Mushroom cook 'chose world scrutiny' over silence, defence says
Share this @internewscast.com

Accused killer Erin Patterson’s account of the deadly beef Wellington lunch did not unravel despite being cross-examined for days, her barrister says.

Colin Mandy SC told the Victorian Supreme Court jury his client had the right to stay silent in her triple-murder trial but she instead chose to face questions from the prosecution.

“She decided to give evidence and to subject herself to several days of cross-examination by a very experienced barrister,” Mandy said.

Erin Patterson's legal team leave the court, led by Colin Mandy SC.
Erin Patterson’s legal team leave the court, led by Colin Mandy SC. (Justin McManus)

Patterson, 50, has denied she intentionally poisoned her former in-laws Don and Gail Patterson, Gail’s sister Heather, and Heather’s husband Ian Wilkinson.

Don, Gail and Heather all died after consuming the July 29, 2023 beef Wellington lunch served by Patterson at her home in regional Victoria, while Ian survived.

Patterson has pleaded not guilty to three charges of murder and one count of attempted murder.

Mandy told the jury Patterson was not only being scrutinised by those in the courtroom during her cross-examination, but also the whole world.

He maintained that despite more than 20 hours of “surgical” questioning from crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC, Patterson’s account did not unravel.

Mandy noted Patterson had spoken to 21 people within 24 hours after the lunch, including medical professionals, health department staff, child protection workers and police.

Accused killer Erin Patterson.
Accused killer Erin Patterson. (Anita Lester)

Each person asked different questions depending on the focus of their investigations but Patterson’s comments to each of them were the same in “every meaningful way”, Mandy said.

“The answer of the question changed depending on who was asking the question,” he said.

Patterson was also forthcoming in her admissions that she lied to the lunch guests about being diagnosed with cancer and that foraged mushrooms might have been in the meal, Mandy said.

The barrister’s closing address is due to continue today before Justice Christopher Beale gives his final directions to the jury.

The judge has already indicated he will not begin his instructions until Monday, with the jury to begin deliberating on Tuesday afternoon at the earliest.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Minnesota Father Beheaded Teen Boy and Disposed of His Body in a Dumpster

A Minnesota man whose 16-year-old son was found dead last month was…

Sheriff: Uncle fatally attacked nephew and abandoned body roadside

Context: The vicinity of County Road 39 and County Road 8 in…

Father Sentenced for Starving 4-Year-Old Daughter

Main: Rodney McWeay during his June 17, 2025, sentencing hearing in Atlanta…

Girlfriend of Bali bombing survivor has clinic targeted in arson attack

A Melbourne skin-care clinic that was firebombed overnight is owned by the…

Man Accused of Beheading Father Following Unsuccessful Citizen’s Arrest

Background: The Bucks County Justice Center in Doylestown, Pa. (Google Maps). Inset…

Tragic Incident at McDonald’s: Employee Allegedly Kills Manager Following Dispute

Inset: Jennifer “Jamma” Harris, tragically stabbed by a coworker at a Michigan…

Man Arrested in Connection with New York Child Sexual Battery Case

Staff report from Gainesville Police Department social media post GAINESVILLE, Fla. –…

Gainesville Resident Accused of Coercing Friend into Assisting Escape from July 2nd Shooting Scene

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Xzavier Taylor Hawkins, 20, was apprehended yesterday…

Man Accused of Harassing Women at Gas Station Fatally Shoots Another Man: Police

Background: The BP at 778 Grant Street in Akron, Ohio (Google Maps)…

Judge Cannon Urged to Address Unresolved Mar-a-Lago Matter

Left: Judge Aileen Cannon (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of…

Georgia Teen Faces Adult Charges Months After Delivering Tearful Eulogy; Accused of Killing Mother and Stepfather, Police Report

A 17-year-old teenager from Georgia has been accused of murdering her mother…

Week One of Diddy’s Incarceration

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs, disgraced music mogul, begins a new fight for a…