Nurse caught on video silencing baby's ventilator alarms

Inset: Eden Garcia (Sanders Funeral Home). Background: News footage of Debra Fraher outside court (KCBD).

A Texas woman who spent five decades working as a nurse has been convicted of allowing a disabled infant in her care to die.

Debra Fraher, 71, was sentenced to 10 years in prison Thursday after a jury found her guilty of injury to a child by reckless omission. Court documents obtained by local ABC affiliate KAMC say Fraher had been hired to care for 4-month-old Eden Garcia, a child with special needs who relied on a ventilator to breathe. On Jan. 18, 2023, video showed Fraher changing Eden’s diaper when the infant began having difficulty breathing. Although the ventilator alarms sounded, Fraher did not respond.

Eden’s mother entered the room moments later and found her baby turning blue.

Emergency medical technicians were summoned to the home, and Eden was taken to a hospital. She died eight days later, on Jan. 26, 2023.

According to courtroom reporting from local NBC affiliate KCBD, prosecutors argued that Fraher heard the alarms but merely reset them instead of investigating the problem. When the alarms went off again, she reset them a second time. Assistant District Attorney Mandi Saye said in her closing argument, “Two machines told her there was a problem… She knew these were lifesaving machines and didn’t pay attention when they went off.”

Assistant District Attorney Cassie Grahm told jurors that Fraher had informed an investigator that, when an issue arises, the tube must be checked from the machine to the patient. However, Grahm said, the former nurse “never checked the tube the way she said you should.”

During closing arguments, Fraher’s defense attorney, Charles Blevins, said, “Sixteen seconds after they discover the girl is blue, [Fraher] has the airbag in her hand and is working to fix things. She is heard on camera that she is sorry and that she did not see the tube had fallen out. This was not some story she made up later. She was doing all she could right then.”

Blevins also emphasized that Fraher had worked in the medical field for 50 years and had “never seen a tracheal come out before.”

Blevins further pointed out that the medical examiner determined Eden’s cause of death was an accidental dislodgement of her tracheal tube.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

16-Year-Old Accused of Killing Twin Brother Before Their Mom

Background: The Washington, D.C., home where authorities say the shooting took place…

Brooker Man Arrested for Allegedly Stealing Nearly $7K in Copper Welding Leads From Employer

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Joseph Edward Deavers, 31, faces a grand…

Police Say Man Fatally Stomped Ex’s Alleged Lover Over Cheating

Inset: Quinton Graham in court. Background: The scene outside the Las Vegas…

Man Convicted of Stabbing Teen Girl 53 Times in Fatal Attack

Top inset: Isaac Arndt (Moorhead Police Department). Bottom inset: Jaelyn Walker (Korsmo…

Woman Told Boyfriend Her Secret Lover Was an Intruder, Police Say

Inset: Lasacia Gore (Macomb County Jail). Background: An Eastpointe, Michigan, neighborhood where…

Police: Mother Told 911 Dispatchers She Shot Her Two Children

Share copy link Inset: Awo Duale (Scott County Sheriff’s Office). Background: News…

Gainesville Man Arrested After Alleged Attack on Co-Worker

Staff report ALACHUA, Fla. – Deontae Reshard Mavin, 24, of Gainesville, faces…