San Diego Unified School District has proposed an unusual approach to shaping its future: giving students a voice in choosing the people who oversee their schools.
The district’s board voted unanimously Tuesday to support allowing 16- and 17-year-olds to vote in school board elections. The resolution now heads to San Diego City Hall, where it would need approval before moving forward.
The proposal comes only two weeks after Culver City voters rejected a similar measure for the second time. In 2022, that initiative fell short by just 16 votes.
San Diego Unified’s resolution argues that voting can become a lifelong habit. Allowing teenagers to participate while they are still in high school—alongside civics education and encouragement from teachers and families—could help establish lasting voting patterns, the board said.
As an example, the resolution cites Takoma Park, Maryland, which lowered its voting age to 16 in 2013.
In Takoma Park, 44% of eligible 16- and 17-year-olds voted in a city election, compared with 10% turnout among voters overall. The resolution also references countries—including Austria, Brazil, Germany and Cuba—that allow 16-year-olds to vote and have higher participation rates than the United States.
San Diego students say they should have a direct say in decisions affecting their daily lives.
“I think that is important for students like me to have a say in the decisions and policies that affect us, like school funding, resources and safety,” one San Diego Unified student told CBS 8.
“We want more people to be voting for whatever is going on in our school, since we are living that daily life,” another student told the station. “I just think it would get more students engaged.”
The school board cannot enact the change by itself. Because San Diego Unified’s elections are governed by the city charter, voters would need to approve a charter amendment.
The proposal has drawn criticism from education leaders, who say the district should focus on academic struggles and a projected $138 million budget shortfall.
“You can’t help but laugh,” Sonja Shaw, president of the Chino Valley Unified School District board, told the California Post. Shaw lost this month’s race for state superintendent to San Diego Unified board President Richard Barrera.
“Half of the kids in San Diego Unified can’t read at grade level and are struggling in math, and the board’s brilliant response is to hand ballots to high schoolers so they can help pick the next group of adults who will keep ignoring the problem. It’s the educational equivalent of rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.”
California’s second-largest school district enrolled 112,250 students during the 2025-26 school year, according to state data.
Student performance on the latest state English exams showed the sharpest decline among California’s five largest districts. The percentage of students meeting or exceeding standards dropped 2.27 percentage points, from 56.17% to 53.90%.
Math results improved by just 0.54 percentage points to 45.85%, leaving more than half of students below proficiency.
The district is also facing serious financial pressure.
To balance its approximately $2 billion general fund budget for 2025-26, San Diego Unified closed a $112.7 million deficit largely by reducing central-office spending and redirecting restricted funds. The district is spending about $176 million more than it receives this year and will still need to identify roughly $138 million in additional cuts or other solutions for 2026-27, when one-time funding expires.
In 2018, the board agreed to pursue a 2020 ballot measure that would have allowed 16- and 17-year-olds to vote for school trustees, but the measure never made it onto the ballot.
Teenagers in Oakland and Berkeley cast their first school board ballots in 2024, several years after voters in those cities approved lowering the voting age.
The Post contacted San Diego Unified and Barrera for comment.