Murder Trial to Begin for Former Navy JAG Officer Accused of Killing, Dismembering Wife

The murder trial for a naval officer, Nicholas Kassotis, accused of murdering his wife, is scheduled to begin next week in Liberty County, Georgia.

As previously covered by CrimeOnline, authorities discovered the remains of Mindi Mebane Kassotis, 40, at the Portal Hunting Club in Riceboro on December 2, 2023, as reported by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.

Her body had been dismembered, and further remains were located within a three-mile radius on the club’s grounds, spanning both Liberty and McIntosh Counties.

The GBI said it believed the remains were put there around November 27, 2023.

In a pre-trial motions hearing last week, both parties consented to keep the crime scene photographs within the courtroom due to the case’s graphic nature, as the remains exhibited tool marks.

“This case, as the court is aware, is horrifically gruesome and will likely cause additional trauma,” stated Atlantic Judicial Circuit District Attorney Laurie Baio last Thursday, as reported by ABC 22.

“It is my intention, your honor, not to be gruesome, but rather to be strictly and solely forensically informative to the jury.”

Kassotis was apprehended in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, the day after investigators confirmed the identification of the remains, facing charges of malice murder, felony murder, aggravated assault, tampering with evidence, and removal of body parts from the scene of death or dismemberment.

Kassotis had served as an officer in the US Navy’s Judge Advocate General corps when he wed Mindi, a writer and business owner originally from New Orleans, in 2016, according to the Daily Beast.

Months before her Mindi’s death, an ex-wife won a $1.5 million divorced judgment against the defendant. The pair then fled, with the defense claiming they were running from a man identified as Jim McIntyre, who allegedly had control of their finances.

“They were living, moving every few days, few weeks, few months, under control of this person we’ll keep calling Jim McIntyre,”  Kassotis’ attorney, Doug Weinstein, said.

The prosecution, according to Court TV, called the defense’s suggestion a “CIA, conspiracy theory-type argument.”

“While the state says that that’s a fabrication, it’s clearly not a fabrication that he makes up after the fact. Because he and Mindi told people about what was going on, why they were on the run, and everything else,” Weinstein argued.

The prosecution also referenced the defendant’s third wife, Samantha Colsmith, and a store receipt showing he purchased items before meeting up with her.

“There is a Target receipt that the defendant purchases on his way to meet with Samantha Colsmith, his third wife. Where he purchased condoms and Old Spice within days of his wife being deceased,” Baio said.

Jury selection is scheduled to begin August 4. Check back for updates.

[Feature Photo: Mindi Mebane Kassotis/Georgia Bureau of Investigation]

You May Also Like

Lawsuit Says Nursing Home Worker Shoved 72-Year-Old Resident, Causing Fatal Brain Injury Facility Called a Minor Fall

Inset: Dennis Newman. Background: The Wisconsin nursing home where Dennis Newman was…

Man Arrested After Allegedly Choking Girlfriend, Swinging Hammer at Her

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Jabar Darnel Colley, 22, was arrested yesterday…

Boy, 12, Forced Into Laundry Room Without AC or Sleep: Police

William Conner (Volusia County Sheriff’s Office). A 42-year-old Florida man is accused…

Homeless Man Arrested in Gas Station Gun Threat Against Stranger

Staff report ALACHUA, Fla. – A 23-year-old man, identified as Tyler James…

Teen Fatally Stabbed 73-Year-Old Mall Manager for No Reason

Background: Tyler Leibelt (center, wearing a jumpsuit) is escorted by police officers…

Police: Man Lured Girl Across States, Held Her Captive 4 Years

Inset: Owen Anderson (Western Virginia Regional Jail). Background: Milwaukee County Courthouse in…

Appeals Court Rejects Trump Bid to Revive Election Order

President Donald Trump speaks with reporters as Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla., from…