Share this @internewscast.com

Migrants are taken into custody by officials at the Texas-Mexico border, Jan. 3, 2024, in Eagle Pass, Texas. (AP Photo/Eric Gay, file)

The nation’s most conservative appeals court is locked in a duel with the U.S. Supreme Court after it issued a ruling blocking the same Texas immigration law that the justices lifted a stay on only one day earlier.

On Tuesday, a majority of justices on the nation’s highest court ruled that Texas S.B. 4 could go into effect while the legal battle challenging its constitutionality proceeded through the courts. The law authorizes Texas law enforcement to arrest anyone suspected of illegal border crossing and charge them with crimes ranging from misdemeanors to felonies, then to prosecute and punish them with jail time or return them to Mexico. At the heart of the legal controversy is Texas’ endeavors to regulate immigration at the border — a topic generally reserved exclusively for federal, not state, lawmaking.

The Supreme Court’s ruling Tuesday ended an administrative stay that was put into place by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Ketanji Brown Jackson, and Elena Kagan dissented from the Court’s ruling, with Sotomayor warning the majority that it invited “chaos and crisis” by upholding the Fifth Circuit’s “unreasoned” ruling that allowed Texas to intrude on federal authority.

A three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit heard oral arguments following the Supreme Court’s ruling on Wednesday, then voted 2-to-1 to block the law.

The panel’s majority was comprised of U.S. Circuit Judge Priscilla Richman and Judge Irma Carrillo Ramirez, while Circuit Judge Andrew Oldham voted for it to remain in effect. Oldham and Richman are both George W. Bush appointees, while Ramirez is a Joe Biden appointee.

Richman said during arguments that no state had previously claimed the authority to deport migrants and asked how Texas would carry out its proposed deportations under S.B. 4.

Texas’s solicitor general argued to the panel that the statute is consistent with federal law and that Texas is simply trying to “make sure” that the “important provisions” of Congressional laws are followed.

By contrast, the Biden administration argued that Texas was attempting to go even further than Arizona did in 2010 with a similar law — one that was struck down by the Supreme Court as being overly intrusive on federal legislative territory.

Throughout the battle over S.B. 4 and at oral arguments Wednesday, Texas advanced the argument that the federal government has provided insufficient border protections and that Texas must protect itself from “invasion” by those crossing the border without authorization. The federal government’s lawyer flatly denied the accusations Wednesday and said numerous statistics had already been introduced into evidence about the administration’s active engagement in the area.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Preschool teacher detained for striking a child

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Paige Julia Nachwalter, age 26, was detained…

New Appeal in Case of ‘Brutal’ Double Murder as 25th Anniversary Approaches

Police have issued a fresh plea for information over the unsolved murder…

States Take Legal Action Against Trump’s Dubious Energy Emergency Declaration

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters in the Oval Office at the…

Tragic Incident: Mother and Sons Killed by Husband Despite Plea for Help

Left: Jeremy Koch (GoFundMe). Right: Front: Bailey and Hudson Koch. Back: Jeremy…

Tragic Incident: 12-Year-Old Fatally Shot During Music Video Shoot, Police Report

Inset: Ethan Parker (Facebook/Zakia Brice). Background: The residence where Ethan Parker was…

Police Report: Man Found Transporting Mother’s Body in Car Covered with McDonald’s Wrappers

Inset: Kevin Ahn (Lancaster County District Attorney’s Office). A man from Pennsylvania…

Teenager Suspected of Trying to Enter AFL Game with Fake Gun

A teenage boy has allegedly been caught trying to smuggle weapons into…

Individual Confesses to Assisting Officer in Disposing of Body in River Following Murder

Inset: Joshua Rogers (Shelby County Jail via WREG). Screenshot: Former Memphis police…

Menendez Brothers: New Court Date Set for Brothers Accused of Killing Parents in California

Despite the prosecution’s efforts, the Menendez brothers’ resentencing hearing has been scheduled.…

Bridge House Resident Arrested for Indecent Exposure and Lewd Conduct

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Joshuia Bernard Jenkins, 35, who was participating…

Lawsuit Claims Negligent Snow Removal Caused Water Polo Coach’s Death

Colleen Lischwe, center (McKendree University). The husband of a well-regarded water polo…

Mother Sentenced to Prison for Molesting Her Son’s Teenage Friend

Natalie Sorrells (Rockwall County Jail via KFDW). A Texas mom is spending…