A 95-year-old widow is facing legal costs of more than £1 million after losing the latest stage of a bitter, decade-long dispute with her wealthy neighbours over a garden fence.
Mary Egan’s battle with businessman Neil Morgan, 65, and his 61-year-old wife Fiona began in 2016, after the couple installed a fence between their adjoining country properties in an affluent Kent village.
The disagreement involved a strip of land measuring just 60 metres. During the proceedings, Mr Morgan described his elderly neighbour as “poisonous” and “malevolent” and accused one judge of being “not fit to judge vegetables at a village fete”.
Although Mrs Egan was awarded damages after a court found that the Morgans had trespassed on her land, a judge later characterised the outcome as a “score draw” and ordered both sides to cover their own legal expenses.
Mrs Egan, who has spent more than £1 million on legal representation over the past 10 years, appealed. She argued that the Morgans’ “deplorable” conduct should have made them responsible for her costs.
The High Court has now rejected that appeal, leaving the widow to meet the seven-figure bill herself.
The dispute dates back to 2015, when the Morgans, owners of the 17th-century Sissinghurst Court in the historic village of Sissinghurst near Tunbridge Wells, put up a new fence along the edge of their garden and Mrs Egan’s land.
The couple, who run a number of businesses, said they were replacing an existing fence because it had deteriorated and was allowing their dogs and cats to escape.
Mrs Egan argued that the replacement had been built on her property and accused the couple of entering her land without permission.
Mary Egan’s legal battle with businessman Neil Morgan, 65, and his wife Fiona, 61, began in 2016 after they erected a fence between their neighbouring country homes in an affluent Kent village
The dispute began in 2015 when the Morgans (above), owners of the 17th-century Sissinghurst Court in the historic village of Sissinghurst near Tunbridge Wells, installed a new fence beside Mrs Egan’s land
Lawyers for Mrs Egan said the Morgans had crossed onto her property, taken down an existing wooden fence and installed new posts.
After Mrs Egan removed a replacement fence, the couple put up another in January 2016, this time supported by concrete posts.
The conflict intensified when the Morgans sued Mrs Egan for damaging their fence. She responded with a counterclaim for trespass and asked the court to declare that the boundary ran through the centre of the line of trees and hedges between the properties.
At a 2021 trial at Maidstone County Court, Recorder John Dagnall dismissed the Morgans’ case and ruled that they had trespassed on Mrs Egan’s land.
He awarded the widow £2,600 in damages, followed by a further £3,250 after deciding that the third fence could remain as the new boundary rather than being removed.
However, he rejected her claim that the legal boundary ran through the middle of the hedge.
At a later hearing in 2024, the judge described the result as a “score draw” and ordered both parties to pay their own legal costs.
The Morgans had incurred a six-figure bill before mostly representing themselves, while Mrs Egan had retained lawyers throughout the case. As a result, her costs rose above £1 million.
Appearing for Mrs Egan at the latest hearing, barrister Daniel Petrides argued that she had been the successful party and should not be left with such a substantial financial burden.
He also claimed that Mr Morgan had subjected lawyers, judges and court employees to repeated personal attacks during the litigation.
“The level of personal invective with which the claimants, and particularly Mr Morgan, have seen fit to bombard Mrs Egan’s advisors, judges and other professionals is simply staggering.”
One junior lawyer was called a “lying hypocritical devious arse of spectacular proportions”, while another was described as a “conceited, sanctimonious, conniving hypocrite”.
MUST READ: Jennifer Lawrence, 36, and Her Changing Look Through the Years
A further solicitor was accused of “sheer stupidity” and given the nickname “Mr I-qualified-last-week”.
Judges were also targeted. Deputy District Judge Swales was described during an earlier hearing as “an offensive, provocative and prejudiced man”.
In a later letter to the court, he was branded “moronic and genuinely not fit to judge vegetables at a village fete”.
Mr Petrides said Mrs Egan had also been subjected to unusually harsh personal insults despite her age.
“Mrs Egan herself – a 95-year-old widow – has been described in correspondence as ‘patronising’, ‘arrogant’, ‘malevolent’ and ‘frankly poisonous’,” he said.
“Some similarly colourful language – ‘all-knowing self-appointed royalty’ – about her even found its way into the particulars of claim before they were amended.”
The barrister said the conduct had needlessly increased the legal costs and should have influenced the decision over who was responsible for paying them.
“It is not acceptable to treat junior lawyers as punchbags and the court should be astute to discourage such conduct in the course of litigation via the use of its costs powers,” he said.
He challenged the description of the case as a draw, noting that Mrs Egan had defeated the Morgans’ claim and secured damages after proving trespass.
“The only correct analysis can be that a party which has defeated a claim against it and succeeded on its counterclaim is the ‘successful party’. It is not a ‘score draw’, it is a 4-0 win.
“Mrs Egan, who is the defendant in these proceedings, did not choose to be sued. Having been sued, her costs of successfully vindicating her rights have been considerable: in excess of £1m over more than a decade of litigation.
“This has been in no small part due to the extraordinary and disproportionate approach of the claimants. For her to be denied any meaningful recovery in respect of those costs was profoundly unjust and wrong.”
Mr Morgan, who represented himself and his wife at the appeal, said they had been provoked into responding and that only his occasional outbursts were being highlighted.
“Most of the time we bit our lip,” he said.
“The few occasions when I responded pithily are now being used.”
He argued that the central issue had always been who owned the trees and hedge, rather than the modest damages awarded to Mrs Egan.
Calling the case a “battle” over the trees, he said the boundary question accounted for 95 per cent of the dispute.
“She didn’t litigate for £5,000 worth of damages – not for 10 years. She didn’t get the rewards she was looking for. A small amount of damages doesn’t bear a conversion into a victory. This wasn’t about money. It never was.
“We put a fence up where there had always been a fence. We put it up because the old one had fallen down and our dogs and cats were getting out.
“We put the fence up where we believed the boundary had always been.”
Mr Morgan maintained that he and his wife were the actual winners because Mrs Egan had failed to prove that the boundary passed through the hedge.
Dismissing the appeal, Mr Justice Tappin accepted that Mr Morgan’s language towards lawyers and court officials had been unacceptable. However, he ruled that the original judge was entitled to conclude that it did not justify ordering the couple to pay Mrs Egan’s legal costs.