As the security footage revealed, the man who killed Brian Foguth entered the Duke and Duchess convenience store a little after 2 a.m., forcing Foguth into a back area of the store, per Unsolved Mysteries. Foguth was forced to hand over cash to the assailant while also managing to trigger a silent alarm. When the customer who would end up calling the police pulled into the station, he triggered a beeping sound the robber thought was an alarm, causing him to panic. A scuffle ensued.

It was at this point when Brain Foguth was killed by a single bullet, but not before possibly injuring his assailant in the face, according to police (per Unsolved Mysteries). It’s believed that the murderer was a white man, between 18 and 30 years old, and approximately 5’9″. He may have also been disfigured in his back and neck area, according to police, but that may have also been due to a ponytail he was trying to conceal when the crime was committed. Brian Foguth’s killer has never been found.