Patrick Clancy can proceed with a wrongful death lawsuit against the medical providers who treated his former wife, Lindsay, before she killed their three children, a judge has ruled.
The grieving father secured the legal victory Thursday when a judge rejected a motion to dismiss his case against the doctors who treated Lindsay for mental illness.
Patrick alleges that Lindsay’s doctors acted negligently and failed to provide his family with adequate support before she strangled their three children in the basement of their home in January 2023.
Lindsay has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. Her criminal trial ended in a controversial mistrial in September, and she is scheduled to face a second trial in March 2027.
Patrick filed the wrongful death lawsuit in January 2026 against psychiatrist Dr. Jennifer Tufts, psychiatric nurse practitioner Rebecca Jollotta, Aster Mental Health and South Shore Health System.
The lawsuit claims the providers failed to recognize Lindsay’s deteriorating mental health, overlooked warning signs that she posed a danger to herself and others, and provided negligent treatment.
Attorneys representing the providers argued in court this week that the children’s deaths could not have been predicted. Norfolk Superior Court Judge Michael Doolin rejected that argument.
In his decision Thursday, Doolin wrote that Lindsay had displayed obvious signs of worsening mental illness. He said she allegedly told Tufts and Jollotta that she was suicidal and had thoughts of killing her children.
Patrick Clancy can proceed with a lawsuit against the medical providers who treated his former wife, Lindsay, before she killed their three children, a judge has ruled
Patrick brought the lawsuit on his own behalf and on behalf of the estates of his three children: Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, who was 8 months old.
Doolin said in his ruling that Lindsay told both Jollotta and Tufts she “was both suicidal and homicidal as to her children.”
Patrick’s courtroom victory came only days after Lindsay’s defense team secured a separate legal win. On Wednesday, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court agreed to hear arguments in her appeal.
Her attorneys renewed their effort this week to have the case dismissed by the state’s highest court, after a retrial for the children’s deaths was tentatively set for March 2027.
Lindsay’s first criminal trial on three counts of first-degree murder ended in a mistrial in September after the jury deadlocked. The jury reportedly split 11 to 1 in favor of acquittal following the January 2023 strangling deaths.
Her lawyers appealed to the Supreme Judicial Court, seeking review of Judge William Sullivan’s decision to reject Lindsay’s initial motion to dismiss the murder charges on double jeopardy grounds.
Patrick filed the lawsuit on his own behalf and on behalf of the estates of his three children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court agreed this week to hear Lindsay Clancy’s latest appeal seeking dismissal of her case on double jeopardy grounds
During Thursday’s hearing, Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court Justice Elizabeth Dewar granted Lindsay’s request for the full court to hear the case.
Dewar wrote that a “review of the merits” of Lindsay’s petition was justified. The hearing is expected to be scheduled for an unspecified date in January.
The appeal included details from the jury notes that became central to the mistrial dispute. In those notes, the foreperson accused the holdout juror, later identified as Michael Desronvil, of being unable to apply the law on reasonable doubt.
On September 3, the jury sent the court a note stating: “A member of the jury is unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt. How should we proceed?”
Sullivan then questioned each juror separately about whether they could follow his instructions. Every juror said they could.
Later that day, the foreperson submitted another note: “Juror has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states. This is why we can not come to a unanimous decision.”
The defense argued that the note indicated Desronvil was not applying the law correctly, but Sullivan declined to intervene.
On September 4, the jury sent a final deadlock note, writing: “With a heavy heart, we report that we are unable to come to a unanimous decision and will not be able to.”
Sullivan declared a mistrial, prompting Lindsay’s legal team to begin seeking an appeal and dismissal of the charges.
Her attorneys argue that the charges must be dismissed under double jeopardy protections, contending that the mistrial could have been avoided if the judge had conducted a more extensive inquiry into the holdout juror.
The Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office has not formally announced which charges Lindsay will face in a retrial. However, prosecutor Jennifer Sprague indicated that the state intends to pursue first-degree murder charges.
“Given what the charges are, it requires a jury trial,” Sprague said in court Monday.
If Lindsay faced second-degree murder or a lesser charge, she could request a bench trial. The prosecutor’s statement suggests that the state continues to seek first-degree murder convictions.