‘Stand your ground’ claim falters in road rage killing as men charged with murder, ex-cops face accusations

Two South Carolina men have been indicted on murder charges in the fatal road-rage shooting of a North Carolina man, after his sister found evidence challenging their original claim of self-defense. Two former police officers connected to the investigation are also accused of official misconduct.

Scott Spivey, a 33-year-old insurance adjuster, was killed on Sept. 9, 2023, following a pursuit that began on Highway 9 in Horry County and ended with gunfire on Camp Swamp Road, roughly nine miles away.

Charles “Weldon” Boyd and Kenneth “Bradley” Williams initially cited South Carolina’s “stand your ground” law, saying they were protecting themselves from a driver behaving irrationally. Both men were arrested Wednesday, more than three years after Spivey’s death.

Scott Spivey

Scott Spivey was killed Sept. 9, 2023, in a road- age incident on Camp Swamp Road in the Loris area of Horry County, S.C. (Obtained by Fox News)

Brandon Strickland and Paul Vescovi, formerly a deputy chief and sergeant with the Horry County Police Department, are also charged with offenses that include misconduct in office and obstruction of justice, according to local reports. Strickland, who allegedly spoke by phone with Boyd after the shooting, additionally faces a criminal conspiracy charge.

All four defendants appeared in criminal court Thursday afternoon. After a two-hour hearing, the judge had not yet ruled on their bond requests, WMBF-TV of Myrtle Beach reported. The decisions were expected to be issued separately later.

Court documents state that Spivey, Boyd and Williams were carrying guns during the encounter. Spivey ultimately pulled over, exited his vehicle and shouted at Boyd and Williams to stop following him. The two men then allegedly opened fire, killing him in what his sister’s attorney called “a hail of gunfire” in a wrongful death lawsuit.

WATCH: Journalist details ‘damning’ recordings in road-rage shooting case

Jennifer Spivey Foley, Spivey’s sister, later located recordings from Boyd’s phone hidden within the police case file. The material had not previously been made public or considered in the investigation. The Wall Street Journal published the recordings last year, drawing national attention to the case.

Foley attended Thursday’s hearing and urged the judge to deny bond to both Boyd and Williams. She also asked that Boyd undergo a mental health evaluation.

According to filings in the Spivey family’s wrongful death lawsuit, the recordings show Boyd telling a 911 dispatcher that Spivey was “trying to get away” while indicating he was still prepared for a gunfight.

“If I see the gun again, I’m going to take the motherf—– down,” Boyd allegedly said to the dispatcher, according to a 2024 civil complaint filed by the family.

The lawsuit alleges that Boyd stayed on the phone with the dispatcher until the shooting occurred.

The Wall Street Journal later reported that Boyd allegedly called a friend who was serving as Horry County’s deputy police chief at the time.

Defense attorneys have maintained in the civil case that Spivey pointed a pistol at Williams’ head and forced Boyd’s truck off the road when the confrontation began. During a 911 call, a man identified as Boyd told the dispatcher that Spivey had fired first.

O’Bryan Martin, an attorney for Williams, rejected the suggestion that the shooting was anything other than an act of self-defense.

Court filings from Boyd and Williams’ attorneys portray Spivey as the aggressor, alleging that he pointed a gun through the vehicle window at Williams without provocation.

Martin also said other motorists had contacted 911 to report erratic driving by Spivey before his vehicle struck Boyd’s truck on the highway.

“When you’re claiming self-defense, we always have to analyze, first and foremost: Well, who brought on the difficulty? Who caused this to start? Who started the fight, to boil it down? And if you’ve got any part in starting the fight, you can’t then turn around and claim self-defense,” Martin told News Outlet. “In this particular case, Scott Spivey set all this into motion.”

Martin further cited the autopsy report, which found that Spivey’s blood alcohol content was 0.13.

Circuit Court Judge Eugene Griffith, who is presiding over the family’s wrongful death lawsuit against Boyd and Williams, questioned Boyd’s credibility and ruled in February that the civil case could proceed.

