Judge blocks layoffs at Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
Share this @internewscast.com

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters in the Oval Office at the White House, Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025, in Washington, D.C. (Photo/Alex Brandon).

An attorney from the Department of Justice faced challenging questions and endured a difficult experience in a Washington, D.C., courtroom on Thursday as he persisted in his ongoing solo efforts to defend the Trump administration’s controversial campaign against major law firms.

Richard Lawson is the sole attorney the government has opted to deploy in court to counter lawsuits brought by law firms such as Perkins Coie, Jenner & Block, and WilmerHale.

During a two-hour motions hearing before U.S. District Judge Loren L. AliKhan regarding the Trump administration’s attempt to weaken Susman Godfrey LLP, the newly appointed deputy associate attorney general was momentarily left without words.

And it happened twice.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

As the court unraveled several issues in President Donald Trump‘s April 9 executive order, key sticking points during the hearing concerned an allegation that the Los Angeles-based law firm “engages in unlawful discrimination, including discrimination on the basis of race.”

During his time at the dais, Susman Godfrey’s lead attorney, Donald Verrilli, said the president’s findings were “completely baseless.”

The Joe Biden-appointed judge, for her part, repeatedly tried to ferret out what, exactly, the government had based the discrimination allegation on.

And there, Lawson was admittedly lacking.

“I don’t have the hard data on hiring,” the DOJ lawyer said at one point.

Instead, Lawson tried to defend Trump’s order by suggesting the court shift to a more nebulous but more holistic inquiry into “the quantum of proof that must exist” for the executive to determine a potential policy. To that end, Lawson argued, the answer is: “it’s low.”

In other words, the government lawyer was trying to move the debate away from specifics and into a framework where the court would be amenable to giving the president broad discretion — even, and perhaps especially, if the specifics are difficult to come by. Lawson suggested the court could sign off on a policy where the president acts based on his subjective understanding of the law firm’s commitments to diversity.

“There has to be some level of discretion afforded to the executive,” he said.

But the judge was not having it.

“I don’t know how, if you’re relying on a legally erroneous statement, you’re allowed to exercise that discretion,” AliKhan replied.

The sole statement in Trump’s order supporting the allegation is: “For example, Susman administers a program where it offers financial awards and employment opportunities only to ‘students of color.””

That line, it turns out, is a reference to the Susman Godfrey Prize, which the law firm describes as “[a]n honor awarded annually to up to 20 students of color who are finishing their first or second year at an eligible law school” and “part of the firm’s ongoing commitment to celebrate and promote diversity among civil trial lawyers.”

The government lawyer was pressed to concede that the prize is not unlawful discrimination in employment under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, despite previous language in court filings highlighting the prize and suggesting it is unlawfully discriminatory.

“It doesn’t seem like anything you have alleged in section one constitutes unlawful racial discrimination,” AliKhan said.

The judge noted that the language regarding the prize is the only example of racial discrimination that Trump’s order contains — and that the line comes immediately after the allegation.

“I just don’t know how you square the circle,” AliKhan said.

While Lawson tried to move on to a different-but-related argument, the judge pushed him to account for the line about the prize.

“So, the only example in the executive order that has to do with racial discrimination isn’t actually an example?” the judge asked, waiting a beat before demanding an answer: “Yes or no?”

A long silence followed.

“Yes or no, sir,” the judge pressed.

More silence.

While the government lawyer did not have an answer, he finally spoke up to say as much.

“I would like to think about that, your honor,” Lawson said.

AliKhan replied: “I would like an answer before you leave my courtroom.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Man Accused of Murdering Ex-Wife, Caught on Camera Moving Bloodstained Mattress

Left inset: Footage purportedly capturing Karl Geiger dragging a blood-stained mattress from…

Man Attempts to Hire Hitman to Murder Wife Amid Divorce and Custody Battle Over Six Children

Mohammad A. H. Mohammad (Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office). An Alabama resident plotted…

Teen Babysitter Given Vodka by Mom, Baby Later Discovered Wandering Street: Police Report

Inset: Ashley Ellis (Vanderburgh County Jail). Background: The area in Evansville, Indiana,…

Domestic Violence Incident Escalates: Suspect Kills Wife Following Police Escort

Inset: Frederick Spears (Arlington police). Background: Home in Arlington, Texas, where Spears…

Husband Stabs Expectant Wife 34 Times, Then Contacts Police: Authorities

Context: A neighborhood in St. Cloud, Minn. where Falus Ali was discovered…

Newly Appointed Judge by Trump Quickly Criticizes Administration

President Donald Trump listens during a ceremonial swearing in of Paul Atkins…

Police Report: Man Allegedly Chipped 74-Year-Old Mom’s Tooth in Attempted Car Theft

Background: Body camera footage shows Donald Chadwell being detained (Edmond Police Department).…

“Officials Dismiss Serial Killer Speculations After Discovery of 5 Bodies in Bayous Over 6 Days: ‘Enough Is Enough'”

On Tuesday, Texas officials denied rumors of a serial killer after five…

Man Allegedly Kidnaps Girlfriend, Attempts to Strangle Her in Car, and Waits Outside for 7 Hours, Police Report

Background: A Malibu Bay apartment building on the 700 block of Malibu…

Urgent Alert: Missing 17-Year-Old Florida Boy Possibly Shot on His Way to Work

Police in Florida are searching for a 17-year-old Florida boy who may…

Police Report: Suspect Admits to Killing Missing Family’s Father

Left (Clockwise from top left): Geraldina Peguero-Mancebo, Junior Cabrera-Colon, and their son…

BREAKING: Second Body Discovered in Bayou Close to Location of College Student’s Recent Death

A probe is currently in progress following the discovery of a body…