NEW YORK – A federal appeals court is considering whether it can — or ought to — intervene in President Donald Trump’s hush money case as a New York appellate court weighs his effort to overturn his historic conviction.
A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals questioned Trump’s attorney and a state prosecutor for more than an hour Monday over Trump’s latest attempt to move the case from state court to federal court. Such a transfer could allow him to seek dismissal based on presidential immunity. The judges did not immediately issue a ruling.
The arguments marked the second court hearing in 11 days as Trump pursues a two-track legal strategy to invalidate the May 2024 verdict. A New York jury found him guilty on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records to conceal a $130,000 payment to adult film performer Stormy Daniels.
At the same time, the Republican president is pursuing a conventional appeal through New York’s state court system. That case was argued before the mid-level Appellate Division on Nov. 5, and the court has not yet ruled.
Whatever the courts decide, Trump will remain permanently linked to a case that went to trial while he was campaigning to return to the White House. He denies any wrongdoing and received no punishment. With a little more than two years remaining in his presidency, Trump continues to fight to shed the distinction of being the first U.S. president convicted of a crime.
Trump’s lawyer says the case could reach the Supreme Court
Trump attorney Robert Giuffra Jr. asked the 2nd Circuit on Monday to act quickly, potentially issuing an order before its full opinion is completed. He wants the court to take control of the case and halt proceedings before the Appellate Division.
Without federal intervention, Trump “will likely have to wait years” for the state appellate courts to act before seeking review by the U.S. Supreme Court, Giuffra wrote in a letter outlining his position.
Judges John M. Walker Jr. and Chief Judge Raymond J. Lohier Jr. expressed skepticism. Walker was appointed to the appeals court by his cousin, President George H.W. Bush, while Lohier was appointed by President Barack Obama.
“How does that work?” Walker asked. “I mean, assuming we were to agree with you, there’s been an argument in the Appellate Division. Briefs have been filed in the Appellate Division. Will those briefs be refiled by everybody here?”
Federal law does not clearly explain how such a transfer would proceed.
Giuffra said the case would likely first return to a federal district judge, who would adopt the state court’s verdict. The matter could then come back to the 2nd Circuit for arguments over whether presidential immunity requires dismissal. The existing briefs, he said, would remain in place with only their covers changed.
“You’re asking us to embrace an entire procedural mechanism that I don’t see anywhere authorized by Congress,” Lohier said.
“We think it is authorized,” Giuffra replied. He described a legal provision permitting post-verdict transfer petitions as “a safety valve that’s intended to protect against exactly the gamesmanship that’s gone on here.”
A federal judge rejected Trump’s transfer bid three times
Trump turned to the 2nd Circuit after a federal judge ruled against him for a third time in August. Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, who died last month at age 92, wrote that “paying hush money to an adult film star or engaging in a cover-up of an embarrassment are not subsumed in presidential immunity.”
Trump first asked to transfer the case to federal court several weeks after his March 2023 indictment. He renewed the request after his conviction and after the Supreme Court’s July 2024 ruling that presidents and former presidents are shielded from prosecution for official acts, and that prosecutors may not use official acts as evidence that unofficial conduct was criminal.
Giuffra told both the state and federal appellate courts that prosecutors introduced evidence of official acts that the Supreme Court’s immunity ruling later barred. He cited testimony about Trump’s Oval Office conversations, workflow and social media posts.
He also challenged prosecutors’ characterization of the hush money payment as an illegal campaign contribution under the Federal Election Campaign Act. Giuffra argued that claims involving that federal law should be heard in federal court rather than in state court.
After Trump appealed Hellerstein’s second rejection, the 2nd Circuit ordered the judge to reconsider, concluding that he had not adequately addressed “important issues relevant” to Trump’s transfer request.
That panel, which also included Lohier, did not indicate how Hellerstein should rule. It directed him, however, to examine more closely evidence Trump identified as involving official acts and whether he could claim those actions were performed as part of his presidential responsibilities.
Steven Wu, chief of the appeals division in the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office, urged the 2nd Circuit to uphold Hellerstein’s decision and keep the case in state court. Even if Trump ultimately succeeds, Wu argued, the state appellate court would still retain authority to issue its own ruling.