Trump DOJ Cites James Comey Novel as It Argues Jury Should Decide If Seashells Were Coded Threat to Kill President - Internewscast Journal
Trump DOJ Cites James Comey Novel as It Argues Jury Should Decide If Seashells Were Coded Threat to Kill President

Main: Former FBI Director James Comey speaks at Harvard University’s Institute of Politics JFK Jr. Forum in Cambridge, Mass., on Monday, Feb. 24, 2020 (AP Photo/Charles Krupa). Left inset: A DOJ court exhibit shows the seashell arrangement on Comey’s phone.

Former FBI Director James Comey was not merely sharing a beachside curiosity when he posted an image of seashells arranged as “8647” on a North Carolina shore, President Donald Trump’s Department of Justice argues. In the government’s telling, Comey is a “charismatic leader” who understood exactly what the message would convey — a point prosecutors say is reinforced by what they call his “eerily on-the-nose novel.”

The DOJ on Tuesday submitted multiple filings opposing Comey’s efforts to suppress evidence, obtain grand jury materials, and have the case dismissed on claims of vindictive or selective prosecution.

One filing, however, focused squarely on defending the seashells prosecution itself. In that document, prosecutors argued that a jury should decide whether Comey’s Instagram post — which he described as a “cool shell formation” spotted “on [his] beach walk” with his wife, Patrice, in May 2025 — amounted to a “true threat” against a political opponent.

So far, the government has not persuaded courts that posting or displaying “86” automatically qualifies as a true threat. Still, prosecutors contend the circumstances surrounding Comey’s post make this case different.

Comey’s lawyers have pushed back sharply, arguing that the administration’s reading of “86” runs contrary to dictionary definitions, as well as “context, precedent, and common sense.” They also filed an affidavit from a former mob prosecutor who said “there is literally no support for the central allegation on which the case rests.”

The government, in response, said U.S. District Judge Louise Flanagan can “easily” reject Comey’s effort to “short-circuit these proceedings,” insisting that “[w]hether Comey’s post constitutes a true threat depends entirely on the sharply disputed factual context.”

That question belongs before a jury, the DOJ argued. Prosecutors said the relevant context includes Comey’s novel “FDR Drive,” which was “only five days from public release” when he shared the seashell photo.

The DOJ turned to an excerpt from the book in which a character described the concept of “stochastic terrorism” by way of a “charismatic leader [who] jacks people up but, through the wonder of the internet, avoids a direct connection to what comes next.”

Comey is just such a leader, the Trump DOJ said.

“On May 15, 2025, a charismatic leader named James Comey, through the wonder of the internet, posted a coded message to his followers meaning ‘kill’ or ‘get rid of’ (a euphemism for ‘kill’) President Trump. Comey has acknowledged taking the picture of the seashells on May 15,” the filing said. “To be sure, Comey’s account suggests any similarity between his conduct and his novel are coincidental.”

But because the “heart of this case is a dispute over what that context means,” the DOJ said, “[o]nly a jury can resolve” it.

“Rather than argue the phrase has a single objective meaning, [Comey] acknowledges that ’86’ has at least ‘in more recent times’ and ‘on isolated occasions’ been used to mean ‘to kill.’ And of course, Comey himself previously admitted that ‘some folks associate those numbers with violence’ after deleting his post,” the opposition filing said, claiming it would be “exceedingly odd” for the judge to toss the case “without the government having ever had the opportunity to present evidence of that context to substantiate its allegation of a true threat.”

After he deleted the post, Comey also said in an appearance on the “Late Show with Stephen Colbert” that he and his wife thought “8647” was a “clever political message” protected by the First Amendment.

“You know what I think it is, I think it is a reference to restaurants when you ’86’ something in a restaurant,” Patrice said, according to her husband.

The post Trump DOJ says ‘charismatic leader’ James Comey’s ‘eerily on-the-nose novel’ shows jury must decide if seashells were ‘coded message’ to kill president first appeared on Law & Crime.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Man Faked Suicide After Killing Ex-Wife and Hiding Her Body

Inset: Britney Watson (Facebook). Background: Kevin Watson appears in court in news…

Man Who Hunted Down and Shot His Stepson Learns Sentence

Inset left: William Bryan Morgan (Eighth Judicial Circuit Solicitor”s Office). Inset right:…

Gainesville Woman Charged With Child Abuse After Allegedly Disciplining 5-Year-Old With Belt

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Ebony Anais Smith, 26, was arrested yesterday…

Gainesville Man Arrested After Allegedly Stabbing Girlfriend

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Joshua Anthony Mears, 19, was arrested the…

Police: Woman at Walmart Yells, ‘Are You Ready to Die Tonight?’

Inset: Jamie Hurni (Portage Police Department). Background: The Walmart Supercenter in Portage,…

Caregiver Learns Sentence for Abusing Adult With Autism

Inset: Toyo Perez (Rock County District Attorney’s Office). Background: The Rock County…

Court Filing: Trump Defied Judge’s Order on Deposition Date

President Donald Trump speaks in the East Room of the White House…