Want to plant trees to offset fossil fuels? You'd need all of North and Central America, study finds
Share this @internewscast.com

While planting trees offers numerous advantages, this well-known strategy for removing carbon cannot single-handedly offset the greenhouse gas emissions generated by the biggest fossil-fuel corporations globally. To achieve this offset, an area equivalent to the entire land of North and Central America would need to be covered with trees, according to a recent study.

Esteemed climate scientists and organizations emphasize the importance of not only reducing carbon emissions but also actively removing them to effectively address climate change. Trees naturally remove carbon by “breathing,” or through photosynthesis. However, after analyzing the data, researchers concluded that the carbon-absorbing capacity of trees cannot match the emissions potential from the reserves of the top 200 fossil-fuel companies, as there simply isn’t enough suitable land available worldwide to make this viable.

Moreover, if it were theoretically possible, these 200 companies would face a cost of $10.8 trillion for planting such a vast number of trees, surpassing their total market value of $7.01 trillion. Additionally, if these companies were held accountable for the social costs associated with the carbon in their reserves, the expenses would outweigh their financial worth, given that scientists estimate the social cost at about $185 per metric ton of carbon dioxide.

“The general public maybe understand offsetting to be a sort of magic eraser, and that’s just not where we’re at,” said Nina Friggens, a research fellow at the University of Exeter who co-authored the paper published in Communications Earth & Environment, a Nature Portfolio journal.

Carbon offsetting essentially means investing in tree planting or other environmental projects to attempt to compensate for carbon emissions. Trees are one of the cheapest ways to do this because they naturally suck up planet-warming carbon. Fossil fuel corporations, along with other companies and institutions, have promoted tree-planting as key part of carbon offset programs in recent years.

For example, TotalEnergies, a global energy company, said in a statement that it is “investing heavily in carbon capture and storage (CCS) and nature-based solutions (NBS) projects.”

To do their calculations, the researchers looked at the 200 largest holders of fossil fuel reserves — the fuel that companies promise shareholders they can extract in the future — and calculated how much carbon dioxide would be released if this fuel is burned. The researchers also focused solely on tree planting because the expense and technological development needed for other forms of carbon capture are still mostly cost-prohibitive.

Forestry expert Éliane Ubalijoro, who was not involved with the research, called the study “elegant.”

It “gives people a sense of proportion around carbon,” said Ubalijoro, CEO of CIFOR-ICRAF, an international forestry research center.

But she cautioned against oversimplifying the equation by looking only at carbon capture, noting that tree planting done right can foster food security and biodiversity and protect communities from natural disasters.

The paper effectively makes the point that it’s financially impossible to offset enough carbon to compensate for future fossil fuel burning, said Daphne Yin, director of land policy at Carbon180, where her team advocates for U.S. policy support for land-based carbon removal. And the idea that companies would ever be required to account for the downstream emissions from the fossil fuel they extract is a “fantasy,” she said.

The idea of planting trees is appealing to the public and to politicians because it’s tangible — people can literally see the carbon being incorporated into branches and leaves as a tree grows, Friggens said. But she says other methods shouldn’t be overlooked — microbes underground store carbon too, but they can’t be seen.

And it’s a physically and mathematically inescapable fact, illustrated in part by this study, that there’s no getting around it — we have to stop emitting carbon, said Jonathan Foley, the executive director of Project Drawdown, who also was not part of the study. Carbon emissions are like an overflowing bathtub, he says: Before you start cleaning up, you have to turn off the water.

“Trees are the sponges and the mops we use to clean up the mess,” he said. “But if the taps are still running and the water’s pouring out over the edges of your bathtub, destroying your bathroom and your home, maybe you’ve got to learn to turn off the taps too.”

___

Follow Melina Walling on X @MelinaWalling and Bluesky @melinawalling.bsky.social.

___

The Associated Press’ climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP’s standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Whitney Purvis arrested: '16 and Pregnant' star charged with involuntary manslaughter

’16 and Pregnant’ Star Whitney Purvis Arrested for Involuntary Manslaughter

The former reality TV star’s arrest is linked to a man’s fatal…
Texas flooding: Death toll from catastrophic storm over the July Fourth weekend surpasses 100

Death Toll from Texas Flooding Over July Fourth Weekend Exceeds 100

The number of fatalities due to devastating floods in Texas over the…
Borussia Dortmund manager Niko Kovac rails against MetLife Stadium grass

Dortmund Coach Niko Kovac Criticizes MetLife Stadium Turf

The complaints about the MetLife Stadium field are unrelenting. German soccer club…
Chicago's bloody July Fourth weekend leaves 55 shot, 6 dead: report

Tragic July Fourth Weekend in Chicago: 55 Shot, 6 Killed

During a bloody Fourth of July weekend, more than 50 people were…
Mets can finally use ideal starting rotation to end first half

Mets Set to Utilize Perfect Pitching Lineup to Round Out Season’s First Half

On Sunday, Carlos Mendoza tried to keep his composure, but if there…
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu Nominates President Donald Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize

Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu Proposes Nobel Peace Prize for President Donald Trump

On Monday, President Donald Trump welcomed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to…
Federal agents conduct immigration raid in Los Angeles despite fierce opposition from Democrat mayor

Federal Agents Carry Out Immigration Raid in Los Angeles Amid Strong Opposition from Democratic Mayor

<!–> Tom Homan Denounces Criticism of ICE: ‘The Rhetoric Must End’ Fox…
Trump Slaps New Reciprocal Tariffs on Imports From Japan, South Korea, Gives Both Countries a Deadline

Trump Imposes New Reciprocal Tariffs on Japanese and South Korean Imports, Sets Deadline for Compliance

President Donald Trump on Monday announced his administration will impose “reciprocal” 25…
Two people wearing masks greet each other at a doorway.
THIS is the chilling moment murderer Erin Patterson discharges herself from hospital…
US adults want the government to focus on child care costs, not birth rates, AP-NORC poll finds

AP-NORC Poll Reveals US Adults Prioritize Child Care Costs Over Birth Rates

WASHINGTON (AP) — As the Trump administration considers strategies to motivate more…
TSA ends shoe removal at select US airports: Reports

TSA Discontinues Shoe Removal at Specific US Airports: Reports

The TSA has not officially announced the change. WASHINGTON — The Transportation…
Chicago mass shooting: $10K offered for information after 18 shot, 4 killed in River North outside Artis, party for Mello Buckzz

Reward Offered After 18 People Shot, 4 Fatally, in River North Chicago Shooting Near Artis; $10K Offered for Tips

CHICAGO (WLS) — A reward is being offered for any information regarding…