New Zealand media outlets responded angrily after Wales stunned their much-fancied side in Cardiff, ending a decades-long wait for victory over the All Blacks.
The New Zealand Herald compared Wales to “the appendix of Britain” and mocked the country’s fondness for fish finger sandwiches, while radio presenter Scotty Stevenson went even further by describing the Welsh team as “dog s***”.
The Herald column was written by Scottish journalist Gregor Paul and was later condemned by Wales Online as an example of “true contempt”.
The comments provoked fury in Wales, although Steve Tandy’s team had already delivered the perfect response on the field, beating New Zealand 35-28 and ending a 73-year losing run against the All Blacks.
In the aftermath, the New Zealand Herald published a particularly sour assessment of the result, asking whether Wales’ victory might have been little more than a “pity win”.
“Could it have been a pity win? Maybe a country whose rugby team has declined in alignment with its post-industrialisation economic demise, won favour with the gods,” the article stated.
“The Welsh, the appendix of Britain in that a once important economic contributor to the United Kingdom ecosystem no longer knows its function, need their spirits lifted.
“They only see the sun twice a year, have come to view fish finger sandwiches as a delicacy worthy of being on brasserie menus and they are gripped by a crippling fabric shortage which leaves everyone barely covered when they head out for a Friday night drink.”
Wales’ stunning rugby victory over New Zealand prompted a furious reaction from sections of the losing country’s media
The New Zealand Herald published a scathing column about Wales after the All Blacks’ long unbeaten run against the Red Dragons came to an end
“Maybe, but again, it’s not a convincing explanation for what happened.
“This is the one loss where it is legitimate to view it only through the lens of something having gone catastrophically wrong for the All Blacks.
“The sense of entitlement New Zealanders feel about the All Blacks winning was not misplaced in Cardiff. This one doesn’t make sense. It doesn’t fit into the data set at all.
“Wales were 10th in the world, and while the ranking system is a nonsense in many respects, this was a fair reflection of their true position. Since the 2023 World Cup, they had won only six games, against Italy, Japan and Georgia.
“Maybe it was simply sport at its brilliant, unpredictable and magical best. Wales defended heroically, attacked with clarity and purpose, and made intelligent decisions throughout.
“It was one of those rare occasions when a team draws absolutely everything from itself, using every ounce of talent, resilience and courage available. The All Blacks, meanwhile, came nowhere close to fulfilling their potential.”
Radio host Scotty Stevenson also urged listeners not to overreact to the result during an appearance on Sport Nation.
“I would urge some caution here. Yes, they have beaten the All Blacks, and yes, they have done so for the first time in 73 years,” he said.
“But I’m just wondering: are you prepared to say one team is a world-beater and the other is dog s***?”
New Zealand had not beaten Wales since 1953, but the hosts produced an electric performance on Saturday
“The word might be harsh, but let’s look at the Welsh record before that game.
“I stand by exactly what I said. They have pulled an iron out of the fire here, and that is why this result has become such a major talking point.
“It is not simply that Wales beat the All Blacks; it is that this Welsh team managed to do it. Think of the players and teams who have tried and failed over the past 73 years.
“Six Nations champions, Grand Slam winners. Adam Jones, Gareth Thomas, Gethin Jenkins, Sam Warburton, Alun Wyn Jones. Do I need to go on? I mean, come on, team.”
The remarks quickly drew a hostile response from Welsh supporters, many of whom took to X to criticise the tone of the New Zealand coverage.
“Quite frankly appalled at their denigration of the sacred fish finger sandwich,” one person wrote.
Another replied: “Sounds more like a description of New Zealand than Wales.”
A third commentator said: “I feel like New Zealand is probably the very last country that should be making these digs. They have so little besides rugby that I start to worry about the effect on the national psyche once the All Blacks are no longer a top-three team, which could happen in any decade now.”
Another post read: “Quite a stance for a Kiwi to take, from a country that, to most of the world, is indistinguishable from Australia.”
One final critic summed up the reaction by writing: “What an ugly article. It says far more about the writer than it does about the Welsh.”