The mother of 17-year-old Xavier Nungaray-Martinez, who plunged to his death from the fourth floor of his Los Angeles high school following an alleged bullying incident, is condemning county officials after a medical examiner ruled his death a suicide and determined that he threw the first punch in a classroom fight.
“The Los Angeles County Medical Examiner’s conclusion that Xavier died by suicide is completely unsupported by any credible evidence we’ve seen,” Lilia Nungaray’s attorney, Spencer Lucas, told the California Post. “The violence that preceded Xavier’s death cannot simply be disregarded before concluding that he intentionally took his own life.”
Lucas spoke after the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner’s Office determined Tuesday that Xavier “intentionally jumped” following a Sept. 30 altercation at Franklin High School.
According to the report, the teenager punched a male classmate, who struck him several times in return, shortly before Xavier went over the fourth-floor railing. Investigators also concluded that he attempted to “forcibly kiss a female student,” who pushed him away.
“We have serious questions about who was interviewed, what evidence was reviewed, and whether the medical examiner distinguished the head and brain injuries Xavier suffered during two separate assaults from injuries sustained in the fall,” Lucas told The Post on Lilia’s behalf.
Xavier’s parents have each filed separate claims alleging that the school district was negligent. The district denied his mother’s claim, and her attorneys are now moving forward with a lawsuit. Lawyers representing Xavier’s father, William Amayo, anticipate that the district will reject his claim as well.
“Equally outrageous is the way Xavier’s mother has been treated. We repeatedly requested the medical examiner’s report but received nothing. Yet the findings were released to the media today without any notice to Lilia or her family,” Lucas said.
“She is devastated and understandably furious,” he added.
Attorneys for both parents said LAUSD has refused to provide even basic information, including details about previous bullying incidents, the name of the alleged bully and the identity of the substitute teacher who was in the classroom.
Both claims allege that the teacher did not physically intervene and instead only shouted at the students to stop.
“This mother has already endured the unimaginable loss of her son, and now she has been blindsided by a determination she was never given the opportunity to review or challenge,” Lucas said.
The attorneys also said the family has received no condolences from the district or the superintendent since Xavier’s death.
“She deserves answers and compassion, not this kind of disregard,” Lucas said.