The lawyer representing accused Pepperdine crash defendant Fraser Bohm accused prosecutors of engaging in “trial by ambush” during a tense courtroom dispute over evidence from the 104mph collision that killed four sorority sisters.
Alan Jackson, a prominent defense attorney, told the court Friday that prosecutors had failed to turn over key forensic material that could challenge their case against Bohm, 25, who appeared in court facing four murder charges stemming from the October 2023 tragedy.
The dispute centers on a bloodstained canister weighing between 10 and 12 pounds that contained nitrous oxide, commonly known as “laughing gas.” Prosecutors allege Bohm was holding the cylinder in his lap moments before the deadly crash on Malibu’s Pacific Coast Highway (PCH).
Jackson is seeking to exclude the canister from Bohm’s upcoming murder trial, arguing that recently uncovered evidence conflicts with the prosecution’s account of how the container became stained with blood.
At Friday’s hearing in Van Nuys, California, a judge had been expected to rule on whether the canister could be introduced at trial. Instead, Jackson asked for additional time to examine what he described as forensic evidence that had not previously been disclosed.
In newly filed court documents obtained by Our News Outlet, Jackson accused the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office of “conspicuously failing to disclose significant evidence” related to blood found on the cylinder. Prosecutors have connected those stains to injuries Bohm allegedly sustained to his jaw and tongue during the crash.
Jackson said he had located independent evidence that “is inconsistent with the People’s theory that Mr Bohm was holding the canister in his lap and bleeding on to it while driving.”
He also criticized prosecutors for failing to provide “the complete evidentiary record,” adding that “critical forensic testing, laboratory records and other material discovery remain outstanding.”
Fraser Bohm appeared in court Friday as a judge was expected to decide whether the laughing gas canister could be used as evidence
Bohm, shown leaving the Van Nuys courthouse, remains free on $4 million bail
“This is trial by ambush,” Jackson told the court.
“The defense cannot be expected to meaningfully litigate the admissibility of the People’s theory, much less confront it at trial, while the prosecution continues to withhold the very evidence necessary to evaluate and challenge it.”
Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Robert Rubinson granted the continuance, moving the hearing to December 18 and giving prosecutors time to respond to the defense allegations.
The judge also scheduled a new trial date for January 25, 2027.
Bohm attended the hearing in a gray suit, tie and white shirt. He remains out of custody on $4 million bail.
He arrived with his mother, Brooke, 57, who reportedly purchased the BMW involved in the crash as a gift for her son’s 18th birthday.
Bohm was 22 when the collision occurred. He has pleaded not guilty to four counts of second-degree murder and four counts of vehicular manslaughter with gross negligence in the crash that killed Alpha Phi members Niamh Rolston, 20; Asha Weir, 21; Peyton Stewart, 21; and Deslyn Williams, 21.
If convicted, he could receive a sentence of 15 years to life in prison for each second-degree murder count.
RELATED: Alison Boshoff Reveals the Inside Story of the Race to Be 007
The crash claimed the lives of four Pepperdine University students, including Deslyn Williams, 21 (left), and Niamh Rolston, 20. The Alpha Phi sorority sisters were also close friends (Source: Niamh Rolston/Instagram)
Peyton Stewart, 21, (left), and Asha Weir, also 21, belonged to Pepperdine’s Alpha Phi chapter. Both were pronounced dead at the scene alongside their two friends
Images included in court filings and obtained by Our News Outlet show the nitrous oxide canister investigators allegedly recovered from the crash scene
The four women died on October 17, 2023, when Bohm’s BMW, traveling at high speed, struck three vehicles parked along the PCH in Malibu, near the area where the students were walking.
The posted speed limit on that portion of the highway is 45mph. Prosecutors filed second-degree murder charges after examining data from the BMW’s “black box,” which indicated that the vehicle accelerated from 93mph to 104mph in the two and a half seconds before impact.
Bohm’s defense team has twice unsuccessfully sought dismissal of the murder charges, arguing that prosecutors cannot establish “malice”—the legal requirement that he understood his reckless conduct could result in someone’s death.
Jackson has repeatedly characterized the deaths as the result of a devastating accident, claiming Bohm was being pursued during a “road rage” incident. The District Attorney’s Office has said there is no evidence supporting that account.
The attorney also argued that, although the crash occurred more than three years ago, prosecutors only recently, “on the eve of trial,” introduced a new theory that Bohm was distracted because he was “holding a nitrous oxide canister” while driving.
Questions surrounding blood evidence on the canister prompted the defense to file a third motion earlier this month seeking dismissal of the four second-degree murder charges.
Jackson has maintained that prosecutors should be barred from presenting the gas cylinder to the jury.
He argues that jurors might conclude Bohm was inhaling nitrous oxide, a substance capable of producing a brief but powerful high, while behind the wheel.
Bohm arrived at court wearing a gray suit, tie and white shirt alongside his mother, Brooke
Video obtained by KTLA from the night of the collision shows the wreckage of Bohm’s red BMW, which he received for his 18th birthday as part of his wealthy parents’ divorce settlement
Prosecutors have said they do not intend to argue that Bohm inhaled the gas. Their position is that the canister itself was a distraction while he was driving.
Defense attorneys counter that even presenting the canister and its nozzle could lead jurors to infer that “Mr. Bohm was ‘under the influence.’”
The families of all four victims have filed wrongful-death lawsuits against Bohm. They are also suing the State of California, Los Angeles County, the City of Malibu and the California Coastal Commission, alleging that unsafe road design and inadequate safety measures contributed to the tragedy.
All four women were seniors at Pepperdine’s Seaver College of Liberal Arts, where they belonged to the Alpha Phi sorority.
They were expected to graduate with the class of 2024 and were later awarded their Pepperdine degrees posthumously.