News Outlet has contacted attorneys for Boyd and the Spivey family seeking comment.

Court records show that attorneys for Boyd and Williams requested a pause in the civil proceedings on Nov. 5, citing an ongoing grand jury investigation. Their clients were indicted within days.

“For over three years, Scott Spivey’s family has fought for something that should never have required a fight — the truth about how and why Scott was killed,” Mark Tinsley, the family’s attorney, wrote in a statement shared on Facebook.

“From the beginning, this family has believed that Scott’s death was not justified.”

A special prosecutor is handling the criminal case after local prosecutors previously declined to bring charges.

“The tragedy of this case is not just that Scott Spivey lost his life,” Tinsley continued. “It is that his family had to fight the very system that was supposed to investigate his death to get to the truth.”

Spivey’s mother, Deborah Spivey, said on “The Will Cain Show” last year that she rejected the “stand your ground” defense because her son was allegedly followed for nearly 10 miles before the deadly confrontation.

“It does not fit the ‘stand your ground’ [law], when someone tries to de-escalate, tries to leave the scene,” she said. “It doesn’t fit that.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

China watchdog warns Trump faces ‘2-on-1’ showdown with Xi, Putin as Taiwan risks mount

China Watchdog Warns Trump of Xi-Putin Pressure as Taiwan Tensions Escalate

President Donald Trump could enter a high-risk negotiating environment Thursday, when he…
Fox News ‘Antisemitism Exposed’ Newsletter: How hate hijacked health care

Fox News’ Antisemitism Exposed: How Hate Hijacked Health Care

– Rising antisemitism is driving Jewish medical students, healthcare workers and patients…
Obama-era homeless policy fueled crisis it promised to end, expert says as Trump admin makes striking reversal

Expert Says Obama Homeless Policy Fueled Crisis as Trump Team Reverses

The Trump administration’s decision to permanently withdraw federal funding from Los Angeles’…
Beloved hippo Fiona dies at Cincinnati Zoo after swallowing visitor's hat

Beloved Cincinnati Zoo Hippo Fiona Dies After Swallowing Visitor’s Hat

Fiona, the beloved hippo whose premature birth and extraordinary fight to survive…
Fairfield water battle ends with China’s second-richest man taking control

Fairfield Water Battle Ends: China’s Second-Richest Man Takes Control

A California city is facing a backlash from residents over a plan…
Elon Musk feels 'pretty foolish' after spending nearly $500M during the 2026 midterms

Elon Musk Says He Feels ‘Pretty Foolish’ After Spending Nearly $500M in 2026 Midterms

Elon Musk said Wednesday that he felt “pretty foolish” about the amount…
Iran warns Bahrain monarchy its survival is at risk amid push to 'evict' US Fifth Fleet

Iran Says Bahrain’s Monarchy Survival at Risk Over US Fifth Fleet

Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) issued a stark warning Wednesday to…
Florida pastor convicted in Haitian president's assassination plot funded partly by US COVID relief money

Florida Pastor Convicted in Haiti President Murder Plot, COVID-Funded

A Florida pastor was convicted Wednesday for his role in a conspiracy…
The Aftermath of the Blue Tsunami of 2026: The Election 'Rigging'

After the 2026 Blue Tsunami: Election ‘Rigging’ Claims Emerge

With the next James Bond now dominating headlines, it is worth applying…
Judge permanently bars California from enforcing ICE mask ban

Federal Judge Permanently Blocks California’s ICE Mask Ban

A federal judge has permanently blocked enforcement of two California laws that…
Flustered Mamdani doubles down on tone-deaf Oct. 7 post attacking Israel for ‘ongoing genocide’

Zohran Mamdani Stands by Israel ‘Genocide’ Post After Backlash

Mayor Zohran Mamdani appeared flustered Wednesday when asked about his controversial Oct.…
MICHAEL RUIZ: What is a dirty bomb? Explosive terror threat explained

What Is a Dirty Bomb? Explosive Terror Threat Explained

No dirty bomb is known to have been successfully used in a…