New York City’s criminal and family courts are set for a significant reshuffling under Mayor Zohran Mamdani.
This week, Mamdani announced 10 new judicial appointments while renewing the terms of six sitting judges. Most of the new nominees have backgrounds as public defenders, and one of the returning judges has drawn criticism from law enforcement groups for what they describe as a notably lenient approach to bail.
Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Valentina Morales, a former Harlem public defender appointed by Mayor Bill de Blasio in 2021, has been given the nickname “Judge Let-em-Go” by some police and prosecutors.
From January through June 2024, Morales released 83 of 101 defendants accused of violent felonies without requiring bail, according to the report. Among those defendants was Eric Taylor, a repeat offender who had previously been convicted of two felonies and nearly two dozen misdemeanors.
Morales was serving in Bronx Criminal Court in 2022 when she released former convict Frankie Centeno on electronic monitoring in a gun case. Prosecutors had requested either $100,000 in cash bail or a $300,000 bond. Centeno later fled the country and was eventually arrested again.
In another case, Morales released Venezuelan migrant Walter Almachi Leal without bail after he was accused of cutting a 43-year-old man with a broken beer bottle in 2023. Last year, she also ordered electronic monitoring for 18-year-old Kalifa Quattara, described as a member of the “Up the Hill” gang, following an alleged shootout with rivals.
Morales is not the only judge with a controversial record to receive another appointment under the Democratic socialist mayor.
Queens Criminal Court Judge Jennifer Saint-Preux, a former Legal Aid attorney who joined the bench last year, declined prosecutors’ request in August to keep alleged career criminal Shaquan Seth jailed without bail. Seth reportedly had nearly 150 prior arrests.
Instead, Saint-Preux ordered Seth held on a $10,000 bond.
RELATED: US Infrastructure Is Crumbling as Adversaries Build Cyber Power, Expert Warns
The judges returning to the bench also include Acting Queens Supreme Court Justice Toni Cimino, a former criminal defense attorney who became a judge in 2016; Judge Tamiko Amaker, the deputy chief administrative judge for criminal court, who was appointed by de Blasio in 2017; and Bronx Criminal Court Judge Joseph Sorrentino, a former chief appellate court attorney who took the bench in 2024.
Bronx Family Court Judge Juanita Wing completes the list of reappointments. She previously worked as an attorney for the state Administration for Children’s Services before becoming a judge in 2024.
City Hall said all of the nominees will face a public hearing Tuesday after being reviewed by the Mayor’s Advisory Committee on the Judiciary.
“The decision made in our courts can change the course of a New Yorker’s life,” Mamdani said in a statement. “That is why the people entrusted with serving on the bench must bring the highest standards of fairness, integrity and accountability to their work.”
According to the mayor’s office, at least six of the 10 nominees for the city’s criminal and family courts are current or former public defenders.
The criminal court nominees include former Legal Aid attorneys Alexis Flyer and Molly Gallivan. William Kendall previously worked as a supervising attorney at Neighborhood Defender Services in Harlem.
Hana Kim and Melissa Medilien, two additional criminal court nominees, previously served as prosecutors in the Queens District Attorney’s Office.
Among Mamdani’s five family court picks, Mary Cheng, who worked in Maryland, and Beth Krause have Legal Aid backgrounds. Brian Holbrook is senior attorney for law and appeals at Brooklyn Defender Services.
The remaining family court nominees include Deana Tietjen, deputy director at the Children’s Law Center and a former legal awareness adviser in Westchester County, and Danielle Rodriguez, who most recently served as a court attorney referee in Queens, according to City Hall.