Share this @internewscast.com
The United States’ federal medicine authority is updating its regulations for approving COVID-19 vaccines, which could potentially limit vaccine availability for millions of children and adults based on new guidelines.
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is modifying the type of evidence it will accept from vaccine makers and will now require fresh clinical trials for the approval of annual COVID-19 booster shots for healthy individuals below 65 years of age.
These modifications suggest that individuals younger than 65 might no longer qualify for the latest COVID-19 vaccines, according to an infectious diseases specialist speaking to SBS News.
Paul Griffin, an associate professor at the University of Queensland who has facilitated clinical trials for COVID-19 vaccines, labeled the FDA’s decision as “absurd”.

“Limiting vaccine access will only amplify COVID-19’s effects,” he noted.

“If we restrict vaccines to people over 65, as appears to be the case in the US, there’s a whole host of people who may get a more significant infection who won’t have the option to be protected,” Griffin said.
So why is the FDA making changes?

It comes down to what US health officials say is a lack of evidence about the efficacy of COVID-19 boosters.

What’s happening in the US?

FDA commissioner Marty Makary and top US vaccines regulator Vinay Prasad wrote in the New England Journal of Medicine on Tuesday that the benefit of repeated annual shots for healthy adults was uncertain after several years of the virus circulating and vaccines being available.
They also said the US was an outlier among high-income nations in recommending yearly shots for healthy adults.
“At-risk Americans can be reassured that they will be covered by such approvals. At the same time, we want more evidence at the US Food and Drug Administration,” Prasad told scientists at the FDA during a live-streamed presentation.

“We want to know more about what these products are doing, especially as we enter the seventh, eighth and ninth dose.”

Makary and Prasad said they expect the FDA will be able to approve the boosters for adults over the age of 65 based on data from tests that measure immune response in patients.
The shots would also be available for everyone over the age of six months with one or more issues that put them at high risk for severe COVID-19 outcomes, they said.
But for healthy people between the ages of six months and 64 years, the FDA expects it would require formal clinical trials for pharmaceutical companies to get approval to manufacture annual shots.

Prasad indicated that all COVID-19 vaccine producers will need to perform placebo-controlled studies in healthy individuals aged 50 to 64 and are advised to include very young children in such trials.

‘Unethical’ process

Griffin warned millions of healthy adults and children stand to lose access to updated vaccines under the new criteria.

“Though the elderly and those with existing health issues are generally more at risk, unfortunately, serious illness isn’t confined to these groups,” he commented.

Requiring new, expensive and lengthy clinical trials for approved vaccines was a step backward in his view, and using placebos in these trials is “unethical”, he said.
“If we’re looking at improving or updating vaccines, we don’t typically go back to including placebos because essentially it’s unethical to do so,” he said.
“If there’s a vaccine already approved, there’s a reason that’s the case. And so then to enrol people in a clinical trial and basically restrict them from receiving what would be considered best practice is actually unethical.

“Typically, when we’re improving vaccines, we include the current standard of care, the approved vaccine rather than a true placebo.”

Griffin said the FDA decision may be influenced by anti-vaccine sentiment in the US.
US health secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr, one of the country’s top vaccine critics whose department oversees the FDA, has been reshaping the decades-old federal system for approval and use of vaccines while also taking steps to align with US President Donald Trump’s goal of shrinking the federal government.

Some 20,000 people have left the department as part of mass layoffs.

How will supply and cost be impacted?

Roger Lord, a senior lecturer in medical sciences at the Australian Catholic University, said the risks of serious hospitalisation would be less for younger healthy people who have already received boosters and may not need a yearly shot to increase their immunity.

But for those still wanting to get vaccinated, supplies could decrease, and costs increase, he said.

As clinical trials are expensive undertakings for pharmaceutical companies, they could also lead to delays, Lord said.
“When it comes to any drug or vaccine, when it’s going through the regulatory process, the most expensive and time-consuming component of testing is actually clinical trials,” he told SBS News.
“The pharmaceutical companies that manufacture these vaccines they’re going to have to pass on those costs associated with that clinical trial back onto the consumer to recover those costs.”
He said these additional costs could lead to companies producing fewer vaccines, which could mean less availability here in Australia.
“If they work out their profit margins are not going to be significant enough to produce more vaccines, it would potentially affect the supply chain in Australia,” he said.

