Share this @internewscast.com

Australia’s special envoy to address antisemitism, Jillian Segal, has rejected criticism regarding the antisemitism definition used in a proposed government plan she recommends implementing.
Albanese indicates he will evaluate the plan’s recommendations but has not fully committed to them.
The report utilizes an antisemitism definition from the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), authored by United States historian Kenneth Stern.

Stern has since distanced himself from the definition, contending that it overly conflates criticism of Zionism and Israel with antisemitism.

International human rights organisation Amnesty International said it rejects the IHRA definition “that has been widely criticised for being used to silence legitimate criticism of Israel’s genocide against Palestinians, and its abhorrent human rights record”.

“The IHRA definition empowers governments to suppress rising opposition to Israel’s ongoing genocide in Gaza, its harsh and unlawful occupation, and its apartheid system, which is a crime against humanity,” the group stated.

Divide over report’s antisemitism definition

Some have raised concerns the definition used could be “inappropriate” for the government to adopt into law and lead to heavy-handed silencing of free speech and criticism of actions of the state of Israel.
Segal said those critics misunderstood the definition.
“The train has moved on, if I might put it that way, and Kenneth Stern has been left behind,” she told ABC Radio National on Friday.

“The definition explicitly states that criticizing Israel is permissible, and indeed many Israelis criticize their own government’s policies. However, advocating for the elimination of the state of Israel is antisemitic.”

Max Kaiser, executive officer of the Jewish Council of Australia — a progressive group critical of Israel’s actions in Gaza — labelled Segal’s report a “blueprint for silencing dissent” and his organisation said the emphasis on surveillance, censorship and punitive control over funding was “straight out of [Donald] Trump’s authoritarian playbook”.
Other Jewish groups, including the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ) and the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council have called for the plan to be adopted in full.
“Its release could not be more timely given the recent appalling events in Melbourne. The actions which the plan call for are now urgently needed,” ECAJ president Daniel Aghion said in a statement.
“We call upon all sectors of society, including government, law enforcement, the media, the university sector, education authorities and online platform providers, to co-operate with the Special Envoy and the Jewish community to give this action plan full force and effect.”

IHRA’s definition, finalised in 2016, states: “Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities.”

Definition is ‘vague and overbroard’, legal expert says

Ben Saul — chair of international law at the University of Sydney, and UN special rapporteur on human rights and counter terrorism — said the definition is “inappropriate … vague and overbroad” and “not workable”.
“It’s not consistent with international human rights law because it imposes excessive restrictions on legitimate freedom of expression,” he told SBS News.
“The definition was never intended to be a legal or regulatory enforcement tool. It was only designed to be a monitoring and awareness-raising tool.”
Saul said the definition provides examples that would likely be misinterpreted and if they became legally binding in Australia would lead to punishment of “legitimate freedom of expression”.
“The International Court of Justice has said there is racial segregation or apartheid happening in Israel’s occupied territories, and the IHRA definition says you can’t call Israel a racist endeavour. So that’s clearly a contradiction with well-accepted international human rights standards,” Saul said.
An advisory opinion handed down by the International Court of Justice last July found Israel is depriving Palestinians “of the enjoyment of the natural resources of the territory” and “diverting a large share of the natural resources to its own population”, which it said was “tantamount to the crime of apartheid”.

Israel has repeatedly rejected this claim.

It recommends strengthening legislation to counter “hateful and intimidating conduct”, including serious vilification offences, the public promotion of antisemitic sentiment, and the display of Nazi symbols. A national database would be created to ensure consistent recording of antisemitic crimes.
Per the report, the envoy will develop a “university report card” to assess how institutions respond to incidents and implement preventative measures. Universities that fail to act could face cuts to government funding.
Universities Australia committed to considering the report’s recommendations.
Saul said universities are already taking antisemitism “incredibly seriously” and in some cases people are already afraid to speak out on the war in Gaza because they’re unclear what constitutes free speech.
— With additional reporting by the Australian Associated Press.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Hannah Thomas’ attorney claims police assaulted her and legal action may be pursued.

Lawyers for a former Greens candidate who suffered a serious eye injury…
Kathleen Folbigg stuck in 'limbo' over wrongful conviction payment

Kathleen Folbigg Awaits Resolution on Compensation for Wrongful Conviction

An Australian woman, exonerated from charges of killing her four children, finds…
Trump drops the hammer on Putin with incredible threat

Trump Issues Strong Threat Against Putin

US President Donald Trump has escalated his approach towards Russia by threatening…
Australian travellers warned over high passport costs

Australian Travelers Alerted to Elevated Passport Fees

As the cold of winter sets in, those eager for a trip…
President Donald Trump talks to reporters as he walks on the South Lawn upon arriving at the White House, Sunday, July 13, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)

Government Continues Its Efforts to Engage with Trump

Jim Chalmers has not been able to confirm whether a meeting has…
Epstein fallout poses a loyalty test: Trump — or MAGA?

The Epstein Scandal: A Loyalty Dilemma Between Trump and MAGA

It’s President Donald Trump versus MAGA. In the days since the Trump…
Kalyn Ponga could be set to leave the Newcastle Knights at the end of the 2025 NRL season

Stunning Update on Kalyn Ponga’s Rugby League Career

Kalyn Ponga is reportedly contemplating a move away from the Newcastle Knights…

Envoy Handling Antisemitism Issues Clarifies Lack of Role in Husband’s Donation to Anti-Immigrant Organization

The federal government’s special envoy to combat antisemitism, Jillian Segal, has distanced…
'Stupid and reckless': Killer struck elderly man then left him to die at roadside

Negligent Actions: Killer Hit Elderly Man and Abandoned Him at Roadside

A killer could be out of jail within two years after admitting…

Chris anticipates his ‘liquid gold’ will advance equality after decades of prohibition

Chris Steel hasn’t relaxed in a donor lounge chair for many years.…
Catrin, a 22-year-old outdoor instructor, left her job in Malvern, England, and relocated to Motutapu Island, situated near Auckland, New Zealand, where she spent nine months working in an outdoor recreation centre

Why I Left the UK for a Remote Island Life: Limited Excursions and Few Activities, Yet Total Bliss

A Welsh expat has shared the benefits and drawbacks of remote living…

Tour de France: Heartbreak for Australian Cyclists as They Fall Short of Podium in Stage 10 Finish

Ben O’Connor and Michael Storer have narrowly missed out on a podium…