Inset: Kalynn Settle (Mesa County Sheriff”s Office). Background: The intersection near where Settle caused a fatal crash in Grand Junction, Colo. (Google Maps).
A woman from Colorado faces the longest possible prison term following her involvement in a DUI collision that resulted in the death of a motorcyclist.
Kalynn Settle, aged 30, admitted guilt to charges of vehicular homicide and cocaine possession.
In a sentencing delivered by 21st Judicial District Judge JenniLynne Lawrence, Settle received a six-year prison term for the homicide and an additional year for the drug charge. Both sentences will be served simultaneously.
The tragic event transpired on June 14, 2025, at the intersection of North Seventh Street and Bunting Avenue in Grand Junction, claiming the life of 41-year-old Aaron Barone.
According to police bodycam footage, Settle initially claimed she stopped to assist as a registered nurse and alleged that a “Mexican lady that left” was responsible for the accident. However, The Daily Sentinel reported that an officer observed what appeared to be “blood or human flesh” on the front of her vehicle.
Settle was apprehended after officers detected the smell of alcohol on her breath, leading her to decline sobriety tests.
Following the refusal to perform the requested maneuvers, police obtained warrants to draw Settle’s blood and search her car, according to Grand Junction-based CBS affiliate KREX and Fox affiliate KFQX.
In the car, law enforcement made telltale discoveries of what appeared to be alcohol, prescription medication, a burnt glass pipe, a baggie of a white powdery substance, and a small circular container of a white crystal-like substance, according to a police affidavit.
The white powder tested positive for ketamine while the white crystal tested positive for cocaine, police said. The blood test showed that Settle had cocaine and alcohol in her system.
When an officer told her she was under arrest for DUI, the since-condemned woman said, “Good luck with that.”
During her sentencing hearing, she struck a different note.
“On that day, I made a choice I can never undo,” Settle said through tears.
Barone’s father mourned the loss of his son and addressed the defendant.
“He worked hard his entire life, only to have it cut short by an act of irresponsibility,” the grieving father said.
Prosecutor Joshua Dougherty asked the court to impose a five- or six-year prison term – arguing the defendant had not truly shown remorse and had missed a number of drug tests during the pretrial process.
The judge, for her part, said she was originally inclined to issue a sentence of community supervision – where Settle would have been able to avoid prison – but was concerned by the missed drug tests.
The court reportedly said such behavior was typical of addicts trying to avoid responsibility for the consequences of a failed drug test.
“These are not the behaviors of a sober person,” the judge intoned – while holding out hope of a decreased sentence with good behavior. “You still have choices you can make that can improve the outcome for you.”
