Stephen A. Smith is facing accusations of racism from viewers and an ESPN colleague after again suggesting that the 13-2 Los Angeles Lakers could be too white to win an NBA championship.
Smith’s focus on the Lakers’ racial makeup resurfaced on ESPN Wednesday, days after he questioned the team’s white stars—Luka Doncic, Austin Reaves and Walker Kessler—during a podcast. While acknowledging that “these white brothers can play,” Smith challenged the league’s Black stars to prevent Los Angeles from winning it all.
“Y’all gonna let them win a championship?” Smith asked Wednesday on ESPN’s First Take.
Jay Williams, an ESPN NBA analyst and occasional First Take co-host, sharply criticized Smith’s remarks, arguing that they reflected a deeply troubling view of race. Williams was not part of Wednesday’s broadcast.
“This sounds like something you’d hear in the 1930s or 1940s, just with the racial dynamics reversed,” Williams, who was not on Wednesday’s episode, wrote on X. “Think about how disturbing that is. We spent generations fighting to ensure athletes were judged by their talent, not the color of their skin.
“Now we’re openly questioning whether Black players should allow white players to win? At what point does fighting against discrimination turn into perpetuating the same mentality we fought so hard to overcome?”
Smith takes questions from reporters following a meeting with US President Donald J. Trump
Lakers guards Luka Doncic (left) and Austin Reaves (right) are seen on November 1
Lakers players Ziaire Williams (11), Luka Doncic (77), Jake LaRavia (12) and Walker Kessler (14) wait during a timeout against the Suns during a game on Sunday, November 15
Smith has since responded to Williams, a former Duke star whose NBA career was derailed by a motorcycle accident.
‘Thanks for reaching out @RealJayWilliams,’ Smith wrote on X. ‘Always appreciate it! You can bring up that b.s. all you want about the 1930’s, but I’m talking about right now.
‘I love this challenge to the fellas. I want to see if this generation of players are gonna succumbed to these @Lakers. I said what I said and I meant what I meant. But I don’t hear you denying that what I said is true.
‘I’m done with this convo,’ he concluded. ‘You know where the hell to find me.’
As for the public, many appeared to side with Williams.
‘I thought sports is where we went to escape from the toxicity of the daily grind,’ one fan responded to Williams. ‘Stephen A wants to make it a whole new arena for it.’
Others accused Smith of returning to the subject to drive viewership.
YOU MAY ALSO READ: US Army Soldiers Reenlist for Rare Chance to Play GTA 6
‘Whether it’s politics or pundits, anchoring your content on identity drives maximum engagement at minimum substance,’ one critic wrote.
Smith insisted current and former NBA players told him in private that they agreed with his take, but some viewers remained skeptical.
‘I feel like 99% of the players in the NBA are worried about how they can make their team win, not about denying a different team with a lot of white players,’ one fan wrote.
He first approached the subject on his podcast last week, saying he’d never seen a team with three white stars win an NBA title: ‘You can bring up whoever the hell you want. There has never been in my lifetime an NBA team led with its top three players being white that delivered you a championship with an abundance of brothers playing basketball.’
Lakers teammates Luka Doncic (left) and Austin Reaves (right) are now 10-2 on the year
Some counterexamples were offered amid the furious social media response, but Smith was born in 1967, so he wasn’t considering the 1958 St. Louis Hawks and their trio of Bob Pettit, Slater Martin and Cliff Hagan. Likewise, many suggested the 1980s Boston Celtics trio of Larry Bird, Kevin McHale and Danny Ainge, but that omits Hall-of-Fame center Robert Parish, who is Black and was easily among the best three players on that team.
On Wednesday, Smith appeared to take particular delight in returning to the subject. Not only did he use a playful voice to explain his point, but he carefully measured out each syllable for maximum effect.
‘It’s very, very important, as we’re watching sports today with all the money that’s being exchanged, you want little motivational nuggets to nudge cats a little bit,’ Smith told his ESPN co-hosts. ‘I’m looking at the brothers, and I’m saying, LA doing special things.’
In addition to naming the Lakers’ JJ Redick as a candidate for NBA Coach of the Year, Smith went on to stress that ‘these white brothers can play.’
Fans have been accusing Smith of racism since he first broached the subject last week.
‘So we’re all ok with racism now I guess,’ one fan wrote on X.
(From left) Lakers teammates Quentin Grimes, Luka Doncic, Austin Reaves and Walker Kessler
‘Racist Stephen A Smith on display!!’ another added. ‘Imagine if a white guy says about black guy in the same manner.’
One X user with the handle ‘MAGA Patriot’ tagged ESPN to demand the network ‘cut ties and fire Stephen A. Smith.’
‘There’s no place in Sports Journalism for the type of Racist Statement’s he’s made and continues to make concerning the makeup of the Lakers Roster and Starting lineup,’ MAGA Patriot wrote on X.
Despite last week’s comments, Smith insisted at the time he was rooting for the Lakers to win a title, which he believes would be good for the NBA, the sport and the 2028 Summer Olympics in Los Angeles.
‘It would be huge for the league,’ he said on his podcast last week. ‘It would be huge for the Olympics. It would be huge for LA. It would be huge for everything, but it ain’t gonna happen. I can’t see it. Not a team with its top three players being white dudes.
‘I’m sorry, I think that’s controversial in some people’s eyes. It ain’t controversial in mine. I’m just telling you how it is. I’m calling it like I see it.’