Alex Brummer: The AI debt binge sparks disturbing echoes of the financial crisis

Jensen Huang’s departure from Nvidia, following days of intense scrutiny over his private life, could become one of the defining moments of the artificial intelligence revolution.

The chipmaker has suffered a sharp blow, losing almost $1 trillion in market value since reports emerged on October 29 alleging that Huang had an affair with a Chinese intelligence asset.

Further claims of an alleged extramarital relationship with Nvidia senior executive Kimberly Powell reportedly increased pressure on the company’s board and ultimately forced it to respond.

The decision to install long-serving director Harvey C Jones as chairman, while finance chief Colette Kress takes over as interim chief executive, reflects an emergency effort to impose stability on a company engulfed by turmoil.

The consequences of Huang’s exit extend well beyond Nvidia. Anthropic, the Claude AI developer, has already seen hundreds of billions of dollars erased from the anticipated value of its planned initial public offering.

Nvidia’s share price may recover and Anthropic may still make it to market. But the allegations surrounding Huang should prompt far closer examination of an AI boom in which corporate governance and extraordinary levels of borrowing have received too little attention.

The departure of Jensen Huang from Nvidia has brought the chip designer down with a bump

Jensen Huang’s exit has delivered a major shock to Nvidia, the leading AI chip designer

Financial markets follow their own patterns, and collective enthusiasm can carry prices far beyond what the underlying reality appears to justify.

Warnings from financial authorities around the world, including the Bank of England and the International Monetary Fund, about inflated AI valuations have been largely brushed aside.

Whenever technology stocks have suffered a sharp fall, they have quickly regained ground. Yet that kind of extreme volatility has often preceded wider market collapses.

Over the past two days, several British business leaders have accused me of being unduly pessimistic. I hope they are correct, and that the Huang controversy proves to be no more than a temporary disturbance on the way to a brighter economic future.

Similar reassurances were offered before the Great Financial Crisis, when the run on Northern Rock and the collapse of investment bank Bear Stearns were widely dismissed as isolated events.

During that period, I visited the offices of CQS, then one of London’s leading hedge funds, where I was introduced to a credit analyst.

He displayed a table detailing credit exposures and showed that many of Britain’s second-tier consumer banks, including Halifax Bank of Scotland, were effectively insolvent. Several major clearing banks were also facing serious difficulties.

Soon afterwards, Prime Minister Gordon Brown, Chancellor Alistair Darling and Bank of England Governor Mervyn King had to assemble a rescue package worth close to £1 trillion, including support for the monetary system, to prevent the financial structure from collapsing.

A crisis that began in the poorly understood US sub-prime mortgage market created a hole in public finances from which the country has never fully recovered.

Only yesterday, I spoke with an analyst whose firm supplies services to hedge funds and investors worldwide. He said the AI investment boom had spread across the financial system. Technology giants and smaller companies alike were no longer able to fund their expansion entirely through cash flow and had accumulated around $3 trillion in debt at remarkable speed.

As in the run-up to the financial crisis, there is very little clarity about where the greatest risks are concentrated.

Anyone who studied the events of 2008 would recognise the proliferation of ‘special purpose vehicles’, structures used at the time to shift liabilities away from published balance sheets. Such arrangements can distribute leverage throughout the wider financial system.

The decline in technology valuations may therefore be more than a nervous response to the allegations involving Huang and the strategic repercussions in Beijing. It may signal that some investors are finally confronting the possibility that the AI boom has been built on far shakier foundations than advertised.

A possible silver lining

For the UK, there may be at least one reason for optimism. Britain’s strong scientific and technology base could be benefiting from the wider AI expansion.

The economy’s unexpectedly strong third-quarter performance, which saw growth accelerate to 0.7 per cent, may have been supported in part by research and development, the adoption of AI and investment in infrastructure such as data centres.

For now, we can only hope that proves to be the case.

DIY INVESTING PLATFORMS

Easy investing and ready-made portfolios

AJ Bell

Easy investing and ready-made portfolios

AJ Bell

Simple investing with ready-made portfolios

Free fund dealing and investment ideas

Hargreaves Lansdown

Free fund dealing and investment ideas

Hargreaves Lansdown

Fund dealing at no cost plus investment ideas

Flat-fee investing from £4.99 per month

interactive investor

Flat-fee investing from £4.99 per month

interactive investor

Flat-fee investing packages from £4.99 a month

Investing Isa now free on basic plan

Freetrade

Investing Isa now free on basic plan

Freetrade

Free investing Isa on the basic plan

Free share dealing and no account fee

Trading 212

Free share dealing and no account fee

Trading 212

No-fee share dealing and no account charge

Affiliate links: If you take out a product This is Money may earn a commission. These deals are selected by our editorial team because we believe they are worth highlighting. This does not affect our editorial independence.

Compare the best investing account for you

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *