that put our officers in a position where they lack the resources necessary to confront a serious threat.”

“These changes will make us a stronger, more effective department,” she said.

Inna Vernikov, a New York City Council member and co-chair of its bipartisan task force on Jew-hatred, told JNS that “by disbanding the SRG, Mamdani is also unleashing a monster on Jewish New Yorkers.”

“Our community has already endured violent protesters attacking Jewish-owned businesses, intimidating congregants at synagogues and threatening Jewish students on university campuses,” she said. “Apparently, that’s not enough.”

“What’s another target painted on the backs of New York’s Jews for this mayor?” Vernikov told JNS.

Evan R. Bernstein, CEO of B’nai B’rith International, told JNS that Mamdani’s move represents “a dangerous and ideological betrayal of public safety, especially for New York’s Jewish community.”

“At a moment when Jews remain the city’s most targeted group for hate crimes, the SRG has been one of the few specialized units capable of rapidly containing violent, antisemitic protests that have repeatedly targeted synagogues, Jewish institutions and ordinary New Yorkers,” he said.

“Replacing trained officers with an unarmed, civilian ‘dialogue’ division that has no arrest powers is not reform. It is willful blindness,” Bernstein said. “Dialogue does not stop mobs chanting for intifada or blocking streets outside of Jewish neighborhoods.”

Mamdani’s announcement came after anti-Israel groups that have organized demonstrations outside synagogues and Jewish institutions throughout New York City called for the NYPD unit to be disbanded.

In May, several people were arrested following an anti-Israel protest outside a Brooklyn synagogue. An NYPD officer was also hospitalized after protesters opposed to Israel attempted to remove barriers outside Park East Synagogue in Manhattan.

New York City recorded an 182% rise in anti-Jewish hate crimes in January, Mamdani’s first month in office. Since then, Jews—who account for about 10% of the city’s population—have been the targets of more than half of all hate crimes recorded in the city.

City data showed that Jews were targeted in 57.8% of New York City hate crimes last month. Jewish leaders in New York and across the country have told JNS that Mamdani’s rhetoric, including his frequent criticism of Israel, has contributed to a less safe environment for Jews.

Chaim Steinmetz, senior rabbi at Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun, a Modern Orthodox synagogue on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, told JNS that the mayor’s decision would negatively affect the Jewish community.

“At issue is not protest as free speech. That must be sacrosanct,” Steinmetz said. “What is of deep concern to the Jewish community is protest as intimidation.”

Steinmetz said demonstrators had intimidated Jews during recent protests outside the UJA building and Park East Synagogue.

“Zohran Mamdani is acting like the protester-in-chief, not the mayor of New York,” he told JNS. “Because of that, there will be many more events like Park East Synagogue.”

“When there is violence,” he said, “it will be Mamdani’s fault.”

The World Jewish Congress told JNS that it has “every confidence” in the NYPD’s ability to protect Jews despite the planned changes.

“Politics must never get in the way of protecting Jewish lives,” the organization said.

Moshe Davis, who previously served as executive director of the mayor’s office to combat Jew-hatred under former Mayor Eric Adams, told JNS that “we need more cops and faster responses when mobs target our community.”

“I hope this fancy video and rebrand won’t change that,” said Davis, who now leads the Protecting Worship coalition. “If the mayor’s new de-escalation unit can convince his own allies to stop targeting houses of worship, we’ll all welcome it.”

Jim Geraghty, National Review’s senior political correspondent, discussed Mamdani’s announcement on his “Three Martini Lunch” podcast.

“You’ve basically announced this is your permission slip,” he said. “This doesn’t work in other cities. Why it would work in New York is completely beyond me, but it feels very on brand for Mamdani to say, ‘I’m going to do everything I can to make my city feel more chaotic and more like an angry mob is really in control.’”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

NYC Subway Shooter Who Accidentally Wounded Bystander Is Sentenced

A subway shooting on Manhattan’s Upper East Side ended with Steven Sylvester…

Dr Renee Hoenderkamp: Why I’m Not Selfish for Getting Pregnant at 59

The messages arrived in a relentless stream, many of them as brief…

Biden Presidential Library Raises Just Over $1M in First Year

Joe Biden’s presidential library is confronting an early fundraising shortfall after the…

Nuclear Accident Risk Rises in Ukraine Amid Russian Airstrikes

International nuclear safety authorities warned Monday that Russia’s repeated strikes on Ukrainian…

Family of British Woman Killed by Fetish Chatroom User Fly to US Trial

The family of a woman who travelled to the United States after…

Jailed ex-Pakistan PM Imran Khan warns he may not return alive

Imran Khan, the imprisoned former prime minister of Pakistan, has warned that…

Robert Pattinson Confirmed as James Bond in Long-Awaited Reveal

Robert Pattinson has been confirmed as the next James Bond, bringing weeks…

John Summit’s Tour Bus Involved in Deadly Crash After Grammy Criticism

The tour bus belonging to John Summit, one of electronic dance music’s…

Trump Blasts CBS News Chief Bari Weiss Over 60 Minutes Report

Donald Trump criticized the new leadership at CBS News’ 60 Minutes after…

Three Sisters Win £1.6m Inheritance Battle Against Brother

Three sisters have secured a victory in a bitter £1.6million inheritance dispute…

Mexican Journalist Reporting on Missing People Killed in Acapulco

Eduardo Flores, a Mexican journalist who reported on missing-person cases, was killed…

SNL Alum Heidi Gardner’s Boyfriend Ray Tintori Dies at 43

Heidi Gardner’s boyfriend, filmmaker Ray Tintori, has died at 43. Tintori, who…