IRVING, Texas – Stewart Rhodes did more than serve prison time because of his loyalty to Donald Trump. While incarcerated for his role in the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol, the founder of the far-right Oath Keepers had Trump’s defiant expression tattooed on his body after the president survived an assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania.
The tattoo symbolized Rhodes’ devotion to the Republican president. Today, he says that devotion is gone.
“I am absolutely done with Trump,” Rhodes said while sitting at a battered yellow table outside an Irving gastropub. He now describes Trump as a traitor and “one of the very worst” figures in American history.
The break with Trump by one of his former followers — a man convicted of seditious conspiracy for helping coordinate an unsuccessful effort to keep Trump in power six years ago — highlights how the president’s support has weakened even among his most radical backers. In 2020, Rhodes insisted that Democrat Joe Biden had defeated Trump through election fraud. This year, amid historic Democratic victories in Texas, Rhodes offered a different explanation.
“The lion’s share is because Trump pissed off his own base,” Rhodes said beneath a black cowboy hat. An eye patch covered his left eye, damaged in an old gun accident, while a pale blue iris watched from the other.
Nearby, attendees gathered over drinks for his Christian Warriors After-Party, held during a three-day conference titled “Christ is King: America After Trump.” Some stopped to shake Rhodes’ hand or sign up for the Oath Keepers and training programs focused on community defense and hurricane relief.
‘The first inkling’ of a break with Trump
Rhodes said his disillusionment began when Trump pardoned hundreds of people imprisoned for their actions on Jan. 6, 2021, but merely commuted Rhodes’ sentence. “That was the first inkling,” he said.
He also accused Trump of violating his promises to end foreign conflicts through the war with Iran. Rhodes said he felt further betrayed when Trump dismissed people pressing his administration to release files related to Jeffrey Epstein, labeling them “PAST supporters.” In Rhodes’ view, Trump had also abandoned his signature political promise.
“We elected him to end the corruption in Washington, D.C. — ‘Drain the swamp.’ Unfortunately, his administration has been one of the most corrupt administrations in U.S. history,” Rhodes said. “The pardons are pay-for-play and everything is pay-for-play.”
The White House did not respond to a request for comment. Rhodes is not the only former Trump supporter to reverse course, but his shift reflects a broader ideological pattern, said Sam Jackson, an associate professor at the University at Albany who studies anti-government extremism.
“They went from seeing Donald Trump as their ally in this fight against the conspiracy to actually being co-opted by the conspiracy,” Jackson said. The shift, he added, “points to deeper consistency in that understanding of the world as driven by hidden, evil actors.”
Rhodes, a Yale Law School graduate who once worked for former Texas Rep. Ron Paul, founded the Oath Keepers in 2009. The group encouraged military members and law enforcement officers to resist what it considered unconstitutional orders, including disarming citizens or conducting warrantless searches.
Watching Trump’s shooting from prison
Rhodes later aligned himself with Trump’s political movement, and the Oath Keepers backed Trump’s effort to remain in office after his 2020 election loss. Prosecutors said that, driven by false claims of voter fraud, members stockpiled weapons, held tactical training sessions and traveled to Washington. Some took part in the Jan. 6 assault on the Capitol.
Rhodes did not enter the Capitol that day, but he said he was a “political prisoner” whose trial was marked by “illegality.” He received an 18-year sentence, among the longest imposed in a Jan. 6 case.
“You are smart, you are charismatic and compelling, and frankly, that’s what makes you dangerous,” U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta told him at sentencing. “The moment you are released, whenever that may be, you will be ready to take up arms against your government.”
Rhodes remained in prison as Trump mounted his political comeback. He watched the assassination attempt in Butler on a prison television alongside other inmates. When Trump raised his fist and shouted “fight,” Rhodes said he believed God was protecting him.
After winning the 2024 election, Trump quickly pardoned hundreds of people convicted of crimes connected to Jan. 6, including defendants who had assaulted police officers. Rhodes received a commutation, which did not erase his criminal record.
“He let us out of prison. We were grateful. I didn’t get a pardon, though,” Rhodes said.
Rhodes says Trump tattoo will be ‘modified’ to match his new view
The Justice Department vacated Rhodes’ conviction earlier this year, removing his status as a felon. He said he is working to rebuild the Oath Keepers, which previously claimed tens of thousands of members, according to leaked membership lists. Once his rights were restored, Rhodes said, his first priority was acquiring firearms. He did not register to vote before the election, though he said he would not have voted anyway.
Rhodes said he believed “the Republican Party has taken us for granted” and did not want to choose between “a half a dose of poison or a full dose.”
As for the Trump tattoo — now a permanent reminder of a man Rhodes considers a traitor — he said he has plans, though he did not explain them.
“I will have this prison tattoo of Trump ‘modified,’” he wrote in a text message, “to reflect that reality. That treason.”