“These companies are profit-driven like any business and are working in the best interest of shareholders.”

Could the same thing happen in Australia?

Griffin was confident a similar decision would not be made by the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA), which is responsible for regulating medicines in Australia.
“I really doubt that the TGA will because they’re a tremendously reputable regulatory body and they do engage a lot of genuine expertise to make the recommendations that they do,” he said.
However, politicians and public sentiment can erode confidence in vaccines, which can affect the uptake of vaccinations and not just COVID-19 boosters, he said.

“The fear that I have is that people, the public and certain politicians are already aligning with some of those concerning things that are happening abroad, including in the US, and may call for these sorts of things to happen and further undermine their confidence in vaccines,” he said.

Griffin said a particularly worrying trend is the decline in childhood vaccinations.

A 2024 report from the National Centre for Immunisation Research and Surveillance found that children aged from 12 months to 5 years old were less vaccinated in 2023 than in 2020.

What does the TGA say?

A spokesperson for TGA said it was independent of FDA influences.
“While the TGA does work closely with international counterparts, including the United States Food and Drug Administration (US FDA), the TGA independently reviews the data and makes its own decision based on the evidence provided by the sponsor, and within the Australian context,” the spokesperson said in a statement to SBS News.
The spokesperson also said TGA does not conduct clinical trials and is “unable to compel a sponsor or manufacturer of a medicine to conduct a clinical trial”.
They said access to COVID-19 boosters will “remain free in 2025” for eligible Australians.
“Government will continue to consider future arrangements supporting the access, supply and distribution for COVID-19 vaccines.”
— With additional reporting from Reuters news agency.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
On Tuesday, Warner Bros. announced at CinemaCon who will be replacing Viggo Mortensen as Strider (aka Aragorn) in the highly-anticipated prequel, Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum, hitting theaters December 17, 2027

New Aragorn Cast for ‘Lord of the Rings’ Prequel, Sparking Fan Debate Over Viggo Mortensen’s Replacement

On Tuesday, Warner Bros. unveiled the actor set to take on the…

Historic Milestone: Afghan Women’s Football Team Gains FIFA Membership

FIFA has unveiled a series of significant governance reforms aimed at enabling…
Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk and her partner Dr Reza Adib in 2023.

Police Investigate Property Linked to Former Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk’s Partner

Queensland Police have searched a luxury beachside unit owned by prominent surgeon…
people walking on the busy Pitt Street retail area in Sydney during the boxing day sales

Historic Shift: England Loses Top Spot as Leading Source of New Australians

For the first time in our nation’s history, England has been knocked…

Iran’s Supreme Leader Announces Intent to Sustain Influence Over the Strait of Hormuz

Iran’s supreme leader has pledged to defend the nation’s nuclear and missile…
Donald Trump has celebrated the axing of a critical part of the Voting Rights Act.

Trump Applauds Supreme Court Ruling with Potential Long-Term Impact on Elections

In the midst of a storm of heated social media reactions and…

New Zealand Mosque Attacker’s Appeal to Overturn Convictions Rejected

A man responsible for the tragic deaths of 51 individuals in a…
IKEA shoppers are being urged to take note of a major change that could impact how they shop, after the furniture giant quietly tightened one of its most popular policies

IKEA Updates Return Policy: What Shoppers Need to Know About New Guidelines

Attention all IKEA enthusiasts: brace yourselves for an important update that may…
Revealed: The extraordinary number of Coalition MPs and Senators who took a freebie trip paid for by foreign billionaires to a conservative talkfest - before Opposition slammed the PM as 'Airbus Albo' for his travel

Exclusive: Coalition’s Secretive Billionaire-Funded Trips Uncovered Amid Criticism of PM’s Travels

EXCLUSIVE In a surprising contrast, the Coalition permitted 14 of its members,…

Pentagon Reveals First Official Estimate: Iran War Costs US Billions

In brief Pentagon officials have fronted a US congressional committee, facing questions…

Trump Proposes Troop Reduction Amid Intensifying Tensions with Germany

In brief Donald Trump has posted on his Truth Social platform, suggesting…
Generic scenes of Commonwealth Bank of Australia logo and words, CBA, Banking, office buildings. Monday 13th Janusry 2025 AFR photo Louie Douvis

Potential Revisions to Property Tax Incentives May Not Deliver as Expected, Major Bank Warns

The Commonwealth Bank has weighed in on the potential effects of altering…