DOJ moves to dismiss lawsuit seeking full Jack Smith report
Share this @internewscast.com

Left: FILE – Special counsel Jack Smith addresses the media regarding an indictment against former President Donald Trump on Aug. 1, 2023, at a Department of Justice office in Washington (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File). Center: U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida). Right: Donald Trump talks to the media before leaving Manhattan criminal court, Monday, May 6, 2024, in New York (AP Photo/Julia Nikhinson, Pool).

On Friday, the U.S. Department of Justice submitted a motion to dismiss a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit seeking to uncover the second volume of former special counsel Jack Smith’s concluding report on the Mar-a-Lago investigation related to President Donald Trump.

The underlying litigation is a relatively terse five-page lawsuit filed in January by The New York Times and one of their reporters.

The plaintiffs claim that the DOJ did not comply with the legal timeline to give a decision on expedited processing of their FOIA request for the second volume of Smith’s report.

Now, the Trump administration, in no uncertain terms, wants to wash its hands of the matter and have the lawsuit dismissed. The filing also offers itself as, in the alternative, a motion for summary judgment.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

To hear the government tell it, those same hands are tied – by an injunction issued on Jan. 21, by U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon in response to an emergency motion to enjoin the release of the second volume filed by Waltine “Walt” Nauta, Trump’s personal valet, and Carlos de Oliveira, Mar-a-Lago’s chief of maintenance.

The district court’s order enjoins:

Attorney General Garland or his successor(s), the Department of Justice, its officers, agents, officials, and employees, and all persons acting in active concert or participation with such individuals . . . from (a) releasing, sharing, or transmitting Volume II of the Final Report or any drafts of Volume II outside the Department of Justice, or (b) otherwise releasing, distributing, conveying, or sharing with anyone outside the Department of Justice any information or conclusions in Volume II or in drafts thereof.

And the injunction, the DOJ says, is the long and short of the case.

“The Times fails to state a plausible claim for relief under FOIA,” the 15-page motion to dismiss reads. “It is clear from the face of the amended complaint that DOJ did not ‘improperly’ withhold Volume II, as required to state a FOIA claim. DOJ had no choice but to withhold the document, as Judge Cannon’s injunction bars DOJ from releasing it.”

The Times, for their part, says Cannon simply did not have the authority to issue the injunction in question – and suggest the DOJ knows and/or agrees the scope of relief granted by the Trump-appointed judge was beyond the district court’s power.

“Defendant has improperly denied the Request for the Second Volume,” the Times’ amended complaint filed in late April reads. “Because the injunction in the Criminal Action was made by a court that lacked jurisdiction to issue such an injunction, it was not a proper basis for DOJ to deny release of the Second Volume.”

The government says this argument could lead to legal chaos.

“Even if this Court were to agree with the Times that Judge Cannon lacked jurisdiction to enter the injunction, an order compelling DOJ to release Volume II under FOIA would put the agency in the impossible position of having to decide which of two conflicting court orders to follow,” the motion to dismiss goes on.

To hear the government tell it, a 1980 U.S. Supreme Court case is instructive here.

The motion to dismiss argues that case stands for the proposition that there is “no discretion for the agency to exercise” in situations “where records sought under the FOIA are subject to injunction issued by federal district court.”

“The Times concedes that the injunction remains in place and precludes the exact relief sought in this case: disclosure of Volume II by DOJ,” the DOJ filing continues. “The Court should therefore dismiss the complaint pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6), based solely on the factual allegations in the amended complaint. Alternatively, the Court should grant summary judgment in DOJ’s favor.”

In their amended complaint, the Times takes stock of the procedural nature of the extant case – which was appealed to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals after Cannon dismissed the charges against Trump.

“At that point, jurisdiction as a matter of law rested solely with the Eleventh Circuit,” the Times argues. “By operation of law, only the Eleventh Circuit could issue an injunction governing the release of the Second Volume. No such injunction was issued by the Eleventh Circuit, and the Injunction issued by the District Court is a nullity. The District Court also lacked jurisdiction to issue the Injunction because there was no live case or controversy before it, as required by Article III of the Constitution.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Tragic Turn: Teen’s Desperation Ends in Fatal Incident at Girlfriend’s Home

Inset: Chanelle Alvarez (GoFundMe). Background: The area around Chanelle Alvarez’s home in…

Could Samuel Alito’s 1986 Perspectives Offer a Lifeline to James Comey?

Left: U.S. Associate Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito Jr. attends inauguration ceremonies…

Shocking Incident: Adelaide House Party Turns Violent, Leaving Man with Disability Stabbed

A man with a disability was stabbed during an unruly house party…

Teen Expresses Remorse to Family After Tragic Incident Involving Friend

Background: News footage of Rolan Delacruz during his sentencing on Oct. 20…

Police Report: Mother Accused of Strangling Her 6-Year-Old Child in Sudden Outburst

Inset: Justine Mroz (Pasco County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The house where Mroz…

Georgia Couple Faces Charges of Child Cruelty After Three Young Children Discovered Unattended at Campsite

In a troubling incident in Carroll County, Georgia, authorities have charged a…

Shocking Abandonment: Parents Leave Three Toddlers Alone at Campsite—An Urgent Call for Awareness

Share In a troubling case emerging from Georgia, authorities have charged a…

Shocking Incident in Gainesville: Man Faces Arrest After Allegedly Brandishing Firearm

Staff Report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Authorities took Diverous Karon Hayes, 43, into…

Man Who Threatened to Assassinate Trump in First Year Receives Sentence

President Donald Trump attends the 157th National Memorial Day Observance at Arlington…

Tragic Discovery: Body of Missing Miss USA Hopeful Kada Scott Found, Investigation Probes Potential Accomplice

The remains of Kada Scott have been discovered in a wooded area…

Mother and Partner Detained Following Discovery of Unresponsive Child: Police Report

Background: West Allis police officers investigate after a child is found unresponsive…

Husband Allegedly Struck and Killed by Wife After Leaving Home

Inset: Alina Gonzalez-Morelos (Pasadena Police Department). Background: The sidewalk near where Gonzalez-Morelos…