Democrat Mary Peltola has been declared the winner of Alaska’s most closely watched and fiercely disputed Senate contest.
Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan in his bid for another term, delivering Democrats their ninth Senate seat flipped in the midterm elections.
The Associated Press called the race two weeks after Election Day, with Peltola holding a 4.3-point advantage over Sullivan.
Alaska, traditionally one of the nation’s most reliably Republican states, became an unexpected center of national political attention.
Adding to the unusual contest was the presence of another candidate named Dan Sullivan: Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from the fishing community of Petersburg. His name appeared on the ballot as “Sullivan, Daniel J Jr.,” while the senator was listed as “Sullivan, Dan S.”
Republicans spent months accusing the second Sullivan of being a “decoy” candidate whose name was intended to mislead voters.
Election officials attempted to remove him from the ballot, arguing that his candidacy had not been submitted in good faith. The Alaska Supreme Court, however, ruled that he could remain in the race.
Although he denied being a political plant, he vanished from public view after a New York Times investigation made explosive allegations about his candidacy.
The newspaper reported that operatives connected to Peltola’s campaign, her attorneys and senior Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee aides had helped recruit him as part of an internal effort known as the “ballot composition project.”
Mary Peltola secured the largest share of votes in Alaska’s contentious Senate race
Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan was seeking a third term. He and other conservatives, including President Trump, repeatedly alleged that a second “decoy” Dan Sullivan had been placed on the ballot as a liberal-backed candidate
The Times said its report was based on interviews with 12 sources, along with text messages and other documents.
Both Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC denied having any role in the matter. Peltola said she “knew nothing” about the alleged effort, while Sullivan described it as the largest scandal in Alaska electoral history and accused her of “still lying.”
The investigation was published after almost 10 percent of Alaska’s registered voters had already cast their ballots. Governor Mike Dunleavy ordered an inquiry into the Peltola campaign, while Fox News, citing unnamed sources, reported that federal prosecutors had opened a criminal investigation.
Even before the report appeared, the Justice Department had sued Alaska election officials. The department asked a court to prevent certification if Sullivan lost and the second Sullivan’s votes would have affected the result under the state’s ranked-choice voting system. “Well, I’m one that said, ‘Do it,’” Trump said of the lawsuit.
The DOJ later revised its complaint to include the Times’ findings. Alaska Republican Senator Lisa Murkowski said the department should not have brought the case. Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC urged a judge to dismiss it, describing the lawsuit as an unprecedented pre-emptive challenge to a democratic election.
An Alaska judge ultimately dismissed the DOJ’s case, halting the Trump administration’s attempt to intervene before the results were certified.
The Justice Department had argued that Daniel J. Sullivan, whom the Trump administration labeled “Decoy Dan,” entered the contest as a “frivolous candidate” intended to confuse voters.
US District Judge Sharon Gleason ruled that the administration did not have standing to bring the lawsuit. The case sought to require Alaska to set aside the second Sullivan’s ballots if Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan lost his re-election bid to Peltola.
The DOJ has appealed the decision.
At the same time, a separate investigation by the House Oversight Committee is continuing.
The FBI has also intensified its criminal inquiry into the controversy surrounding Alaska’s alleged “decoy” candidate.
Two people familiar with the investigation told Our News Outlet that agents questioned former Peltola campaign manager Elisa Rios on Election Day.
According to the sources, FBI agents approached Rios in Chicago on Tuesday.
“Full speed ahead” was how one source characterized the investigation.
Rios was reportedly involved in efforts to recruit the second Dan Sullivan.
In the Times investigation, she said Peltola “definitely” knew about an alleged plan involving the DSCC to locate another Sullivan in an effort to improve her prospects of winning the Senate seat.
Rios said she left Peltola’s campaign in August during a broader staff reorganization, only months before the election. She did not explain the specific reason for her sudden departure.
Cheryl Bruce, previously the campaign’s deputy manager, replaced her.
Peltola, the latest Democrat to win statewide office in Alaska, first won the state’s lone House seat in a 2022 special election, defeating Sarah Palin through ranked-choice voting. She lost that seat in 2024 before Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer personally recruited her to run in the Senate contest.
The rising cost of living became one of the defining issues of the campaign.
In late August, a store in the remote village of Shungnak was charging $26.82 per gallon for gasoline, nearly double the $13.99 price posted the day before. The statewide average was slightly above $5 per gallon.
Peltola also shared images showing a rural grocery store selling a pack of paper plates for $53.99.
The Democrat blamed the soaring prices on the war in Iran and said Sullivan had voted in favor of it 14 times. Sullivan agreed that Alaskans were struggling with higher costs but attributed the problem to energy policies from the Biden administration.
Fish was another distinctive feature of the campaign. Peltola built part of her platform around the slogan “fish, family and freedom.”
She supported banning large trawlers based outside Alaska and expanding financial protections for local fishermen. Sullivan, meanwhile, said he wanted to keep foreign seafood fleets out of Alaska’s waters and away from US markets.
Their disagreement centered on which vessels should be allowed to operate in Alaska’s waters. Peltola sought to prohibit factory trawlers from the Lower 48 states, while Sullivan opposed that move and instead called for a ban on unregulated foreign operators.