Sweet potato fries have secured a reputation as the virtuous choice, appearing on restaurant menus and supermarket shelves as an apparently healthier alternative to ordinary French fries.
Their bright orange colour, naturally sweet taste and impressive nutritional profile make it easy to believe that choosing sweet potatoes is automatically the smarter option.
But do they really deserve their healthy reputation? Or are we simply reassuring ourselves when we order them with a burger, convinced we have made the better choice?
The answer is more nuanced than it may seem.
Although sweet potatoes have some nutritional advantages over regular potatoes, experts say the preparation method and cooking oil can make a substantial difference.
Once deep-fried, a serving of sweet potato fries may have far more in common with traditional chips than their health-food image suggests.
So, are sweet potato fries genuinely the healthier side dish, or have regular French fries been unfairly criticised? We asked nutritionists to settle the great chip debate.
Are sweet potato fries really the healthier side dish?
What’s in sweet potato fries?
Native to tropical parts of Central and South America, sweet potatoes are not technically potatoes. They are root vegetables.
Their high vitamin content and relatively low calorie count have made them popular around the world, where they are often promoted as a healthier alternative to traditional russet potato chips.
Sweet potatoes are rich in beta-carotene, an antioxidant that the body converts into vitamin A. This vitamin supports healthy eyesight, the immune system and skin health.
Research shows that a single medium sweet potato can provide more than the recommended daily amount of vitamin A.
They are also a useful source of fibre, which supports digestion, helps maintain regular bowel movements and may keep you feeling full for longer.
Sweet potatoes contain vitamin C, which is involved in collagen production and immune function, as well as potassium, a mineral that helps regulate blood pressure and supports normal muscle function.
They also supply vitamin B6 and manganese, both of which contribute to the body’s metabolism.
Like conventional French fries, sweet potato fries are cut into thin strips, cooked until golden brown and commonly served with ketchup and mayonnaise.
Are they a healthier alternative to traditional chips?
Despite the sweet potato’s nutritional benefits, experts say its fried form is not automatically the healthier choice.
Rob Hobson, a registered nutritionist and author of Unprocess Your Life, says the popular side dish has acquired what he calls a “health halo”.
“Both sweet potato and regular fries are sources of carbohydrate, and once they are deep-fried, they can contain similar amounts of calories and fat,” he explains.
“That means a great deal depends on how they are prepared, how much oil they absorb and the size of the portion.
DISCOVER MORE: Meet Peter Dager: The Actor Behind Santi in ‘Stick’ on Apple TV+
“The main nutritional advantage of sweet potatoes is their beta-carotene content, which gives them their orange colour.
“The body converts this into vitamin A, which is important for healthy vision, immune function and skin. They also provide fibre and potassium, although regular potatoes contain these nutrients too, along with vitamin B6 and some vitamin C.”
Mr Hobson says it is also a misconception that sweet potato fries are necessarily better for blood sugar because they have a lower glycaemic index, which measures how quickly food raises blood glucose.
How potatoes are prepared is central to their nutritional value, nutritionist Rob Hobson said
In reality, the issue is more complicated, Mr Hobson says.
“The glycaemic index of both types of potato varies according to how they are cooked, and both provide carbohydrates that are broken down into glucose,” he says.
Portion size and the other foods in the meal can also affect the body’s blood sugar response.
Eating sweet potato fries with protein, such as chicken, fish or eggs, and healthy fats may slow digestion and help moderate the rise in blood glucose, Mr Hobson says.
The belief that sweet potatoes are much higher in fibre—the important nutrient associated with a lower risk of bowel cancer and reduced cholesterol—is not entirely accurate either.
A serving contains only slightly more fibre than French fries, by around 0.2g, while skin-on fries contain marginally more.
Mr Hobson also warns that sweet potato fries are not automatically lower in calories.
“If you compare two similar portions cooked in the same way, the difference in calories may be relatively small,” he says.
“Some commercially prepared sweet potato fries also contain added coatings to help them become crisp, so check the ingredients and nutrition information instead of assuming they are the healthier choice.
“The cooking method probably makes the biggest difference. Baking or air-frying either variety with a small amount of oil will generally produce a lower-fat option than deep-frying.
“I would choose whichever one you enjoy most. Both can form part of a healthy diet, and portion size, cooking method and what you eat with them are likely to matter more than the type of potato.”
So, how do sweet potato fries compare with the alternatives?
We compiled the following nutritional information for a range of fry options:
| Type | Calories | Fat | Carbohydrates | Fibre | Salt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| French fries | 290 | 14.2g | 39.7g | 3.8g | 0.5g |
| Skin-on fries | 155 | 3g | 34.7g | 4.2g | 0.2g |
| Chip-shop chips | 214 | 8.4g | 33.2g | 3.2g | 0.1g |
| Triple-cooked chips | 180 | 6.5g | 26.3g | 3.3g | 0.4g |
| Oven chips | 190 | 5g | 35.3g | 3.5g | 0.1g |
| Sweet potato fries | 153 | 0.8g | 36.6g | 4g | 0.2g |
Sweet potato fries have the lowest calorie count in this comparison. However, Mr Hobson points out that the figures represent an average product and do not include varieties with additional coatings.
Skin-on fries, made with unpeeled potatoes, are also relatively low in calories because their larger surface area absorbs less oil than thinner fries.
French fries and chip-shop chips are among the highest in fat and calories, while French fries contain the most salt.
Mr Hobson adds: “It is important to remember that chips are a side dish, not a major source of nutrition. The overall quality of the meal—including what you serve alongside them—is what matters most.”