An Alabama man who claimed self-defense for shooting TikTok star Ophelia Nichols’ teenage son during a drug deal was acquitted of murder on Friday— as the influencer said that “justice had been stripped” from her family.
Reuben Gulley, 25, was found not guilty of killing 18-year-old Randon Lee after a jury deliberated for about an hour and a half before returning with the verdict that shocked Lee’s family and friends, according to WALA.
Nichols, known as “Mama Tot” and with over 12 million followers on TikTok, revealed that her husband burst into tears when the jury foreman shared the verdict in the packed courtroom.
“I have watched my husband break down sitting in that courtroom today while I did my best to hold it together for myself, for him, my children, our entire family,” Nichols wrote on Facebook.
“As I could feel the excited energy from the other side because their son was coming home, I slowly melted into my seat. Knowing that Justice had been stripped from my son and us, I couldn’t even describe what it did to my soul,” she wrote.
Gulley shot Lee inside his car when the teen attempted to sell him weed during an arranged drug deal outside a gas station in Prichard, Ala., on June 24, 2022.
Gulley had admitted during his trial on Thursday that he shot Lee during the drug meet-up in self-defense after the teen pulled a gun on him first.
Prosecutors had argued Gulley shot Lee to avoid paying $300 for the 2 ounces of weed the two had agreed on.
Security footage from the Pride gas station in Prichard, Ala., north of Mobile, captured a hooded Gulley stepping out of the passenger side of a car and going around to Lee’s car parked behind a gas pump.
Gulley testified that he got into the back seat of Lee’s car and pulled out 15 $20 bills to pay for the drugs before Lee allegedly pulled out a gun, leading to the deadly shooting.
The footage, played as evidence during the trial, didn’t show the moment of the shooting but did capture Gulley running back to the car with a gun in his hand as Lee drove off.
Gulley’s attorney argued that the prosecution’s case was undermined by insufficient evidence and a flawed investigation by the Prichard Police Department.
Attorney Chase Dearman said investigators failed to pursue important leads and never adequately explained how a single shot allegedly fired by Gulley could have left a bullet inside Lee’s body while also creating a bullet hole in the vehicle’s windshield.
“Of course, I’m satisfied, but more than anything else, I am relieved,” Dearman told WALA following the hearing. “I stayed awake all night thinking that a Mobile County jury could not convict someone based on evidence like this, and I’m extremely happy.”
Prosecutors attributed the acquittal to shortcomings in the police department’s evidence-gathering and investigative work.
“Despite the problems with the investigation, we believed in this case because we had independent evidence that supported it,” Mobile County Chief Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Susman said.
“There is no question that the issues involving the Prichard Police Department became a distraction for the jurors, and I believe defense attorneys are taking full advantage of that,” Susman continued. “As we continue seeking justice, I hope people will be able to concentrate on the reliability of the remaining evidence and that the proper outcomes will ultimately follow.”
Nichols condemned the verdict, saying Gulley’s acquittal dealt another devastating blow to her family and left them struggling to understand the jury’s decision.
“We don’t know what led the jurors to that decision, or how they reached it, and I’m sure we will ask ourselves those questions for the rest of our lives,” Nichols wrote. “There was no remorse for our family and no regard for Randon’s life. What happened to us was incredibly cruel, and knowing that other families face situations like this is frightening.”
Through tears, she added, “I watched my daughter cry uncontrollably today. In the 20 years we’ve been married, I’ve seen my husband cry maybe three times, and today he couldn’t hold it together. He broke down.”