Why is a travel guide warning tourists Edinburgh is best avoided?

Why a Travel Guide Warns Tourists to Avoid Visiting Edinburgh

A travel guide has advised visitors to think twice about travelling to Edinburgh, citing the Scottish capital’s growing problems with overtourism.

Fodor’s says the heavy concentration of tourists in the Old Town, the seasonal surges linked to major events, the spread of short-term holiday rentals and mounting pressure on public services have all placed strain on the city.

The travel publisher, which produces guidebooks and online advice, examined the challenges facing Edinburgh before concluding that travellers may be better off considering other destinations until conditions improve.

Edinburgh appears on Fodor’s 2026 ‘No List’, alongside seven other destinations. The guide’s list contrasts with its 27-place ‘Go List’ and highlights locations where it says infrastructure is ‘straining as a result of tourism, natural resources are under threat and residential communities are disrupted’.

Fodor’s says the situation also raises questions about who ultimately benefits from the tourism economy.

Concluding its assessment, the guide states: ‘For those who have already seen the castle, walked the Royal Mile, and experienced the festivals, there is a case for exploring somewhere less saturated until a balance is restored.’

Its report draws on research from other organisations, pointing to concerns including congestion, rising costs and the prevalence of short-term rental properties.

It cites a Post Office study which ranked Edinburgh as the third-most expensive of 50 cities surveyed, behind Oslo and Copenhagen. The research found that a two-night break for two people in three-star accommodation cost £668.

The guide added: ‘This is costlier than a weekend away to famously exorbitant cities like Dublin and London.’

Fodor’s also highlights the introduction in July of Scotland’s first city-wide visitor levy. The charge adds 5 per cent to overnight accommodation costs, capped at the first five consecutive nights of a stay in Edinburgh.

Revenue from the levy will support the City of Edinburgh Council’s Housing and Tourism Mitigation Fund, which aims to raise £5million each year and provide 472 affordable homes over the next three years.

Assessing the measure, Fodor’s states: ‘This is a meaningful attempt to make tourism contribute more directly to the city, but it also has limitations.

‘Day-trippers do not pay the overnight accommodation charge despite using streets, public spaces and transport.

‘Additionally, a levy does not automatically reduce visitor numbers or prevent overcrowding in the historic centre.’

The guide continues: ‘While tourism does bring visible economic benefits to Edinburgh, this does not invalidate the experiences of its residents who feel that their community has changed beyond recognition, lamenting in forums about unaffordability and housing shortages.’

The other destinations named on Fodor’s No List are the Albanian Riviera, Italy’s Amalfi Coast, Bali in Indonesia, the French island of Corsica, Kyoto in Japan, Tanzania’s Ngorongoro and Sedona in Arizona.

Jeremy Tarr, editorial director at Fodors.com, said: ‘The Go List celebrates destinations that offer something special, while the No List looks at places where the pressures of tourism have become difficult to ignore.

‘We encourage travellers to keep exploring, but to be thoughtful about where they go and the choices they make along the way.’

He added: ‘The No List isn’t about writing off these destinations. They’re still remarkable places with a great deal to offer travellers.

‘It’s about recognising that even places we love to visit can face challenges when tourism grows beyond what local communities and environments can comfortably support.

‘We hope the list encourages people to look beyond a destination’s appeal and consider the long-term impact of their visit.’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Mohamed Hadid, 78, Engaged to Brazilian Model Keni Silva, 43

Mohamed Hadid has announced his engagement to his significantly younger partner, Keni…

Pregnant Jetstar Passenger Receives Refund After Being Told to Wear a Jacket

Jetstar has refunded the fare of a 32-weeks-pregnant passenger after cabin crew…

Danielle Lopez’s Remains Found 2½ Years After She Vanished in NJ

The remains of Danielle Lopez, a New Jersey woman who disappeared while…

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s Daughter Madison Accused of Bullying, Report Says

After Jensen Huang was forced out of Nvidia following revelations about his…

Mexican Journalist Reporting on Missing People Killed in Acapulco

Eduardo Flores, a Mexican journalist who reported on missing-person cases, was killed…

Dr Renee Hoenderkamp: Why I’m Not Selfish for Getting Pregnant at 59

The messages arrived in a relentless stream, many of them as brief…

Economist Warns Interest Rate Pain Could Get Worse

As an economist, I hear the same question almost everywhere I go:…

Bachelor Star Sam Wood’s Explosive Prison Call Played in Court

Bachelor star Sam Wood made an emotional prison phone call to his…

Teen Gang Caught Setting Fire to Historic Mansion

This is the moment five balaclava-wearing teenagers were caught setting fire to…

95-Year-Old Widow Faces £1m Court Bill in Fence Boundary Dispute with Neighbour

A 95-year-old widow is facing legal costs of more than £1 million…

Why Some Gyms Are Banning Scantily Clad Women From Workouts

Mitch Parsons, a 31-year-old wealth management professional, was visiting Chicago for work…

Woman Fought to See Migrant Jailed After Her Rape Case Was Dropped

A woman raped by a small-boat migrant fought to have him jailed…