For a decade, Charlotte Lister believed a hip replacement was inevitable. Even a short walk to the shops could leave the former Miss Great Britain finalist in severe pain, while nights were often almost impossible.
‘Driving was painful, walking was painful and cold weather made everything worse. I started to feel like an 80-year-old in a 40-year-old’s body,’ says Charlotte, now 39.
Although she repeatedly consulted her GP, she was reassured that there was nothing serious to worry about.
‘Sometimes I was in tears because it hurt so much. I was convinced I had arthritis and slept with a pregnancy pillow between my knees to take pressure off my hips.
‘I even wondered whether I should pay privately for a hip replacement.’
Earlier this year, however, Charlotte happened to see a different GP and was diagnosed with a separate, and often treatable, condition: bursitis.
Bursitis is inflammation of a bursa, one of the small, fluid-filled sacs that cushion bones and the tissues around them.
‘There are more than 150 bursae throughout the body,’ explains Caesar Wek, an NHS consultant orthopaedic hip and knee surgeon in Dorset. ‘They are found wherever tendons, muscles or skin move across bone.’
Charlotte Lister was a Miss Great Britain finalist and reached the Top 15
Repeated friction or pressure, an impact or fall, and less commonly inflammatory conditions such as gout or rheumatoid arthritis can irritate a bursa. The areas most often affected include the shoulder, the tip of the elbow, the front of the knee, the back of the heel and, in Charlotte’s case, the outer hip.
This condition, called trochanteric bursitis, affects the bursae positioned over the greater trochanter, the bony prominence that can be felt at the top of the thigh bone.
It ‘usually causes an aching or burning pain on the outside of the hip,’ says Mr Wek. ‘Sometimes the discomfort extends down the outer thigh towards the knee.’
‘People often say they cannot lie on the affected side at night because the pressure irritates the bursa and tendon.
‘Pain can also occur when getting up from a chair, climbing stairs, standing or walking for a long time. Pressing the bony point of the hip is usually very tender.’
Trochanteric bursitis is one of several conditions affecting the outer hip, thigh and buttock that are grouped under the term greater trochanteric pain syndrome, or GTPS.
GTPS also includes gluteal tendinopathy, in which the tendons attached to the deep buttock muscles become worn and sometimes partially torn. These muscles help keep the pelvis level when standing on one leg. ‘Without them, you would lurch sideways with every step,’ Mr Wek explains, which accounts for the characteristic gait.
‘It mainly affects people between 40 and 60, particularly those in their fifties, although it can also occur in younger, athletic people,’ he adds.
The tendon becomes frayed rather than inflamed, he says. Symptoms can resemble bursitis, but weakness is also common alongside pain on the outside of the hip.
Hormonal changes, especially falling oestrogen levels, may also contribute to GTPS because oestrogen is thought to help maintain tendon structure and function.
GTPS is widespread, says Professor Sion Glyn-Jones, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon at the Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre (NHS) and Nuffield Health Oxford. Research suggests that about one in five people experience its symptoms.
Because GTPS and hip osteoarthritis can produce similar symptoms, ‘patients and doctors confuse the two all the time,’ says Mr Wek.
‘Both can cause hip pain, a limp and difficulty on stairs, and both commonly begin between the ages of 40 and 60.’
There are, however, useful distinctions between the two conditions, he adds.
Hip osteoarthritis affects the ball-and-socket joint itself. As the cartilage wears away, the bones rub together, causing pain and restricting movement.
M Caesar Wek says bursitis can affect ‘younger, sporty people, particularly runners’
Charlotte’s hip problems started after she ran a half marathon in 2016
‘The pain is typically felt in the groin, although it can also affect the buttock, the front of the thigh or the knee,’ explains Mr Wek. ‘The hip becomes stiff, making it difficult to put on socks and shoes, cut toenails or get in and out of a car. Hip rotation may also be limited and painful.’
GTPS, by contrast, affects the tissues outside the joint. The pain is concentrated on the side of the hip, while the joint itself usually continues to move normally. Patients can generally still reach their feet.’
Bursitis can affect ‘younger, sporty people, especially runners,’ says Mr Wek. ‘Women are affected more often, by around three or four to one. The wider female pelvis means the tendon passes around the trochanter at a sharper angle, increasing compression. Hormonal changes during the menopause can also affect tendon quality.’
Charlotte’s symptoms began after she ran a half marathon in 2016.
‘At first I assumed it was normal post-race soreness, or perhaps that I had pulled a muscle in my hip,’ she says.
‘But the pain became worse over the following days. It began in my hip and travelled down towards my knee.’
Charlotte works in hotel management and lives in Nottinghamshire with her partner, Craig, 62, and her 15-year-old daughter. She visited her GP, who believed the race had caused an injury and advised rest along with heat or ice packs. ‘I followed that advice for days and then weeks, but the pain never went away,’ she says.
Over the following months, Charlotte repeatedly returned to her GP and was advised to take anti-inflammatory medication and continue using heat or ice.
‘Nothing improved, and I became frightened that I had caused permanent damage.’
When she finally saw another GP this year, he suggested that her symptoms sounded like bursitis. ‘I had never heard of it,’ she says. He told her she needed a steroid injection immediately.
‘The injection was extremely painful and made me cry out. The GP said that confirmed the diagnosis because the needle had reached the painful “spot” associated with the condition.’
‘Afterwards, I felt incredible. My hip was pain-free, I could move easily and all the discomfort had disappeared. It felt like a miracle. I was also hugely relieved to learn that I did not have arthritis and would not need surgery.’
Charlotte was also prescribed physiotherapy exercises designed to reduce inflammation and build strength.
Ideally, a steroid injection into the bursa should be guided by ultrasound, says Mr Wek. ‘It provides good short-term relief for most people and can interrupt the pain cycle, allowing them to take part in physiotherapy.’ However, the benefit usually fades after about three months. ‘Repeated steroid injections can weaken the tendon, so I use them sparingly,’ he adds.
For lasting improvement, ‘a structured programme combining education and exercise’ is essential, Matt Harrison, a spokesman for the Chartered Society of Physiotherapists, told the Daily Mail.
These programmes generally run for two to three months and aim to strengthen the hip muscles, improve movement patterns and stabilise the pelvis. Alongside physiotherapy, Mr Wek advises reducing pressure on the area by avoiding lying on the painful side, sitting cross-legged or standing with all the weight on one hip.
Shockwave therapy is another option. It uses sound waves to increase blood flow, encourage healing and reduce pain, and ‘has reasonable evidence behind it for chronic cases that have not responded to physiotherapy alone,’ says Mr Wek. ‘Surgery is reserved for the small number of people who remain affected after six to 12 months of appropriate non-operative treatment. One option is keyhole removal of the bursa.’
Professor Glyn-Jones says platelet-rich plasma, or PRP, is a newer treatment. It involves taking a patient’s blood and separating out the platelets, which contain growth factors that may stimulate healing.
He says: ‘Early studies produced encouraging findings, but more recent research has been less convincing. PRP remains an evolving treatment rather than an established one.’
At present, PRP treatment is available only privately.
After several weeks, the benefit of Charlotte’s steroid injection began to fade, as she had been warned it might. ‘My physiotherapy exercises provide some relief, but nowhere near as much as the injection. I’m now looking forward to having another one soon.’