Judge denies Trump admin's 'nonsensical' bid to shred Flores
Share this @internewscast.com

Left: U.S. District Judge Dolly Gee speaks during an interview with the National Asian Pacific American Bar Association (NAPABA/YouTube). Right: President Donald Trump addresses reporters in the Oval Office at the White House on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Washington, D.C. (Photo/Alex Brandon).

A federal judge in California has rejected an attempt by the Trump administration to abolish the 28-year-old Flores Settlement Agreement, which enforces court-mandated supervision over how immigrant children are treated while in federal custody.

U.S. District Judge Dolly Gee released a 20-page order on Friday, maintaining the agreement from 1997. She stated that the Justice Department’s attorneys had not presented “any new facts or law” that would justify ending it “at this time,” according to Judge Gee, an appointee of President Obama.

The administration had also tried to end the Flores agreement back in 2019, towards the close of Donald Trump’s first term, but that attempt also failed. Gee reportedly termed the recent hearing a “deja vu,” as the government presented similar arguments once again.

“The court remains unconvinced,” Gee wrote in Friday’s order. “There is nothing new under the sun regarding the facts or the law.”

According to the Flores Settlement Agreement, immigrant children must be housed in facilities that are “state-licensed” and must be treated in a proper and humane manner before being handed over to family members or guardians “as quickly as possible.” The settlement traces its origins to Jenny Lisette Flores, a 15-year-old detainee who initiated a class-action lawsuit in 1985.

The Trump administration argued that the Flores agreement was obsolete because Congress had already passed legislation to address the issues the settlement was designed to tackle. Additionally, it asserted that governmental bodies had established procedures and standards to ensure appropriate treatment of the youth.

“The legal basis for the agreement has withered away,” DOJ lawyers argued in a May 22 motion for relief. “Congress enacted legislation protecting UACs [unaccompanied alien children], and the agencies promulgated detailed standards and regulations implementing that legislation and the terms of the FSA,” the lawyers said, blasting the agreement as an “intrusive regime” that has “ossified” federal immigration policy.

“The legal and policy landscape has also changed beyond recognition,” they added.

Gee noted Friday how she had heard this all before.

“These improvements are direct evidence that the FSA is serving its intended purpose, but to suggest that the agreement should be abandoned because some progress has been made is nonsensical,” the judge blasted.

“Incredulously, defendants posit that DHS need not promulgate regulations containing an expeditious release provision because ‘this Court has interpreted [expeditious release] to apply to accompanied children,'” Gee explained. “But ‘the FSA was intended to provide for prompt release of unaccompanied children.’ This is plainly incorrect and ignores the rulings of at least three separate courts.”

Gee concluded her order by saying it was ultimately the Trump administration that “continues to bind itself to the FSA by failing to fulfill its side of the parties’ bargain.”

Lawyers for immigrant children named in the class action complaint that spurred all this have said Trump’s second term has seen similar violations of the Flores agreement that have been alleged in the past.

“In CBP facilities across the country, including in cases documented by class counsel in New York, Maine, Illinois, Ohio, Arizona, Texas, and California, plaintiffs report being held for days and sometimes weeks in restrictive, traumatic conditions,” the lawyers said in a June 17 motion to enforce the FSA. One parent, whose allegations were included in the motion, described how they and their child were held at a facility where “the rooms have hard walls, like cement, and there is a window facing the hall but you cannot go out or see the sun,” per the motion.

“We are never allowed to go out,” the parent said. “The children keep telling us, ‘This is not America.’ They feel imprisoned and confused. They are seeing the sun for the first time in this interview room. They both ran to the window and stared out, and my son asked, ‘Is that America?'”

The plaintiffs’ lawyers accused the Trump administration of wanting to be released from the settlement “not because they have complied with and will continue to observe its fundamental principles, but because they want the flexibility to treat children however they wish,” according to the June motion.

DOJ officials did not respond to Law&Crime’s requests for comment Sunday.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Judge Rejects Trump’s Request to Halt Case Due to Shutdown

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters in the Oval Office at the…

Mother Uses Steam on Baby Girl’s Face Causing Severe Skin Damage Due to Gender Disappointment

An Ohio woman was jailed on Wednesday for allegedly abusing her 4-month-old…

Man Accused in Fatal Gangland Shooting Incident in Sydney’s West

A man has been charged for his alleged role in the fatal…

Scheduled Execution for Sole Woman on Death Row in US State

The Tennessee Supreme Court has set execution dates for four people, including…

Police Discover Missing Woman Hidden in Attic in Gruesome Crime Scene

Insets, top to bottom: Douglas Shaw and Renia Lewis (Vallejo Police Department).…

Former Groomsman Denied Bail in Connection to ‘Brutal’ Gold Coast Murder

A man accused of brutally murdering a father-of-two has been denied bail…

Man Reveals Location Where He and Army Friend Disposed of Dismembered Roommate: Police Report

Background: Rainor Joiner is seen in footage allegedly showing New Mexico officers…

Gainesville resident detained after assaulting security guard at Shands

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Lavell Lorenzo Lawrence Strong, 29, was arrested…

Indiana Man Fatally Injures Girlfriend in Front of Young Daughter

An Indiana man is facing charges for shooting his girlfriend in the…

Police Report 14-Year-Old’s Plot for High School Attack

Kamiakan High School in Kennewick, Wash. (Google Maps). A 14-year-old boy from…

Mother-in-Law Allegedly Hired Hit on Law Professor Son-in-Law; Jury Misconduct May Lead to Her Release

After nearly three weeks of testimony, a jury swiftly reached a verdict…

Mother Accused of Shooting and Stabbing Son to “End His Suffering”: Police

Inset: Krista Roy (St. Charles County Jail). Background: The Missouri home where…