Trump firing of FTC commissioner was 'unlawful': Judge

Left: U.S. President Franklin Roosevelt is captured moments before delivering his “On the Fall of Rome” Fireside Chat from the White House in Washington on June 5, 1944 (AP Photo). Right: President Donald Trump is seen posing for photographers upon arriving for a formal dinner at the Paleis Huis ten Bosch ahead of the NATO summit in The Hague, Netherlands, on Tuesday, June 24, 2025 (AP Photo/Alex Brandon).

A federal judge based in Washington, D.C., issued a permanent order barring President Donald Trump’s employees from interfering with a “legitimate Commissioner” of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) from completing her full seven-year term.

U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan highlighted that the “circumstances” of this particular case “closely resemble” the situation in a 90-year-old Supreme Court case, Humphrey’s Executor v. United States. In that case, the estate of an FTC commissioner successfully argued that President Franklin Delano Roosevelt could not dismiss William Humphrey without just cause due to policy disagreements, securing backpay for the commissioner.

The 1935 unanimous SCOTUS ruling was clear that “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance” were the only causes for firing an FTC commissioner, as Congress expressly intended to insulate the independent fair competition agency from being unfairly subjected to the whims of the executive and, by extension, politicization and dysfunction.

FTC Commissioners Rebecca Slaughter and Alvaro Bedoya filed suit against Trump, FTC Chair Andrew Ferguson, FTC Commissioner Melissa Holyoak, and FTC Executive Director David Robbins in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia back in March.

Slaughter and Bedoya claimed that the president removed them without cause — in direct contravention of the law, which says: “Any Commissioner may be removed by the President for inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office.”

“In short, it is bedrock, binding precedent that a President cannot remove an FTC Commissioner without cause,” the plaintiffs’ lawsuit said. “And yet that is precisely what has happened here: President Trump has purported to terminate Plaintiffs as FTC Commissioners, not because they were inefficient, neglectful of their duties, or engaged in malfeasance, but simply because their ‘continued service on the FTC is’ supposedly ‘inconsistent with [his] Administration’s priorities.'”

“The President’s action is indefensible under governing law,” they added.

On Thursday, AliKhan agreed, handing Slaughter a permanent injunction blocking her ouster at the summary judgment stage of the litigation, deciding the issue of Slaughter’s reinstatement without need for a trial.

You May Also Like

Police: 300-Person Teen Party Had Underage Drinking, Fireworks

Inset, from left: Lisa Vaughn and Aubrey Vaughn (Fairfax County Police Department).…

Man Accused of Strangling Woman for 10 Minutes After She Laughed at Him, Police Say

Inset: Victor Dorantes-Velazquez (Broward County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Hallandale Beach apartment…

Gainesville Man Arrested After Pointing Gun at Stranger

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Vontez Robert McGlorthon, 21, was arrested yesterday…

Prosecutors: Father Who Killed 7-Week-Old Son Hurt Infant Before

Inset: Jacob Thompson (Ottawa County Prosecutor’s Office). Background: Magruder Hospital in Port…

Police: Mother Beat Newborn Son to Death at Home Within an Hour

Jantelle Sharon Jordan (Smith County Sheriff’s Office). A Mississippi mother is in…

Trump Administration Urges Court to Allow Construction of 250-Foot Washington Arch Despite Standing Challenge

President Donald Trump displays an image of the proposed Triumphal Arch on…

Dad Allegedly Fractured Baby’s Skull, Told Cops Blood on Shirt Was Tomato Sauce

Inset: Muhire Augustin (Boone County Jail). Background: The Fourth Avenue home in…

Man Arrested After Alleged Robbery at Homeless Encampment

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Michael Allan Davis Sr., 30, was arrested…