2 men who served 15 years in prison for crime they were later acquitted of file civil rights lawsuit against 3 Cleveland officers, Cuyahoga County
Share this @internewscast.com

Kenny Phillips, Michael Sutton, and their lawyers claim authorities hid evidence that would have proved their innocence in a 2006 shooting.

CLEVELAND — Two men from Cleveland are bringing a lawsuit against three current or former Cleveland police officers and Cuyahoga County after spending more than a decade behind bars for a crime they always maintained they did not commit.

Kenny Phillips, Michael Sutton, and their lawyers at Friedman, Gilbert + Gerhardstein filed the federal civil rights suit on Wednesday, a year to the day after the men were found not guilty of the crimes they had originally been indicted and imprisoned for.

According to attorney Sarah Gelsomino, the lawsuit names three officers who were involved in the case in 2006, whom she said “were involved in fabricating claims against them, completely fabricating evidence against them, just making up stories about something that never happened.”

According to the lawsuit, in May of 2006, Phillips and Sutton were pulled over and arrested after witnessing a shooting ahead of them on the road. The lawsuit alleges that defendants — Daniel Lentz and Michael Keane — fabricated evidence linking Phillips and Sutton to the crime, and further contends Carl Hartman suppressed evidence. Lentz and Keane are still with the Cleveland Division of Police, while Hartman is no longer with the department.

Additionally, the filing names Cuyahoga County as a defendant for the “practices maintained by the prosecutor’s office,” including withholding evidence of Phillips and Sutton’s purported innocence, according to Gelsomino.

Phillips and Sutton were arrested for attempted murder, among other charges, and eventually convicted. After exculpatory evidence was uncovered in 2015, there was a new trial in September 2022, and this time, the pair were acquitted on all counts.

“In this case, Kenny and Michael now are saying, ‘These officers are responsible, this prosecutor’s office is responsible, and now they need to account for their wrongdoing that accounted for their wrongful conviction,'” Gelsomino stated.

“We’re thankful for the freedom, but it’s like now, who do we hold accountable for what we’ve been through?” asked Sutton. “I got arrested on stage. I had a full ride to college, so you all really took my life away from me.”

“I feel robbed, for sure,” Phillips added. “They knew —they held all the evidence from day one. They knew from day one that we [didn’t] do this.”

A state level case is also underway for wrongful imprisonment, with the aim of having the two men officially declared wrongfully imprisoned in order to seek financial compensation.

There’s not a breath that they take or other exonerees take that is not impacted by the trauma of having been ripped off the streets and thrown into prison wrongfully, and that’s what this federal case is about,” Gelsomino said. “And it’s about saying that that’s a result of misconduct or wrongdoing.”

3News reached out to the City of Cleveland, are received the following response: “Our policy is to refrain from commenting on pending/open legal matters.”

We also reached out to the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s Office. Communications Manager Lexi Bauer shared the following statement:

“The Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s Office does not have a policy of withholding evidence. In fact, since 2009, our office has provided open discovery on all criminal cases. Our office did this prior to the Criminal Rule 16 amendment that required open discovery, which became effective on July 1, 2010. We were one of the first counties in Ohio to do so. In addition, this office pioneered an electronic process for open discovery utilizing a web-based system.

“The Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s Office has prosecuted more than 200,000 cases since the Sutton and Phillips case was tried in 2006. With so few cases overturned, it is abundantly clear that the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s Office operates in an exemplary manner in the prosecution of criminal cases.

“Due to pending litigation, we decline to comment further.”

Share this @internewscast.com
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Who was Tiffany Valiante and what happened to her?

THE YOUNG woman was only 18 years old when she suffered an…

Oceanarium helps to keep Bowie the Lobster alive

It’s a race to keep Bowie the Lobster alive as freshwater floods…

Fairytale of New York singer Shane MacGowan dies aged 65 after an eight-year health battle – and just three days after his wife shared wedding photo to celebrate five year anniversary

The Pogues’ frontman Shane MacGowan has died aged 65.  The legendary Irish…

Tucker Carlson reveals he's 'flattered' by rumors he will be on the Trump 2024 ticket as his running mate – but says the chances are similar to 'an asteroid striking the Earth'

Tucker Carlson on Thursday laughed off speculation that Donald Trump could choose…

Hamas claims Israel is still refusing to accept its offer of repatriating the dead bodies of the Bibas family – including 10-month-old Kfir – before sharing sick video of distressed father Yarden Bibas in captivity

Hamas has claimed Israel is refusing to take back the bodies of the…

Cleveland Hopkins International Airport needs airline buy-in for proposed terminal overhaul

Increasing construction costs have contributed to the rising price of the project,…

Von Miller was investigated for domestic violence 2 years before his arrest warrant for ‘assault on pregnant girlfriend’

NFL star Von Miller was previously investigated for a domestic violence claim…

British Air-Warfare Destroyer HMS Diamond Deployed to Gulf

AFP — Britain on Thursday announced that it was sending one of its…

OHSAA football championships in Canton: Breaking down the matchups involving Northeast Ohio high schools

Seven area teams have made it to the final round, with Division…

Emergency vehicles can't reach our homes – now we're being threatened with court action: Furious villagers on crumbling coast slam council for abandoning their homes – as they're left stranded after access road collapses following a land slip

Astonished residents of a dramatically eroding coastal village have attacked a council…

NBC News Correspondent Antonia Hylton Shares Details Of Her Cancer Journey

NBC News correspondent Antonia Hylton has revealed that she was diagnosed with…

Foreign-Born Population Hits 49.5M Under Biden – Largest Ever in U.S. History

The nation’s foreign-born population has hit an unprecedented 49.5 million, the largest…