Man convicted of stabbing 'lovesick' teen girl 53 times

Top inset: Isaac Arndt (Moorhead Police Department). Bottom inset: Jaelyn Walker (Korsmo Funeral Home). Background: Police investigate after Arndt killed Walker in Moorhead, Minnesota (KVLY/YouTube).

A Minnesota judge has convicted a 20-year-old man of stabbing his 14-year-old former girlfriend dozens of times, cutting her throat, hugging her and then fleeing the scene on a scooter.

Isaac Arthur Arndt was found guilty of first-degree murder in the death of Jaelyn Walker in Moorhead, a Minnesota city along the border with North Dakota.

According to a courtroom report from Fargo, North Dakota, by NBC affiliate KVLY, the eight-day trial concluded on Oct. 28. Prosecutors and defense attorneys submitted written closing arguments to Judge Tammy Merkins, who delivered her verdict on Thursday.

The guilty verdict brought relief to the 60 relatives and friends who filled the courtroom and gathered outside the courthouse in support of Jaelyn. Many wore T-shirts featuring her face inside a heart.

Jaelyn’s mother, Amanda Gullekson, emerged from the courthouse and shouted, “We did it!” according to the local Forum of Fargo–Moorhead newspaper. Family members said the conviction was “what we hoped for.”

“There is going to be relief, and he will never be on the streets to hurt anybody again. That was our goal,” Gullekson told reporters outside the courthouse, according to The Forum.

Gullekson said she had hoped Arndt, who was 18 when he killed Jaelyn, would show some reaction as the verdict was announced. She said she saw none.

“I was hoping for a little bit of remorse, and there was absolutely none shown,” she reportedly said.

In closing arguments, prosecutors said Arndt “played on the emotions of a lovesick teenager to lure her out of her home to put an end to what to him was an inconvenience.” They said he attacked her in a secluded area, stabbing her 53 times before dragging her body to the riverbank in the hope that it would float away.

Defense attorneys argued that Arndt had committed a “rash and unconsidered act” and panicked afterward.

According to a probable cause statement, Arndt entered the Clay County Law Enforcement Center at around 11 p.m. on Aug. 19, 2024, to report an assault. He had cuts on two fingers.

Arndt told police that he and Jaelyn had been at Gooseberry Park when an “unknown white male” began following them. He said the man attacked him with a knife as he ran away, according to the affidavit.

About 90 minutes after Arndt made his report, Jaelyn’s mother contacted the Moorhead Police Department to say her daughter was missing. A location tracker connected to Jaelyn’s phone through Snapchat led officers to an area near a bicycle trail at Elm Street and 6th Avenue South.

Officers searched the area and found Jaelyn’s body in the Red River near a wooded section beside the trail. She had suffered multiple stab wounds. Police also recovered a knife and a large amount of blood.

Moorhead detectives interviewed Arndt at the hospital. After being read his Miranda rights, he initially repeated the account he had given another officer earlier that night. Detectives noted that his statements were inconsistent.

Arndt later acknowledged that he and Jaelyn had been in a “romantic relationship” for several months, but that the relationship had recently ended, according to the affidavit. He claimed they were at the park when Jaelyn asked about his new girlfriend and attacked him after he refused to answer.

“Defendant stated he started to ‘slash’ at the victim and that he stabbed the victim about 13 times. Defendant stated he fled the scene on his scooter and along the way he discarded his phone, his back pack, and the scooter,” detectives wrote.

An autopsy found that Jaelyn had 53 stab wounds, along with several defensive injuries.

Arndt later spoke with detectives and prosecutors in a second interview. He allegedly said that after stabbing Jaelyn several times, he saw her “laying there suffering.”

“Defendant stated that he then cut her throat, gave her a hug and stabbed her one more time in the back,” the affidavit stated.

He then dragged her body to the river and left her there, according to the complaint. Arndt acknowledged that she was dead.

During a search of Arndt’s Fargo home, detectives allegedly found bloody socks and a towel concealed in a kitchen cupboard. The affidavit also said bloodstained toilet paper was found in the bathroom.

Police said they obtained security footage from the park showing Arndt emerging from the wooded area where Jaelyn’s body was found before leaving on a scooter. Text messages on Jaelyn’s phone reportedly indicated that she and Arndt had arranged to meet at the park around 7:30 p.m. on the night of the killing. Witnesses also told police they saw two people matching their descriptions around that time, according to the affidavit.

In Jaelyn’s obituary, her family described her as “our beautiful, blue eyed, fearless, and feisty girl who loved singing and, although she kept it to herself, she had a beautiful voice.”

“Her quiet time was spent in her room after making herself her macaroni and tomato juice, which was her favorite. If you had the privilege of being her friend, she would let you join too as she loved her closest friends fiercely,” her family wrote. “You’d never find Jae in anything but sweatpants and a sweatshirt, wrapped in one of her favorite blankets with a power fan blowing in her face. If it wasn’t comfy, she wasn’t having it.”

Jaelyn also loved animals, especially her cats, as well as spending time with her family.

“Her favorite family time was lake time, filled with the whole family, all 40 something of us, especially her cousins,” the obituary said. “Her love of Anime gave her aspirations to travel and see the world. Jae was so proud of the choice to be baptized at Prairie Heights on May 22, 2022. She is now in the loving arms of Jesus.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Police: Man Accused of Beating Malnourished Toddler With Belt

Inset: Hakeem Kareem Rae’Quan Lowman (Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office). Background: The 3300 block…

Police Say Man Concealed Dead Woman Under Blanket at Hotel

Left inset: Linda Kilgore (Facebook). Right inset: Alphonso Amos (Cobb County Sheriff’s…

Lawsuit: Couple Mistook Carbon Monoxide Poisoning for Shroom Trip

Insets, from left: John and Kristen Ruskey (GoFundMe). Background: A private residence…

Waldo Man Charged With Smuggling Razor Blade Into Jail After Fleeing Deputies

Staff report WALDO, Fla. – Bernard Jason Carter Jr., 52, was arrested…

Where Is Susan Smith Today? Mother who drowned Sons: 2026 Parole Hearing Explained

Susan Smith remains incarcerated in South Carolina as she seeks parole for…

Mother Who Killed Son in Drunk Crash Says He Should’ve Stayed Home

Inset: Rachale Francine Peloquin (Ramsey County Jail). Background: The fatal turn in…

Parents Arrested After Boy Shoots Himself With Gun, Police Say

William David Howard Jr. and Jennifer McGrath Butler (Wake County Detention Center…

Three Defendants Indicted by Alachua County Fall Term Grand Jury

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – The Alachua County Fall Term Grand Jury…