When worried parents finally exposed childminder Amanda Mathewson’s shocking betrayal, their deepest fears were confirmed. Suspicious that their children were being neglected, they went to her home and opened the unlocked front door.
Inside, they discovered a horrifying scene: more than two dozen children had been left without adult supervision, exposed to the risk of serious injury or worse.
A distressed two-year-old was crying beneath a kitchen table, while other children had been confined to a utility room. Five primary-aged children were outside in the garden, and upstairs the parents found their own two young children locked in a bedroom with nine abandoned babies and toddlers.
As the horrified father carried two children downstairs, Mathewson returned. Doorbell-camera footage later showed that she had been away for more than 30 minutes for the second time that day.
The father, who cannot be named for legal reasons, said: ‘As Amanda walked back in the front door, she looked up at me and we locked eyes. I will never forget it, she looked like a child who had been caught in the act of doing something they knew they shouldn’t.’
‘I said to her, “What the hell, Amanda? How many laws have you broken here?”
‘Her soul just left her body. She realised her life as she knew it was over, she was caught, she was done.’
Amanda Mathewson, 55, was sentenced to two years in prison at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court earlier this month
Earlier this month, Mathewson, 55, was jailed for two years at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court after admitting that she had wilfully neglected, abandoned and exposed children to the possibility of unnecessary suffering or injury.
On August 26, 2024, the day her deception was uncovered, 27 children were found at her home in Dunfermline. Fifteen were under 12, ten were below primary-school age and two were younger than one.
Mathewson’s licence allowed her to care for a maximum of eight children under 12, including no more than three below primary-school age and one under the age of one.
Among the children discovered on the day of her arrest was a girl with significant developmental disabilities who had previously suffered neglect. Two other children were found strapped into prams.
After her arrest, Mathewson herself admitted: ‘God knows what could have happened to those kids.’
She pleaded guilty and is now in prison, but the families’ concerns remain. A lawyer representing them is examining possible legal action in an effort to prevent anything similar from happening again.
More than 50 children from around 40 families are known to have used Mathewson’s services during the period covered by the charges, from September 30, 2023, to August 27, 2024.
Children who spent time in her care continue to experience night terrors and may face lasting psychological trauma.
Their parents have been left battling misplaced guilt while worrying about the effect of the distress on their children.
The court heard that one child developed an intense sense of responsibility for protecting younger siblings. Another said he had been strapped into a buggy for an extended period; when he tried to wriggle beneath the straps, they tightened around his neck and another child had to free him.
One girl refuses to leave her bedroom without permission. Other children have become clingy and wary, while some parents have suffered such severe psychological consequences that they have abandoned jobs because they no longer trust anyone else to keep their children safe.
Children who were cared for by Mathewson continue to suffer night terrors and could face long-term trauma
Parents fear that the full consequences of Mathewson’s actions may not become apparent in their children for many years.
The damage reaches beyond the families directly involved. The case has undermined confidence in childminding and raised serious questions about the official safeguards intended to protect children, after Mathewson’s deception went undetected for almost a year.
Her wrongdoing came to light only after the parents who exposed her realised their children were not with Mathewson on a school run and entered the house while she was away.
Without that intervention, it is impossible to know how much longer her elaborate deception might have continued.
The families’ anger deepened when it emerged that an employee of the childminding regulator, the Care Inspectorate, had been warning Mathewson before unannounced inspections.
There had been several missed opportunities to uncover the truth. In June 2024, two months before Mathewson’s arrest, the Care Inspectorate received a complaint about child-to-carer ratios and inadequate monitoring of children upstairs. The watchdog failed to act on those concerns.
Mathewson did more than neglect the children. She used them as unwitting participants in her scheme, assigning primary-aged children caring duties and telling them to hide and remain silent whenever parents or other adults arrived.
Babies and toddlers were kept upstairs, and one five-year-old girl later told her mother that Mathewson had placed her at a bedroom door to stop the younger children from wandering away.
The mother said: ‘My daughter was effectively in charge, making sure they stayed up there and stayed quiet.’ Another parent said her child had been left to change babies’ nappies and had to ‘sneak biscuits because they didn’t get to eat anything’.
Primary-aged children were often kept downstairs in the utility room, sometimes behind a closed door, and told not to come out while parents were present. They sat on the floor playing with iPads and were given crisps and doughnuts. Children as young as five were also left to make their way to and from school alone and told to wait in the garden when Mathewson was away.
The court heard that some children returned home extremely thirsty, while their clothes remained implausibly clean despite diary entries describing messy meals. Several parents said their children had not been given the food recorded in the diaries and had instead received biscuits or sweets.
Children were collected in soiled nappies, with dried faeces on their underwear or soaked clothing after wetting themselves. Some had unexplained scratches or bite marks, yet no accident reports had been completed. It appeared Mathewson had not been present to prevent the incidents or explain how the injuries occurred.
Amanda Mathewson, pictured left, at Kirkcaldy before she was jailed
Mathewson routinely produced a convincing explanation, and parents believed her because she was regarded as a respected community figure who had worked as a childminder for 30 years.
