Order bars Michigan judge from hearing felony cases
Share this @internewscast.com

Kirsten Nielsen Hartig (Oakland County).

A Michigan judge, reportedly with a history of mistreating staff and causing issues for prosecutors, has been prohibited from presiding over felony cases and is now limited to handling small claims and landlord-tenant disputes.

As per an order acquired by Law&Crime, 52nd District Court Chief Judge Travis M Reeds has removed Judge Kirsten Nielsen Hartig’s authorization to manage criminal cases.

The order states, “All General Civil, Landlord Tenant, and Small Claims actions filed in the [district] will be assigned to Judge Kirsten Nielsen Hartig.”

Meanwhile, all “criminal and civil infraction ordinance violations,” as well as “all felony cases” will be assigned to another judge, the order said. The order takes effect on May 27.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

The order does not give a reason for the action in the court that handles cases in the Detroit suburbs of Troy and Clawson but Hartig has a history of misconduct allegations, according to local reports.

“The order was issued to ensure fairness in the courtroom,” Oakland County spokesperson Bill Mullan told The Detroit News.

The Detroit Free Press reported Hartig’s rulings in 2022 sparked Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald to appeal to a higher court. McDonald claimed Hartig dismissed cases against a trio of alleged armed robbers as retribution for a scheduling conflict. The appeal alleged Hartig “has a long-standing practice of seeking to impose her own personal view of what the law should be via the criminal cases before her,” McDonald wrote, according to the Free Press.

McDonald also noted that Hartig’s decisions were repeatedly overturned on appeal.

Hartig in a statement to the Free Press at the time chalked up McDonald’s beef to election year politics and said she only dismissed the case because the prosecutor refused to show up to a court hearing in person, despite knowing that’s what the judge expected.

“They didn’t do their job and now they’d like to blame the judge for enforcing the law,” Hartig said in a statement at the time, according to the Free Press. “That’s no surprise, and neither is the attempt by political opponents to pile on.”

More from Law&Crime: Improperly plowed road led to water polo coach’s death after car is unable to pull over, gets slammed into by semi-truck and goes off overpass: Lawsuit

Also in 2022, a former court administrator sued the county, alleging that Hartig created a hostile work environment and that the administrator was fired for complaining about it, the Detroit News reported. While Hartig was not personally named in the lawsuit, the administrator alleged after she returned from medical leave the judge made it clear that she had to report to her daily “unless you’re unconscious.”

Hartig also made the administrator stand up in front of a courtroom full of people where she accused her of mismanaging grant funding, the lawsuit said. The Free Press reported the court administrator settled for $100,000 in 2023.

According to Hartig’s biography, she was elected to the district court bench in 2010. It says she “currently presides” over the district’s Recovery Treatment Court.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Jury Fails to Decide in Murder Trial

A jury has been unable to decide whether a wheelchair user who…

Heartbreaking Incident: Ex-Partner Shoots Woman and Himself in Presence of Their Child

Background: News footage from the Hamtramck, Michigan, neighborhood where Brianna Frame was…

Attorneys for Teen Charged with Baby’s Death Seek to Exclude Statements from Case

Left: Alexee Trevizo (Artesia Police Department); Right: Footage from police body camera…

Mother Confesses to Bathtub Drowning of Her Children

Brittany Medina (Lawrence County Sheriff”s Department) and her children, Jackson and Maddie…

Teen on House Arrest Accused of Selling Drugs Close to School

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Damorie Lamontay Miles, age 19, was taken…

Woman Accidentally Backs Over Husband Following Dispute: Police Report

Inset: Dara Masterson (Sebastian County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The area in Arkansas…

Foster Mom Charged with Killing 9-Year-Old Disabled Girl Found in River

Pennsylvania authorities announced that a 9-year-old girl, who was declared missing on…

Father Faces Charges After Attempt to Shoot Buzzard Tragically Results in Daughter’s Death

An Illinois man has been taken into custody six weeks after fatally…

Man Murders Girlfriend and Her Dog, Contacts Ex Afterwards

Inset left: Taton Dorfman (Pima County Sheriff’s Department). Inset right: Hannah Rogers…

Woman Attacks Mother and Brother Over Lost PlayStation Game

Share copy link Alexandra Dominguez (Marion County Jail). A Florida woman was…

Farmer Found Guilty of Killing Missing Girl on His Property

Inset: Jade Colvin (Iowa Department of Public Safety). Background: James Bachmurski at…

Father Accidentally Shoots Daughter While Targeting Buzzard: Police Report

Background: The location in Waterloo, Ill. where Emma Schultheis was fatally shot…