‘This went way beyond hazing’: 11 High School Lacrosse Players Turn Themselves In After Staging Kidnapping, Stuffing Younger Student in Car Trunk

In Syracuse, New York, a group of five younger students on the Westhill High School lacrosse team felt thrilled when invited by older team members to attend a match against a rival school and have dinner at McDonald’s.

After the game concluded and while heading back home, the car driver seemed to lose his way and stopped. Abruptly, masked attackers appeared from the woods—wielding a gun and a knife—and attempted to kidnap the boys. Four managed to flee, but the masked attackers captured one.

Outmatched 11 to one, the boy had his hands bound and a pillowcase put over his head, as they forced him into the trunk of a car at knifepoint. The kidnappers taunted him en route to another secluded wooded location, where they left him on the ground—alone and terrified for his life.

Still bound and blindfolded, the boy heard the attackers return. He didn’t know if they planned to release him or kill him. Instead, they revealed it was a prank. The attackers were upperclassmen on the lacrosse team staging a hazing ritual. The entire incident was recorded on video.

The next morning, the victim’s family reported the incident to the school, as students circulated the video and rumors of the mock kidnapping sparked a social media firestorm in the community.

A school resource officer reported the incident to the Sheriff’s Office, triggering an investigation.

Joining Nancy Grace today:

High School Hazing Incident Backfires: District Attorney Urges Involved Students to Surrender
Dr. Gary Brucato – Clinical Psychologist and Author: “The New Evil: Understanding the Emergence of Modern Violent Crime”
Joe Scott Morgan
Joseph Scott Morgan  –  Professor of Forensics: Jacksonville State University, Author of “Blood Beneath My Feet,” and Host of “Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan;” X:@JoScottForensic
High School Hazing Incident Backfires: District Attorney Urges Involved Students to Surrender
Mary Kielar – Investigative Reporter for CNY Central Media Group; Instagram @MaryKielar, Facebook @MaryKielarCNYCentral, X: MaryKCNY

Additional Guests

  • Shari Foltz – Mother of Stone Foltz, Son Died during a hazing incident at a frat initiation at Bowling Green State University // Founder of I Am Stone Foltz Foundation
  • David Bianchi – Trial lawyer at Stewart, Tilghman, Fox, Bianchi & Cain, [recognized as “America’s leading hazing lawyer”], Represented Danny Santulli’s family who was left permanently impaired after fraternity hazing incident at University of Missouri
  • Barry Hutchison – Former 26-year law enforcement veteran and detective, now owner & Chief Investigator for Barry & Associates Investigative Services [located in Kansas & Missouri]

“Crime Stories with Nancy Grace” is also a national radio show on SiriusXM channel 111, airing for two hours daily starting at 12 p.m. EST. You can also subscribe and download the daily podcasts at iHeart Podcasts.

[Feature Photo: Pixabay]

You May Also Like

CNN Lawyer Mocks Trump DOJ’s ‘Magic Words’ Strategy to Secure President’s Wishes

Main: President Donald Trump and Marco Rubio, U.S. secretary of state, attend…

Mother Who Ignored Son’s Texts as 3-Year-Old Died Home Alone Learns Her Fate

Jennifer Prudencio appears in court for sentencing on Sept. 22, 2026 (Law&Crime).…

Police: Man Shoots Friend Eating McNuggets Over Ex’s Texts

Inset: Wilson Jackson (Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Milwaukee, Wis., neighborhood…

Mom Pleads Guilty After Abandoned Kids Ate Spoiled Raw Meat

Inset: Krystal Farmer (Genesee County Prosecutor’s Office). Background: Body camera footage from…

Doctor Says Boy Allegedly Starved by Fire Chief and Wife Resembled ‘Concentration Camp Survivor’

Left: Angela Mittlestadt (Laramie County Sheriff’s Office). Center: Laramie County Fire District…

Man Sentenced for Aiding Friend Who Killed Teen With AK-47

Left inset: Martin Cruz (Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Office). Center inset: Fortunato…

Gainesville Man Pleads Guilty to Federal Firearm Charge

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. — Ramone Ron Young Jr., 34, has pleaded…

Man on Pretrial Release Charged After Rollover Crash and Fleeing on Archer Road

Staff report ARCHER, Fla. – Neal Andrew Troiano, 38, was arrested yesterday…