Their confidence was reinforced by an unannounced Care Inspectorate visit to her home roughly a year before her arrest. The inspection rated areas including care, learning and the setting as ‘very good’, the second-highest level on the quality scale.
The report described a ‘comfortable, welcoming and homely environment’ where children were treated ‘with warmth, kindness and a nurturing approach’.
EXPLORE MORE: WhatsApp ‘Affair Mode’: Settings Cheaters Use to Hide Chats
However, it now appears Mathewson may have known that inspectors were coming. A legal case will argue that the regulatory failure created or extended a foreseeable risk of harm to the children.
When sentencing Mathewson, Sheriff John MacRitchie highlighted the deliberate nature of her conduct and condemned it as a ‘gross abuse of a position of trust’.
Many parents regarded Mathewson as a friend. One described securing a place with her as ‘winning the childcare lottery’. Most new business came through personal recommendations.
The effort she put into maintaining the deception was extensive. Behind a carefully constructed facade, she hid her disregard for the children entrusted to her.
She told parents that other adults or childminders were present in the house when they were not.
To disguise the noise of the children inside, Mathewson played loud music near the front door when parents arrived and prepared the children for rapid handovers. She hid extra children’s bags and shoes, invented daily diary entries and insisted that parents text before arriving so she had time to move children out of sight.
Mathewson also created a system that kept parents outside the house. She said the doorstep collection arrangement introduced during Covid had worked well.
She claimed that children became distressed when unfamiliar adults entered the property.
One father, however, said that when he collected his children from inside the house, everything appeared entirely normal.
Sheriff MacRitchie told Mathewson: ‘You knowingly created conditions in which injury, terror and neglect were obvious and foreseeable. You knew the risks and continued’
He said: ‘I would go into the kitchen dining room and there would be kids, including my daughter, playing with toys. We would say a few words and say our goodbyes and go. It just felt like any other childminder’s house.
‘It is now sickening to think that she must have had children in other rooms squirrelled away.’
The day of Mathewson’s arrest was not an isolated incident. Leaving large numbers of children without adult supervision for hours had become routine.
She concealed her actions with calculated dishonesty. At Christmas, she took three children to a church party and sent them home with photographs of them smiling alongside Santa.
For the six children left behind, she arranged a generic festive photograph designed to make their parents believe they had attended the event.
She frequently selected only some of the children for outings. On one occasion, she visited another childminder with three of the eight children in her care, while taking three of 11 children on a two-hour trip to a fire station.
She took four of six children on a woodland walk and, on another day, brought five to a park while eight remained alone at the house.
Sheriff MacRitchie told her: ‘You knowingly created conditions in which injury, terror and neglect were obvious and foreseeable. You knew the risks and continued.’
It is difficult to understand how Mathewson could show such disregard for the safety of vulnerable children, although greed was clearly one of the driving factors.
Friends said she was often carrying plenty of cash. She owned two cars: one used for transporting children and another kept immaculate and free of child-related mess.
She was generous when eating out, enjoyed holidays, manicures and Botox, and lived on a desirable leafy street in Dunfermline where homes sell for an average of £600,000.
Kim Leslie, a partner at Irwin Mitchell Scotland who specialises in personal injury and child abuse law, is representing several families whose children were cared for by Mathewson.
Parents wait to enter court for the sentencing verdict in the Amanda Mathewson case
Ms Leslie has been asked to investigate a possible civil claim against the Care Inspectorate. She said: ‘It beggars belief that a failing of this magnitude could go unnoticed.
‘The families involved have found it extremely distressing and are desperate to ensure that no other family ever has to go through something like this.’
Bringing a claim may prove difficult because the Care Inspectorate, as a public body, does not owe children a direct duty of care. However, the disclosure that one of its employees passed confidential information to Mathewson could provide a possible basis for civil proceedings.
Ms Leslie said: ‘That’s simply not good enough and it cannot be allowed to happen again. This is a fundamental breach of trust which, by the regulator’s own admission, completely compromised the efficacy of regulatory scrutiny. The parents want the Care Inspectorate to be held to account.’
The Care Inspectorate described Mathewson’s criminal conduct as ‘shocking’ but declined to confirm whether the employee suspected of informing her had been identified. The person may still work for the organisation.
After Mathewson’s conviction, the Care Inspectorate said it had reviewed its internal processes and introduced revised procedures covering inspections, complaints and conflicts of interest.
Public liability insurance would normally be a potential route for compensation, but one of Mathewson’s insurers confirmed that her policy had been voided and would not explain why.
Unlike motor insurance, public liability cover is not recorded on a central database. Lawyers must therefore rely on Mathewson disclosing whether she held any other policies.
Parents had taken comfort from the requirement for registered childminders to hold insurance, but when support was needed, that apparent safety net seemed to have disappeared.
The families want regulatory loopholes closed. Despite the number of government-funded placements at Mathewson’s home, they say no warning signs were triggered by sudden increases in the number of children, even though those totals clearly exceeded her legal limits.
Ms Leslie said the case had had an intolerable effect on the families.
She added: ‘Mathewson was a master manipulator who was very seasoned and skilled at this deception. It is a parent’s worst nightmare.’